Share this page!

Enter URL or ID to Unroll

You can paste full URL like: https://x.com/threadreaderapp/status/1644127596119195649
or just the ID like: 1644127596119195649

How to get URL link on X (Twitter) App

  1. On the Twitter thread, click on or icon on the bottom
  2. Click again on or Share Via icon
  3. Click on Copy Link to Tweet
  4. Paste it above and click "Unroll Thread"!
  5. More info at Twitter Help
WhiteMinaret Profile picture
@whiteminaret1
Nov 4, 2025 • 6 tweets • 3 min read • Read on X
Scrolly
🧵 Is there Ijma' that Isa AS is alive?

Some Muslims claim there's consensus that Jesus AS is still alive & that denying it is Kufr. But Tafsir Tabari records 4 differing views of the Salaf.

3/4 views translate 'Tawaffa' as 'Taking of the Soul', disproving any claimed Ijma'. Image
VIEW #1: TAWAFFA = DEATH

"And others said: The meaning is: I will take you with the taking of death." Image
VIEW #2: TAWAFFA = SLEEP

"Then the interpreters differed regarding the meaning of 'taking'...

Some said: 'It is the taking [of soul] during sleep' and according to them, the meaning was: 'I am causing you to sleep and raising you during your sleep.'" Image
VIEW #3: TAWAFFA = DEATH (In End Times)

"And others said: The meaning is: When Allah said, 'O Jesus, I am raising you to Me...I will cause you to die after I send you back down to the world.' They said: This is from what is presented earlier but meant to be later..." Image
VIEW #4: TAWAFFA = PHYSICAL TAKING

"Others said: The meaning is: 'I am taking you from the earth and raising you to Me.'...I am seizing you from the earth alive to My presence, and taking you to what is with Me without death, and raising you..." Image
CONCLUSION

• No Ijma' that Isa AS is alive
• Even Salaf had differing views so how can there be Ijma'?
• 3/4 views of Salaf translate 'Tawaffa' as 'taking of the soul'. NOT the body!
• 2/4 translate it as DEATH

🔗Article: whiteminaret.org/doj/no-consens…

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
　

Keep Current with WhiteMinaret

WhiteMinaret Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @whiteminaret1

WhiteMinaret Profile picture
Dec 30, 2025
🧵Sign of Messiah: Miraculous Prophecy - Birth of the son of Khalifa I

After the enemies mocked the death of the son of Maulvi Noor-ud-Din RA & called him Abtar, Mirza Ghulam Ahmad AS prophesied birth of a son who would have boils on his body

5 years later, that son was born Image
1) BACKGROUND

In 1894, the son of Maulvi Noorudin RA died in infancy

A Muslim enemy claimed that this is the proof that Ahmad AS had lost the debate with Abdullah Atham. He further mocked Noorudin RA by calling him Abtar (one without male issue)

Noorudin RA was 60 years old Image
2) PROPHECY

"In my dream, I saw that...God has given you that boy instead of Muhammad Ahmad, who is better than him in complexion, appearance, and strength...I saw that there were some rashes or pustules/boils erupting on the body of this child." Image
Read 7 tweets
WhiteMinaret Profile picture
Dec 20, 2025
🧵 La Nabiyya Ba'adi | Muslim Scholars

Anti-Ahmadis claim Ahmadi Muslims have invented interpretation of this hadith. That's just false.

Muslim scholars for centuries have defined "La Nabiyya Ba'adi" as "No LAW-BEARING Prophet after me."

Otherwise we reject Nuzul-e-Masih! Image
@MrAdnanRashid @BroHajji 1) IBN QUTAIBAH (d. 267H)

"The Holy Prophet ﷺ meant that there would be no Prophet after him who would abrogate his law."

