Senior Obama natl security official @brhodes has a NYT editorial on Biden & Gaza, full of odd claims abt the war, and plenty of tropes abt Jewish money & Israel keeping the Dems from winning elections and perfecting the world.
Rhodes: Biden gave Bibi 'unconditional support' to give the US leverage over him.
An odd claim. Biden held up key arms shipments & the Rafah operation for months. He lost leverage as his WH turned more on Isr.
Trump got to a Gaza ceasefire bc of his embrace of Isr
2/11
Rhodes: Siding with Israel over Hamas was hypocritical for Dems defending a “rules-based order,” racial equality & democracy.
Huh? What does backing Isr have to do with *racial equality*?
And Isr is a democracy fighting Hamas - the least democratic entity one could imagine.
3/11
Rhodes: Dems can't side with a 'right-wing govt determined to block...a Palestinian state'
That is not 'right wing.' That is consensus for Israel's mainstream. Golan's leftwing Democrats isn't pushing for a state.
Maybe left-wing Israelis know something Rhodes doesn't?
4/11
Rhodes: 'The centerpiece of Biden’s MidEast policy remained the Abraham Accords.'
This is the admin that wouldn't say the words 'Abraham Accords' at the outset.
And Rhodes blasts Ab Accords for being w autocrats and sidelining Pals. As if Pal leaders would be democrats. 5/11
Rhodes: After Oct 7, Isr leaders were "referring to Palestinians in Gaza as 'human animals'” & cutting all Gaza off. He links to Def Min Gallant speaking in Hebrew on Oct 9...
Who was clearly referring to Hamas as animals,
and a siege on *Gaza City* ahead of major combat
6/11
Rhodes: Isr leaders said that Palestinians were living in "an evil city"
Netanyahu on Oct 9: “Any place Hamas deploys, in this evil city, all the places Hamas is hiding, operating — we will turn it into a ruin.”
Hardly evidence of calling for attacks on all Palestinians.
7/11
Rhodes: "If you believe a Pal child is equal in dignity & worth to an Isr or US child, it is no longer possible to support this Israeli govt"
That's simply not how laws of war work. All countries prioritize the safety of their own civilians.
Wonder what he'd say abt WW2.
8/11
And ofc, his AIPAC obsession: "AIPAC donors" "More Democrats are refusing to take AIPAC money."
Jewish money controlling US politics.
Even worse - He says American democracy can't be restored "if it is beholden" to AIPAC and its financing of the far-right.
9/11
This sentence is especially egregious: "Some political support may be lost if Democrats distance themselves from Israel, particularly among donors."
= Rich Jews will be mad.
10/11
Antisemitism has always been about blaming Jews for the evils keeping the world from being redeemed.
And...Rhodes argues that Israel and AIPAC are the reason for growing authoritarianism, Dems losing to Trump, & Dems being unable to 'build the world they want."
11/11
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
🧵Israel’s 12 Day War was efficient, effective, and swift, ending with a clear victory.
Meanwhile, we have reached day 632 of the war with Hamas in Gaza, with none of the war aims reached.
Why do the two campaigns look so different?
(1/12):
The long-anticipated campaign against Iran's nuclear program ended after 12 days of undeniable competence.
Israel knew exactly where Iran's nuclear scientists and generals were- they fired drones missiles into their apartments to take out eliminate key regime figures. (2/12)
Commandoes operated on Iranian soil, smuggling in missile systems and a drone facility.
Israel gained air superiority over Tehran and destroyed its air defenses.
Israel also set back Iran's nuclear program- the extent is not yet known- but it was significant. (3/12)
After the US strike on Iran earlier this week, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and President Donald Trump agreed on a rapid end to the war in Gaza and expansion of the Abraham Accords. 1/4
Trump and Netanyahu agreed in their phone call that the war in Gaza would end within two weeks. Four Arab states, including the UAE and Egypt, would jointly govern the Gaza Strip in place of Hamas. The terror group's leaders will be exiled, and all hostages will be released. 2/4
They were joined on the "euphoric" call late Monday night by Marco Rubio and Ron Dermer.
Gazans who wish to emigrate would be absorbed by several unnamed countries. Saudi Arabia and Syria will establish diplomatic ties w Israel. Other Arab/Muslim countries will follow 3/4
Israel has some significant achievements in its campaign against Iran's nuclear program.
But success depends on its ability to strike one site - Fordo.
And Israel can't take it out from the air on its own.
Here's where the campaign stands:🧵
1) On Monday, Netanyahu listed many of Israel's achievements since last Friday:
Israel has taken out Iran's military leadership, struck ballistic missiles and launcher sites, destroyed half of Iran's UAVs, killed 10 top nuclear scientists and gained air superiority in west Iran
2) Israel began the campaign by striking Iranian air defense systems to allow the air force to operate freely.
Also, as of Tuesday the IDF announced that it wiped out 40% of Iran's ballistic missile launchers, but Iran still has abt 1800 missiles.
Israel operation against Iran could take 2-3 weeks, but the timeframe depends on decisions made by the political echelon on the scope of the campaign, an Israeli official tells me. 🧵
“There’s a bank of military targets that we can complete pretty quickly,” says the official. “If they decide to expand it to more like government symbols, economical targets, all that, then it will take longer.” >>>
The complete destruction of the Iranian nuclear program is *not* the goal.
A tighter nuclear deal between Iran & Western powers is the goal, says the official.
Israel is aiming to “cause enough damage [to the nuclear program] to revert to diplomacy and get a good agreement.” >>