1/ A thread on #ownvoices and #representation as well as allyship, guests, holding babies, writing the other, and assorted issues dealing with POC characters/stories being written by white folks. Nothing super new, just bringing nuanced notions together, reflecting on my views.
2/ America desperately needs a LOT more #ownvoices books. That should be our priority. I've even advocated for a sort of #affirmativeAction in publishing. Agents and editors should be ACTIVELY seeking out POC talent, recruiting, nurturing, publishing.
3/ Especially in kids lit. Only 25% of books for kids feature protags of color. Only 6% are actually written by authors of color. Both of those numbers MUST CHANGE, but the second is the biggest problem. Writers of color need to be the main folks writing these stories.
4/ Within that 6%, some groups are in worse straits. Just 26% of books with Black protags are written by Black authors & 40% with Native protags by Native authors. Contrast: 61% of books with Latinx protags are by Latinx & 89% of books with Asian Pacific protags are by AP folks.
5/ So, yeah, tons of work to be done. However, I still believe there is room at the table for non-POC allies who write POC protagonists really well (though to be honest, this is a pretty high bar).
6/ @NisiShawl once shared Diantha Day Sprouse's three categories of folks who borrow others' culture: invaders, tourists, and guests. "Guests are invited. Their relationships with their hosts can become long-term commitments and are often reciprocal." irosf.com/q/zine/article…
7/ These guests, however, are rare. They tend to be people who are actively engaged in cultural exchange, who spend years of their lives understanding the other culture, allowing it to reshape their souls. They incorporate new beliefs and practices unironically into their lives.
8/ @debreese shared a few years ago James Ransome's explanation for not illustrating books with Native American protagonists: “I haven’t held their babies.” To truly merit the privilege of writing about a community, they must know you well enough to trust you with their kids.
9/ TBH, I can't think of many examples. One guy is Joe Hayes. He moved to Arizona as a kid, lived among Mexican-Americans, picked up Spanish, became deeply involved in the community and its folklore. He retells many of those tales in English & Spanish. Kids (& parents) love him.
10/ Despite the lousy job other wyt dudes have done, I want Joe to have a seat at the table. As a Mexican-American, I know & trust him. I'll let him cradle my nietos (if I become an abuelo) and tell them cuentos (en español). But, yeah, he's an exception to the norm.
11/ If you are not POC and want to be like him, a guest and ally who crafts good representation, that's cool. But, like @brownbookworm said last week at #wi13 you need to do the work. & be willing to listen to your critics (whose help you should enlist ... get a cultural expert)
12/ There's a ton of advice out there on what it means to "do the work." @djolder has a great essay on writing the other and the self, which reminds you that bad/racist rep is also flat-out bad writing, & that you need to understand yourself first: buzzfeed.com/danieljoseolde…
13/ @debreese has done amazing work in this regard, focusing on Native rep. "Good intentions are not enough [....] Book research is not enough. Visits to reservations aren’t enough, either. Real relationships with American Indians are vital [....]" slj.com/2013/11/collec…
13/ More soon. Taco break.
14/ @CynLeitichSmith reminds us, citing a wise bit of advice, that writers wanting to explore another culture should read 100 books by folks of that community. I suspect that most would be deterred if they tried to do so: kirkusreviews.com/features/100-b…
15/ And even well-intentioned cishet wyt writers who attend to these suggestions get it wrong all the time, as @tinytempest so thoroughly explores in her LitReactor piece "Representation Matters" :litreactor.com/columns/repres…
16/ At the end of the day, guys like Joe Hayes are one-in-a-million. Depressingly, I doubt most wyt bandwagon-hopping writers of kid lit are going to invest years of their lives engaging with a new culture and hundred of hours of authentic #ownvoices reading so they're prepared.
17/ I at least hope folks who insist on writing POC protags outside their experience will seriously consider reading WRITING THE OTHER by @NisiShawl & @cynthia_ward (or better yet, attending one of their retreats/ workshops) writingtheother.com
18/ And I sure as hell hope that publishers who insist on publishing non #ownvoices rep enlist the aid of a cultural expert (a "sensitivity reader") to ameliorate the damage they might otherwise do to kids who, as it stands, have hardly any literary mirrors at all.
19/ Given how hard this is to get right, how much even we POC wring our hands about our own adequacy in speaking for our culture, maybe your best bet (hypothetical cishet wyt person) is to rethink the entire idea of writing a protag outside your frame of reference.
20/20 Ask yourself, "Why do I want to do this?" If your answer doesn't center on your longstanding relationship with the community in question, you may end up doing more harm than good. The road to hell, people. The road to hell.
21/ Perhaps, instead, you keep writing what you've been writing, including supporting characters of color in a respectful, reasearched way, & you use your privilege to REACH OUT TO WOC and promote #ownvoices so that publishing is transformed. That's real allyship.
22/ I'll give you two examples. @AdamGidwitz has multiple bestsellers to his name. When he came up with the idea for @unicorn_rescue he could've written all the various cultures and creatures himself. Instead, he found WOC to co-author books with him. That's an ally right there.
23/ The other is @camphalfblood who used his platform to pitch a new imprint to @DisneyHyperion (Rick Riordan Presents) that will be publishing mythic fantasy from WOC like @Roshani_Chokshi and @jencerv . That sort of amplification of #ownvoices is what we really need right now.
24/ Also, as we say in Spanish, OJO (careful): POC can laterally screw this up, too. ANYONE writing protags from another culture can. I'm Mexican-American. Lived most of my life in South Texas. But my dad was navy, so 8 years of my childhood I spent in South Carolina.
25/ 1970s. Not many Latinx. We lived among Black people, mainly. I lived and breathed that Lowcountry culture, listened to Grandmothers' Gullah tales, played with and fell in love with kids from our neighborhoods. But I still only write Mexican-American protagonists.
26/ There's one exception: my story "Huckleberry Juju," which is based on my experiences during those years and is narrated by a fictional version of my older friend Keith. Beyond that, why would I? sites.google.com/a/newmyths.com…
27/27 Only 26% of kids books with Black protagonists are written by Black authors. @DrivenByTatiana has been engaging w/me on this, and they say it well: "If you're so connected to black ppl, then you should know that black ppl can tell their stories better than they can." Amen.
Missing some Tweet in this thread?
You can try to force a refresh.

Like this thread? Get email updates or save it to PDF!

Subscribe to David Bowles (Ocēlōtōn in Tlamatini)
Profile picture

Get real-time email alerts when new unrolls are available from this author!

This content may be removed anytime!

Twitter may remove this content at anytime, convert it as a PDF, save and print for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video

1) Follow Thread Reader App on Twitter so you can easily mention us!

2) Go to a Twitter thread (series of Tweets by the same owner) and mention us with a keyword "unroll" @threadreaderapp unroll

You can practice here first or read more on our help page!

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!

This site is made by just three indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member and get exclusive features!

Premium member ($3.00/month or $30.00/year)

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!