I'll start by saying that the two groups are indeed different, at least because no one would completely copy someone else's brand. The girls from both groups are different, the lore is different, no one denies that
Fans heavily distort the meaning of all this, and I've said it many times before. Sometimes idols have a similar sweater, hairstyle, and so on
But as Min Heejin said, it's all a puzzle. If there are too many of these pieces connected to another group in one act, then the imitation of someone else's style can become obvious
I'm explaining all this in the simplest terms :
Let's take this performance. The outfits themselves, even if they resemble NewJeans, don't necessarily have to be linked to NewJeans
The background beat, even if it's reminiscent of NewJeans, could be used by others
The set design is also associated with NewJeans, but it's a popular style at the moment
Each of these things individually are elements used by many. However, the combination of these elements makes people think of NewJeans because that's exactly how a group's atmosphere is built
Let's take this specific case. Dance tutorials on paper have existed for a long time, and SNSD, BTS have done it. But with ILLIT, it's not just a similar design layout, but also the same method of promoting an album
That is, both groups used a tutorial as a way to promote their album, and on top of that, they have a similar design
All of this could have been avoided if BELIFT had taken just the promotional method, and not everything at once. But they don't just use the same promotional methods; they also sometimes replicate NewJeans' style (even if not always). That's what it all started with
🧵NEWJEANS FORMULA~ Why is using multiple sources normal?
Everything is a Remix. Every new creation is built on what came before. No style emerges from a vacuum. Using multiple sources is the very foundation of creativity and cultural evolution
Synthesis Creates Originality. True originality often lies in the unique combination of existing elements. An artist's style is defined by which influences they choose and how they combine them to express something new
🧵 The big thread about what kind of copying Min Heejin’s and her team were talking about
First, I want to say that NJ has always been about homage. It's a respectful nod to the iconic aesthetic of Y2K, the pop culture of the 2000s. They take one recognizable detail, rework it through their unique filter, and something nostalgic is born. It's a dialogue with the era
What HYBE is doing with il-t It's a systematic replication of the stylistic code that MHJ and ADOR have built for NJ over several years. This isn't a single detail it's an entire pattern, a set of visual, choreographic, and musical recipes, assembled into a recognizable brand