If this ceasefire winds up happening, the bold Iranian gambit to trade much of their senior leadership, most of their navy, at least half their missile launchers, the lives of thousands of security personnel, various bridges and rail lines, steel and petrochemical plants, their deterrence, their nuclear infrastructure, their air defenses, and the ability to use Dubai as a sanctions evasion hub for the possibility of charging tolls for merchant shipping on the Strait of Hormuz will have been a titanic failure
The Islamic Republic didn't spike oil prices enough to trigger a global recession. They've conceded their tollbooth scheme in Hormuz. Their resilience and Legomen videos impressed western experts but bought America and Israel the time needed to destroy nearly everything in their original target bank
Meanwhile Tehran's Lebanese proxy lost a decent amount of territory to the Israelis while their Yemeni and Iraqi proxies were largely irrelevant to the fighting. Iranian ballsitic missiles failed to kill a single Israeli soldier and hit targets of somewhat lesser value than back in June. Over the past six weeks, Iran has probably helped the Israelis sell billions in missile defense systems...
US and and Israel now have a very good idea of where the uranium is; Iranian breakout scenarios all involve speculation about underground enrichment facilities whose existence isn't yet proven. Even if these facilities do exist, back in June Israel destroyed the only known Iranian facility for converting enriched uranium to bomb fuel.
Aspects of the weaponization and delivery program—scienfitific facilities, individual scientists and procurement officials, space launch-related infrastructure—have been targeted over the past month. The fact the Israelis attacked relatively low-value stuff, like a yellowcake production plant and the Arak reactor, suggest to me that they've destroyed an awful lot of that stuff that really mattered to building and delivering nukes
The Iranian missile attacks on Israel were much more physically damaging during those 12 days in June than they have been the past 4 weeks. Killed more people, hit a couple actual targets etc
Pyschological and social damage is a different story though...
Here's the thing though, aerial attacks from the Iranian state figured in some of the absolute worst plausible nightmare scenarios facing Israel. But after hundreds and hundreds of attacks, the best effort the regime can mount against the Little Satan, I'm not sure Iranian missiles would even crack the top 10 of the worst disasters to have been visited upon Israel in my lifetime
Nick Kristof, New York Times columnist, Pulitzer winner, human rights mascot, guy who wanted to be governor of Oregon etc, didn't *have* to call the architect of perhaps the deadliest massacre of the 21st century a "strong and pragmatic leader who just might be able to hammer out a peace deal." No one was holding a gun to his head. And yet there it is
"Insider kingpin" is also just wretched writing. Kristof doesn't have an original thought in his brain. Did he ever? Is the bar for moral authority really that low at a place like the New York Times and in the segments of society it caters to?
The wild thing about the Somali fraud story is that while there are still a lot of intriguing unknowns out there, almost every major detail has been been public for months or even years. Part of the scandal is that it's all been systematically tolerated *at best*
"Why haven't national Republicans and/or the Trump administration done much about this?" is one of those intriguing unknowns. Oddly enough, I think part of it has to do w/the fact that the federal prosecutors who really know the issue are all Obama and/or Biden people, and for whatever reason newcomers in the Trump DOJ didn't have the knowledge or the inclination to pick up where they left off x.com/JamesMJohnson4…
And here's the other thing, the third rail of this whole topic isn't immigration or Islamophobia or whatever—it's the, uh, frequency with which major politicians drift in and out of the margins of these schemes. It's not smart to go after an Ellison or an Ilhan or a Tim Walz unless you really have them nailed...
As author of a long and I think pretty thorough reported piece on the Somali fraud issue that published just before that much-discussesd City Journal piece (), I figure I might as well weigh in on some of the big questions of what's now become a topic of national discussion finallycountyhighway.com/archive/volume…
1) Are Somalis more prone to fraud than any other immigrant or ethnic group? It is obvious that there are aspects of the Somali social system (the clans etc), the post-independence Somali historical experience, and the particularities of Somali migration to the US that created a ripe environment for public service fraud.
This doesn't *just* describe Somalis. As I wrote in County Highway, urban ethnic fraud is one of the building blocks of America. But Somalis are not Jews or Italians. In fact they're very different, proudly different, from Gikuyus or Oromo or other East African groups. Part of what makes this whole topic so uncomfortable is that even in America, ethnic, religious, and national communities aren't sorta just magically interchangeable with one another. The New World actually has an inconsistent record at flattening us all...
2) Having said that, the Somalis fraudster didn't create the bizarre, unaccountable, and almost laughably fraud-prone service delivery system that they later exploited. The model of using government grants to nonprofit organizations as a kind of rent distribution network for favored client groups really took off in Minnesota over the past 15-20 years, and it's festered in something that sure looks like a washing machine for political kickbacks. Elements of the Somali community might have figured out how to benefit from this state of affairs, but it emerged organically, out of authentically Minnesotan social and political conditions.
I've been writing/reporting on Qatar and Qatari foreign policy since 2011 or so. A major theme runs through all of my work on the topic: For the past 25 years, the country's leadership has had a practically unlimited and in fact globe-spanning sense of the national interest. This is a very small country of about 300,000 citizens that convinced itself that disparate, unrelated actors, such as the dictator of Eritrea, Malcolm Hoenlein, the Taliban, and the Washington Wizards were critical to its national strategy, which had no apparent limits...
The Qataris constantly behaved as if there were no risks to the strategy—and their confidence was warranted. There is an inherent tension, even an inocherency, to a Gulf monarchy serving as the global clearing house for Muslim Brotherhood propaganda. Doha made it work though. At every turn, the inherent tensions of their project wound up working in their favor
Ie, the past couple of years, October 7th has been a huge boon to Qatar. Hosting Hamas turned Doha into one of the managers of the world's hottest crisis, indispensible to everyone. But again, the court's strategy and outlook on the world seemed *only* to produce positive results, to the point that I think they become blind to to how inherently unmanageable and incoherent the larger project actually is
I do not know that Israel's course in Syria is especially wise. It all seems very reckless. But here's the thing: Druze fall in battle at higher proportional rates than their Jewish comrades in the IDF. Druze have died defending synagogues and even the Temple Mount from terrorists. Israelis all know this...
There is no fellow-feeling of any kind between Israeli Jews and Sunni religious militants, but that is not the case with the Druze. From the Israeli perspective the Syrian state might look more fake and more threatening and more temporary than the Druze within and beyond Israel's own borders
Still, Israelis should know better than just about any group of people on earth how the purest intentions can lead to the stupidest and most tragic errors. Real risks of getting sucked into an Arab sectarian war, with the result of undermining a state-building project in Damascus that everyone else (the US, the Gulf, Turkey etc) wants to succeed...