Discover and read the best of Twitter Threads about #huntingatlantis
Most recents (3)
Hey folks, given all the drama over #HuntingAtlantis I thought I would clarify a few points about the scientific technology used in the show by @jessphoenix2018 . So I give you:
The ‘Science’ of #HuntingAtlantis Part 1: Science Machines and Make-Believe
The ‘Science’ of #HuntingAtlantis Part 1: Science Machines and Make-Believe
That ray-gun that @jessphoenix2018 brings out sometimes is called a Portable X-Ray Fluorescence device, or a pXRF for short. The machine shoots x-rays at your chosen target, and reads the energy which comes back in order to determine what elements it’s looking at
This technology is heavily used by geologists and archaeologists alike (and definitely by geoarchaeologists like yours truly). It can help identify ancient paints and pigments, to analyse soils, and even to source some stone like obsidian. And it looks like a phaser!
Pseudoarchaeology and fake history causes real harm in our society
Many people think, what’s the harm of hunting for a lost city? It’s entertainment, right! It even exposes children to real science
CW: The harm leads directly to racism and eugenics
1/18
Many people think, what’s the harm of hunting for a lost city? It’s entertainment, right! It even exposes children to real science
CW: The harm leads directly to racism and eugenics
1/18
The host of #HuntingAtlantis (@stelpavlou), and unfortunately his wife, have claimed that their TV show inspires children to be curious about real facts, real scientific methods, and real archaeology
This might be true in some cases, but there are problems with this argument
/2
This might be true in some cases, but there are problems with this argument
/2
The show misrepresents researchers. Repeatedly, archaeologists on #HuntingAtlantis present fascinating, new finds
Then, it cuts to the hosts who explain how these finds support their Atlantis theories
The experts have no recourse to reply to this fantastical jump in logic
/3
Then, it cuts to the hosts who explain how these finds support their Atlantis theories
The experts have no recourse to reply to this fantastical jump in logic
/3
I have apparently pissed off some powerful people with my tweets about Atlantis
For a bit my account was locked. i have done nothing offensive. This TV show has misrepresented archaeologists and scholars. If some lawyer asks me, I can prove it
Bring it on, report my account
For a bit my account was locked. i have done nothing offensive. This TV show has misrepresented archaeologists and scholars. If some lawyer asks me, I can prove it
Bring it on, report my account
i'm not sure why someone's wife decided to write a 20 tweet thread about me, with the first tweet about my who my dad was
I am an archaeologist. I am a good archaeologist
Atlantis is just not real
I am an archaeologist. I am a good archaeologist
Atlantis is just not real
if you really want to make a documentary about Atlantis, and cant even ask your experts about their opinions about Atlantis
then you are misleading them
then you are misleading them
