I cannot speak to any specific details of this tragic event, but I do feel it is very important to state:
there is NO SITUATION where it is normal for a pt to wait >8hrs with severe chest pain if there is ANY meaningful flow in an ED that is functioning as it should be.
2/14
Without severe overcrowding and crushing volumes/acuity, it is a certainty that this pt would have been seen in a more timely fashion... at a min his symptoms could have been treated sooner, even if his underlying disease might have progressed to the same outcome.
3/14
I am positive that severe overcrowding was a major factor in delays to care, and that his prolonged waiting did NOT improve anything in this pt's case.
The institutional response will be to try to blame one single HCW for this tragic outcome...
4/14
"why didn't the nurse get him into a bed sooner? why didn't a doctor see him in the WR? why didn't someone treat his pain?..."
there is no question in my mind that severe and WELL-KNOWN ED overcrowding and system issues were the primary factors in this pt's delay to care
5/14
It bears noting that this occurred in a Covenant Health facility.
The Premier likes to vilify AHS and its teams/leads, but inordinate gridlock and severe overcrowding is an ongoing critical bottleneck regardless of what entity runs the hospital...
6/14
in fact, CH often has WORSE pt Access Metrics than many AHS hospitals, but for some reason govt doesn't make them report to the same standard as AHS.
7/14
Shuffling hospital ownership, while ignoring workforce and capacity planning is going to be meaningless, and more ABs will suffer as the govt continues to neglect meaningful change.
8/14
I would very much like to hear what the CH CEO Patrick Dumelie has to say about the severe overcrowding in his facility that would have contributed to this tragic outcome.
What's his plan to ensure this doesn't happen again?
9/14
I would very much like to hear what the ACA CEO David Diamond has to say about the severe overcrowding in his Edmonton Corridor that would have contributed to this tragic outcome.
What's his plan to ensure this doesn't happen again?
10/14
They owe an explanation to the patient's family, but also to the HC teams that are left high and dry trying to operate in completely untenable and dangerous overcrowding day in and day out.
11/14
Saying the case will become an M.E. case is NOT the same as a system/hospital review to try to learn what contributed to delays, and what could be done to improve care for future pts.
12/14
I hope Albertans will ask the Premier what her clear and cogent plan is to prevent more tragic events like these from occurring in our EDs. (Maybe on her call-in show, where she likes to reassure all is well???)
13/14
I'll close with a plea: let's review this case in the context of the severe system overcrowding, and commit to a real plan and a real fix.
We've had 2.5yrs of endless chaos and change, and everything continues to get worse.
14/14
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
This reads to me that the calls to acknowledge that our HC system is in a medical "state of emergency" were not actually "misguided". It took 8 days to get a whole bunch of "generals" to stand-up and admit the troops are actually in trouble...
I wonder, if HUNDREDS of physicians hadn't added their voices to the cry for help, if govt hoped this would just go away after officially and publicly gaslighting concerned vocal HC advocates?
2/4
It does remind me that the Judge Wyant report recommended HCW whistle-blower processes and protections, and govt "accepted" this recommendation. Wonder where that stands?
3/4
I received a message from an Alberta ED colleague that stopped me cold. He treated a very elderly pt - a retired Charge Nurse who began her career as WWII ended. She waited 8 hours in the WR for care. Her assessment of our current reality is devastating.... 1/8
She told the doc she has never seen it this bad. Not even before we had a formal healthcare system. But her most damning observation wasn't about the wait time or the lack of staff. It was about safety.
2/8
She said: "People feel scared." The ED is supposed to be the sanctuary… the place where fear subsides because you know you will be cared for. Instead, she watched Albertans sitting in terror.
3/8
Let’s go into more depth as to why a state of emergency and ACTUAL PROVINCIAL COORDINATION of care MUST happen immediately to maintain a semblance of safe and timely care in EDM hospitals: 🧵
1/12theglobeandmail.com/canada/article…
When one zone becomes overwhelmed there are emergency escalation measures that can be implemented to help maintain safe care
Some of which are:
- provincial wide load levelling
- bypassing a zone that is flooded - ex northern pts skip EDM and are sent to Calgary
2/12
- Mandatory repatriation (recovering pts sent back to home zone hosps asap)
- Mandatory first bed alc placement anywhere in province
- Release temp funding for additional surge teams and resources
- Postpone scheduled surgeries to use surgical wards for overflow
3/12
Let’s look at REAL TIME DATA for our EDM Adult EDs RIGHT NOW:
Our EDs have become HOSPITAL WARDS that see the odd Emergency patient!
(Think about that: they can no longer care for undifferentiated new pts, forced to run in-pt ward care vast majority of their time) 1/8
The entire EDM Zone is operating with ~ 38 FUNCTIONAL Emerg beds for the entire city! (worse if you consider the MIS is MINUS 21 beds over non-surge capacity)
Couple of notes based on this real time date from TODAY:
2/8
- Funded beds are estimates cuz we’ve added overflow spaces and surge and lots of additional care spaces already!
I would love AH/govt respond and correct what they think the most current data is!
3/8
Seeing more and more weighing in about how the GNH Triage nurse/ED team should be held to personal account makes me realize that the avg AB just doesn’t understand what an utter dumpster fire our major EDs have been for months/yrs. 1/9
It’s why it’s been in the news so much… and why I'm wasting so much breath trying to alarm the public … it is utter chaos and only getting worse.
Let me say this loud and clear: this case was tragic, but this is absolutely NOT the only death due to ED overcrowding.
2/9
This is just the tip of the iceberg, and unless something changes, many more will needlessly die.
Only the Premier and the govt can act to afford meaningful change.
3/9
Anybody who reads about this tragic case and thinks this has to do with a HCW not recognizing the severity at triage has simply NOT been paying attention.
Our triage system completely fails when we have DOZENS of triage level 2 and 3 pts in our WRs, with added severe overcrowding and unsafe levels of EIPs (EIP = SICK admitted pts that should be on specialized wards in the Hosp).
2/14
Covenant Health sites not only have EIPs, they also have TWAs = transfer waiting to be admitted = can spend DAYS in the ED simply waiting for a team to admit the sick pt, but they can’t be admitted because the admitting services are “FULL”. This does NOT happen at AHS sites.
3/14