Frédéric Bastiat’s essay “That Which Is Seen and That Which Is Not Seen” (1850) contains one of the clearest and most powerful insights in economics. Bastiat observed that people - including policymakers - focus almost exclusively on immediate, visible results (the “seen”) while ignoring the hidden, long-term consequences (the “unseen”).
Take his famous broken-window parable: a shopkeeper’s window is smashed; the glazier is hired, earns money, and as he spends it elsewhere, onlookers declare the economy stimulated. What is seen is the new job and spending, but what is unseen is what the shopkeeper could have done with that same money - buying a new suit, repairing his roof or investing in his business. Society ends up with one window instead of a window plus a suit. Destruction does not create net wealth; it merely redirects it and conceals the loss.
Bastiat applied the same logic to government spending, public works, subsidies, and even war. Every franc taken in taxes or borrowed is a franc that cannot be used by individuals for their own purposes. The jobs “created” by the state are visible; the jobs, innovations, and goods never produced because resources were diverted are invisible.
This single insight exposes why so many well-intentioned policies fail. Real prosperity grows from the unseen choices of free individuals, not from the visible hand of the state.
Take his famous broken-window parable: a shopkeeper’s window is smashed; the glazier is hired, earns money, and as he spends it elsewhere, onlookers declare the economy stimulated. What is seen is the new job and spending, but what is unseen is what the shopkeeper could have done with that same money - buying a new suit, repairing his roof or investing in his business. Society ends up with one window instead of a window plus a suit. Destruction does not create net wealth; it merely redirects it and conceals the loss.
Bastiat applied the same logic to government spending, public works, subsidies, and even war. Every franc taken in taxes or borrowed is a franc that cannot be used by individuals for their own purposes. The jobs “created” by the state are visible; the jobs, innovations, and goods never produced because resources were diverted are invisible.
This single insight exposes why so many well-intentioned policies fail. Real prosperity grows from the unseen choices of free individuals, not from the visible hand of the state.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
