🧵 Why Farmers Can’t Sell You Meat Straight From Their Land
The story behind how it became illegal for farmers to sell home-processed meat in America.
1️⃣ It wasn’t always illegal.
Before 1906, farmers could raise an animal, butcher it, and sell meat directly to neighbors, towns, or local butchers.
There were no federal rules governing meat sales: only local ordinances or state guidelines.
But as industrialization boomed, huge packing plants in cities like Chicago took over most meat production.
This shift from local to factory-scale processing changed everything.
The story behind how it became illegal for farmers to sell home-processed meat in America.
1️⃣ It wasn’t always illegal.
Before 1906, farmers could raise an animal, butcher it, and sell meat directly to neighbors, towns, or local butchers.
There were no federal rules governing meat sales: only local ordinances or state guidelines.
But as industrialization boomed, huge packing plants in cities like Chicago took over most meat production.
This shift from local to factory-scale processing changed everything.
2️⃣ The book that shook the nation.
In 1906, journalist Upton Sinclair published The Jungle.
He meant to expose worker exploitation in Chicago’s meatpacking plants, but what horrified readers was the description of rats, filth, and spoiled meat being ground into sausages.
Public outrage exploded.
President Theodore Roosevelt, though skeptical of Sinclair’s politics, ordered his own federal investigation, and it confirmed much of the unsanitary truth.
In 1906, journalist Upton Sinclair published The Jungle.
He meant to expose worker exploitation in Chicago’s meatpacking plants, but what horrified readers was the description of rats, filth, and spoiled meat being ground into sausages.
Public outrage exploded.
President Theodore Roosevelt, though skeptical of Sinclair’s politics, ordered his own federal investigation, and it confirmed much of the unsanitary truth.
3️⃣ The government’s reaction, sweeping reform.
Under massive public pressure, Roosevelt and Congress acted fast.
Two laws passed within days of each other:
The Federal Meat Inspection Act (FMIA) June 30, 1906
The Pure Food and Drug Act June 30, 1906
Under massive public pressure, Roosevelt and Congress acted fast.
Two laws passed within days of each other:
The Federal Meat Inspection Act (FMIA) June 30, 1906
The Pure Food and Drug Act June 30, 1906
These laws marked the birth of modern food regulation in the United States.
The FMIA made it illegal to sell meat that hadn’t been inspected in a federally approved slaughter and processing facility.
The goal was to clean up the industry and protect consumers from contaminated meat.
The FMIA made it illegal to sell meat that hadn’t been inspected in a federally approved slaughter and processing facility.
The goal was to clean up the industry and protect consumers from contaminated meat.
4️⃣ The intent vs. the impact.
The FMIA was aimed squarely at industrial packers like Armour, Swift, and Morris, not small farmers.
But the law didn’t make a distinction.
Every business selling meat had to comply with the same inspection rules, even the small, rural butcher who slaughtered five cows a year.
It required USDA inspectors to be physically present, meaning only large, centralized plants could afford to operate.
Over time, this forced thousands of small processors out of business, not because of poor quality, but because of cost and bureaucracy.
The FMIA was aimed squarely at industrial packers like Armour, Swift, and Morris, not small farmers.
But the law didn’t make a distinction.
Every business selling meat had to comply with the same inspection rules, even the small, rural butcher who slaughtered five cows a year.
It required USDA inspectors to be physically present, meaning only large, centralized plants could afford to operate.
Over time, this forced thousands of small processors out of business, not because of poor quality, but because of cost and bureaucracy.
5️⃣ The monopoly years and the next law.
After World War I, the U.S. meat industry was dominated by the “Big Five”: Armour, Swift, Morris, Wilson, and Cudahy.
They controlled livestock markets, prices, and distribution across the country.
Farmers had little power, they sold animals into a system they couldn’t influence.
In response, Congress passed the Packers and Stockyards Act (PSA) in 1921.
This law aimed to stop price manipulation, collusion, and monopolistic control.
It gave the USDA authority to regulate the business practices of packers and livestock dealers.
The PSA helped curb abuse, but it didn’t change how meat was processed or who could sell it.
The inspection rules from 1906 stayed firmly in place.
After World War I, the U.S. meat industry was dominated by the “Big Five”: Armour, Swift, Morris, Wilson, and Cudahy.
They controlled livestock markets, prices, and distribution across the country.
Farmers had little power, they sold animals into a system they couldn’t influence.
In response, Congress passed the Packers and Stockyards Act (PSA) in 1921.
This law aimed to stop price manipulation, collusion, and monopolistic control.
It gave the USDA authority to regulate the business practices of packers and livestock dealers.
The PSA helped curb abuse, but it didn’t change how meat was processed or who could sell it.
The inspection rules from 1906 stayed firmly in place.
6️⃣ The 1967 turning point — Wholesome Meat Act.
By the 1960s, only federally inspected meat could be sold across state lines, but some states still allowed local intrastate sales without USDA inspection.
That changed in 1967, when Congress passed the Wholesome Meat Act, signed by President Lyndon B. Johnson.