[Ta’wilu Mukhtalifil-Ahadith, p. 236] Image
2) QADI ‘IYAD (d. 544H)

In response to the Mutazilites and Jahmites who denied the descent of Isa AS based on this hadith:

"...and this is an invalid reasoning because it is not meant by the descent of Isa AS, that he descends as a prophet with a law that abrogates our law." Image
Read 28 tweets
WhiteMinaret Profile picture
Dec 17, 2025
🧵Mahdi/Messiah will come in 19th Century AD | Classical/Modern Ulema

While the Ummah is desperately awaiting the coming of a mythical Mahdi, the real Messiah & Mahdi has already come

The Ulema have prophecized the Ad-Dajjal/Mahdi/Messiah arrives in 13th/14th century Hijri
1) SHEIKH ʿABDUL QĀDIR JĪLĀNĪ (d. 561H)

The book on the biography of another Saint - Imam Ahmad al-Sabri has a letter by Sheikh Jilani in which it's prophecized the Mahdi will manifest between 1300H-1400H and the Muqallideen won't accept him.

[Tadhkirah Anwar Sabri, p. 143-144] Image
2) SHĀH NI’MATULLĀH WALI (d. 834H) - 1

"Immediately after the passage of twelve hundred years
I see terrible/strange things happening...

And I read: Alif, Ha, Mim, and Dal. (Ahmad).”

[Al-Arba’in fi Ahwal-al-Mahdiyin pg. 45-47] Image
Read 36 tweets
WhiteMinaret Profile picture
Dec 14, 2025
🧵Sign of Messiah: Sheikh Najafi loses the challenge of Divine Sign

Najafi challenged Ahmad AS that he could show a sign in 40 minutes

Ahmad AS told him to show one in 40 DAYS instead, and he would do the same

35 days later, Allah manifested the sign of the death of Lekh Ram Image
1) CHALLENGE (1 Feb 1897)

Najafi writes to Ahmad AS and boasts about showing a sign within 40 minutes.

"Well then let him announce a prophecy and we shall give him, not forty minutes, but forty hours. Thereafter if no Sign appears on our side within forty days and he shows- Image
Image
-a Sign within forty hours, or, indeed within forty days, we shall believe in his spiritual eminence and we shall give up our own claim. But if within the period specified a Sign appears on my side and none appears from his side, this would be the proof of my righteousness."
Read 6 tweets
WhiteMinaret Profile picture
Dec 11, 2025
🧵Is Mirza Ghulam Ahmad AS one of the 30 Dajjals?

Anti-Ahmadis falsely allege that Ahmad (AS) is one of the 30 Dajjal’s prophesied in the Ahadith by the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ

This is not only false but their scholars prove otherwise! Image
1) A PERFECT PROOF

This hadith doesn’t contradict the coming of the Messiah in the End Times

It simply shows that 30 dajjals — a finite number of false claimants — will appear before the true Messiah.

Muhammad ﷺ did not say ALL claimants of Messiah will be Dajjal. Image
2) ʻIyāḍ Ibn-Mūsā al-Ubbi (d. 827 AH)

500 years before Mirza Ghulam Ahmad AS

“This hadith has proven true, for if one were to count those who claimed prophethood from his time ﷺ until now, they would reach this number, and this is known to anyone who examines the histories.” Image
Read 9 tweets
WhiteMinaret Profile picture
Nov 27, 2025
🧵 Anti-Ahmadis: “Mirza Ghulam Ahmad AS is a Bloody Mahdi & Rebel”

Today they claim he was a British agent, yet in his own lifetime they reported him to the government for being a rebel.

They switch sides whenever it suits their narrative. Image
1) CHRISTIANS

"He has attacked, and is attacking, not the British Government, and its officials, but Christianity and its missionaries, and in such a manner as is likely to cause very bitter and dangerous feelings in the minds of his followers against the religion of their... Image
...rulers and its exponents. In the very pamphlet, which he issues as an apology for himself he repeats the epithet for Christian missionaries that The Muhammadan protested against-Dajjal (an Arabic word signifying sorcerer or perverter of the truth)."
Read 10 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!

This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

Send Email!

:(