Aabhas Maldahiyar 🇮🇳 Profile picture
Author || Urban-Designer & Architect II Latest book- Babur: The Chessboard King ( @PenguinIndia )

Oct 21, 2019, 19 tweets

#SadarPranam fake Comrade. Aren’t you son of SQR Ilyas,member of Central Advisory Council of Jamaat-e-Islami_Hind whose motto is Iqaamat-e-Deen?

Do u condemn your father’s affiliation being a communist.

Well u may not but,here I expose lies in ur thread in below thread. 1/n

2/n What was happening at #JNU when you guys represented:

Durga Mata as objectionable imagery
What about continual insult of Bhagwan Rama at #JNU ?

Now when your own act has made you begin to pay, u play victim card?

3/n Utter lie. No Hadith has captured this incidence old woman. Rather Muhammad chose to forcefully convert old man Abu Sufyan when he came to plead him not to wedge war on Meccans (source: Ibn Ishaq 808-9)

4/n Another lie.Hold on Comrade, from when Atheists started believing in Angels?Though let me give u facts than”rhetoric”.

Muhammad enjoyed the protection of his powerful uncle, Abu Talib & was never persecuted by Meccans. Source of snippet(Ibn Ishaq,168)

5/n For 15 years Md was occasionally mocked while praying at the Kaaba. He continued provoking Meccans & threatening to bring them "slaughter".This caused them to seize Muhammad in an attempt to "throttle" him, but he was released unharmed almost immediately.

Source:Ibn Ishaq184

6/n So @UmarKhalidJNU no stone was thrown at Muhammad.

Even Hadith of Bukhari confirms he was unharmed. (Snippet)

7/n In fact had Muhammad been #Compassionate he would have forgiven the man who had seized him when captured following the Battle of Badr. According to his biographers, Muhammad chose instead to have him slaughtered even as he unarmed begged for his life.

8/n @UmarKhalidJNU Even Quran doesn’t supports that Muhammad suffered physical abuse at Mecca.

But let me tell you one more act of #Compassion of him.

One entire Sura describes the gruesome torture awaiting Abu Lahab and his wife in hell.

9/n According to the authentic Hadith, their only crime was personal mockery of "the Messenger" at Mecca (Bukhari 60:475). Check snippet.

10/n Well @UmarKhalidJNU Prophet fought against Racism? This is new & high class lie.

Read the truth. As per,Sahih Muslim 3901, Muhammad actually “purchased” the slave by trading 2 black slaves,which certainly isn’t eg of emancipation. (Check snippet)

11/n Its quite clear from 10/n that Muhammad owned as well as traded African slaves. Being a rich man he could have easily freed all 3 slaves,but instead he chose to sell the 2. So how did Muhammad show emancipation for slaves?

12/n It can’t be found anywhere that Muhammad “liberated” slaves caught in battle,until he found gain from it. Actually,he made slaves out of free populace(specially women and children). He used families as leverage to force their men into accepting Islam.
Snippet:Ibn Ishaq 879

13/n @UmarKhalidJNU in fact Md set precedents for women as sexy slaves. Women were passed out like to his men(exactly IS did with Yazidi women).

Eg from: Ibn Ishaq 878 (snippet)where Prophet hands over 3 women to Umar, Uthman and Ali (future caliphs)

another #Compassion

14/n As per Muhammad, Allah gave Muslim men a divine mandate to keep as many sex slaves as they wished (Quran 4:24, 33:52).

Snippets taken from quran.com

15/n @UmarKhalidJNU in case u have read enuf then u may pretend that this applies only to women captured in battle, then I have “Quran 70:30” for u which was “revealed” in Mecca, when there were no battles.

16/n One of the best explanation of Muhammad’s relationship with his slaves comes from the most authentic.

Read Bukhari 47.743

As per this hadith,the pulpit that Md preached Islam from was made from slave labor on his command. So Md had no problem Slavery& Racism didn’t exist

17/nUmar,Racism wasn’t the concern, Slavery was in 7th cen bt #Muhammad didn’t ever cared to remove it rather used”Women”as sex slaves(ref from Hadithin above tweets till 16/n. Don’t cook ur own agenda(like Black Racism).History books aren’t printed in JNU

18/n You respect all faith? Come on comrade, representation of Durga Mata in objectionable state & insult to Bhagwan Rama everyday at JNU is respect to Hindus?

N/n Continual fatwas have come not from Hindutvavadis & Continual murders of Mullahs hasn’t happened. Prophet is irrelevant here, what’s relevant is “precedents” being set by followers. You can’t kill #KamleshTiwari just because he mocked #ProphetMuhammad

Share this Scrolly Tale with your friends.

A Scrolly Tale is a new way to read Twitter threads with a more visually immersive experience.
Discover more beautiful Scrolly Tales like this.

Keep scrolling