This law required every state to adopt meat inspection standards “equal to” federal regulations or turn over authority to the USDA.
Nearly all did — and that’s when it became effectively illegal for a farmer to sell home-butchered meat anywhere in the U.S. unless it went through an inspected plant.
Even if a farmer butchered on their own property safely, they couldn’t legally sell a single cut to a neighbor.
By the 1960s, only federally inspected meat could be sold across state lines, but some states still allowed local intrastate sales without USDA inspection.
That changed in 1967, when Congress passed the Wholesome Meat Act, signed by President Lyndon B. Johnson.
This law required every state to adopt meat inspection standards “equal to” federal regulations or turn over authority to the USDA.
Nearly all did — and that’s when it became effectively illegal for a farmer to sell home-butchered meat anywhere in the U.S. unless it went through an inspected plant.
Even if a farmer butchered on their own property safely, they couldn’t legally sell a single cut to a neighbor.
8️⃣ States start fighting back.
In recent years, several states have passed “Food Freedom” or “Herd Share” laws to bring back some control to small farmers.
Wyoming led the way in 2015, allowing direct-to-consumer meat sales through herd-share models.
South Dakota, Colorado, and Maine have followed with similar measures.
These laws let consumers buy directly from farmers they trust, bypassing federal middlemen, though they still operate within limited exemptions.
In recent years, several states have passed “Food Freedom” or “Herd Share” laws to bring back some control to small farmers.
Wyoming led the way in 2015, allowing direct-to-consumer meat sales through herd-share models.
South Dakota, Colorado, and Maine have followed with similar measures.
These laws let consumers buy directly from farmers they trust, bypassing federal middlemen, though they still operate within limited exemptions.
7️⃣ The system today.
Modern federal law (under the FMIA and Wholesome Meat Act) allows only three main types of meat processing:
USDA-inspected: can be sold anywhere in the U.S.
State-inspected (equal-to): can be sold within that state only.
Custom-exempt: for the owner’s personal use — not for sale.
That means if a farmer sells you meat from an animal slaughtered at a “custom” processor, it’s technically illegal unless you legally owned part of the animal before slaughter (like in a herd share).
Modern federal law (under the FMIA and Wholesome Meat Act) allows only three main types of meat processing:
USDA-inspected: can be sold anywhere in the U.S.
State-inspected (equal-to): can be sold within that state only.
Custom-exempt: for the owner’s personal use — not for sale.
That means if a farmer sells you meat from an animal slaughtered at a “custom” processor, it’s technically illegal unless you legally owned part of the animal before slaughter (like in a herd share).
9️⃣ The legacy.
The 1906 laws were born from real public health crises and corporate corruption, and they did make food safer.
But over time, they also centralized meat production in the hands of a few corporations.
Today, four companies: JBS, Tyson, Cargill, and National Beef, control about 85% of U.S. beef processing.
That’s a direct descendant of those early inspection laws meant to protect the public.
The 1906 laws were born from real public health crises and corporate corruption, and they did make food safer.
But over time, they also centralized meat production in the hands of a few corporations.
Today, four companies: JBS, Tyson, Cargill, and National Beef, control about 85% of U.S. beef processing.
That’s a direct descendant of those early inspection laws meant to protect the public.
🔟 The takeaway.
The laws that made meat “safe” also made it nearly impossible for local farmers to sell it directly.
A book meant to expose exploitation ended up reshaping the food system for a century.
And while the intent was good, the impact has been consolidation, lost local control, and fewer choices for farmers and consumers.
The laws that made meat “safe” also made it nearly impossible for local farmers to sell it directly.
A book meant to expose exploitation ended up reshaping the food system for a century.
And while the intent was good, the impact has been consolidation, lost local control, and fewer choices for farmers and consumers.
Sanitation contractor: In 2023, a U.S. Department of Labor (DOL) investigation found that PSSI employed more than 100 children (ages 13 to 17) to work overnight cleaning shifts in 13 meatpacking plants across eight states.
Children at Tyson plants: The DOL report specifically noted that seven of those minors were employed by PSSI at two Tyson facilities in Arkansas and Tennessee.
Hazardous conditions: The jobs involved dangerous, hazardous tasks. News reports revealed that some of these children were migrant minors who had arrived in the U.S. alone.
Whistleblower allegations: In 2024, a former Tyson employee and a U.S. Senator alleged that the company used a third-party contractor to employ children in a processing plant. The whistleblower claimed that Tyson took retaliatory action after they reported the issue.
Children at Tyson plants: The DOL report specifically noted that seven of those minors were employed by PSSI at two Tyson facilities in Arkansas and Tennessee.
Hazardous conditions: The jobs involved dangerous, hazardous tasks. News reports revealed that some of these children were migrant minors who had arrived in the U.S. alone.
Whistleblower allegations: In 2024, a former Tyson employee and a U.S. Senator alleged that the company used a third-party contractor to employ children in a processing plant. The whistleblower claimed that Tyson took retaliatory action after they reported the issue.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
