Aabhas Maldahiyar 🇮🇳 Profile picture
Author(3 books),Columnist, Urban Designer "Ex-Marxist" My latest book #ModiAgain (story of my transformation) buy at https://t.co/VWAACLWi8N
𝓡𝓮𝓣𝔀𝓔𝓽𝓡 🇮🇳 Profile picture vishnu🇮🇳 Profile picture Pradipto Moitra(#NonVeg #Bhakt ,Gobhi ji Ka Nahin) Profile picture ‍।। श्री राम ।। Profile picture Pavan 🇮🇳 Ready for B+ Blood by 18Nov20 Profile picture 114 added to My Authors
19 Sep
1/n #SadarPranam to Ishvara within you @_YogendraYadav ji.

I'm sorry to say but you have no idea about how Communists had supported Communal Violence around 1946-47.

I mention same in this thread which you may respond should you have enough substance.
2/n @_YogendraYadav ji, if I refer to "Brothers Against the Raj", Hashim the secretary of the Muslim League, the key man behind the rise of Suhrawardy, mentions in his memoir, "Let Us Go To The War", that he had help from Nikhil Chakravartti a young communist. Read.
3/n Not to forget, Hashim calls himself an "Islamic Socialist".
Read 7 tweets
16 Sep
1/n #SadarPranam to Ishvara within you @irfhabib ji.

Will you call work of #IrfanHabib in regards to Mughals? Because his works don’t say so great about Akbar & Mughals as you portray.

Here are some citations from his works & other Scholars.

You may respond with Substance!
2/n I’m first quoting from book “The Cambridge Economic History of India” edited by T Raychudhuri & Irfan Habib in regards to few economic troubles to Indians by Mughals. Read on.
3/n Irfan Habib gives account of money hoarding at large scale by Mughal Emperors including Akbar.

He quotes De Laet who mentions Akbar’s treasure to be ~522.4 million florins & Sarista Khan to have hoarded ₹380 million.

Was economy blooming?

Snippet pg 183
Read 13 tweets
14 Sep
1/n #SadarPranam to Ishvara within you @_sabanaqvi ji.

While you defend @UmarKhalidJNU , here in this thread I put a bit of truth which makes me conclude he was a Terrorist in making & your opinion is wrong.

U may answer should u have enough substance.
2/n The google search about @UmarKhalidJNU brings this page for you.

A Human Rights Activist. Really? Let’s inspect more by quoting Dr Ambedkar.

“The brotherhood of Islam is not the universal brotherhood of man. It is brotherhood of Muslims for Muslims only.
3/n one can observe in this video clearly that @UmarKhalidJNU asked people to come on street when @POTUS visits Delhi on Feb 24, 2020
Read 14 tweets
12 Sep
1/n #Atheist#Nastika

I explain in this thread.

In early ancient Greek, the adjective átheos was used as a term of condemnation largely meaning "impious".
2/n Comes 5th Century BC, átheos began to indicate more deliberate and active godlessness with perspective of "severing relations with the gods" or "denying the gods".
3/n Then came the term term "asebēs"applied against those who denied or disrespected the gods of particular locality, even if they believed in other gods. In modern translations of classical texts átheos is mentioned as "atheistic".

Source: Atheism in Pagan Antiquity
by ABD
Read 12 tweets
10 Sep
1/n #Secularism

This thread explains the history and idea about it.

But before we dwell deeper, we must understand that Secularism is about "Religion" not "Dharma".

And, Dharma ≠ Religion (explained in quoted tweet)
2/n It was Mr George Jacob Holyoake who used term "Secularism" in 1851 through his magazine "Reasoner".

He writes in his book"English Secularism: A Confession of Belief", that it was all about "rejection of few Christian Scriptural beliefs".
3/n In the Reasoner Edition of July, 1871, he tells Secular knowledge is manifestly that kind of knowledge which is founded in this life which relates to the conduct of this life conduces to the welfare of this life and is capable of being tested by the experience of this life.
Read 16 tweets
29 Aug
1/n I want to learn from @AatishTaseer if VS Naipaul too is non-distinguished person as he claimed @GarudaPrakashan to be for publishing #DelhiRiotsUntoldStory by @advmonikaarora . In this thread I’m putting Naipaul’s opinion abt Islam.

Aatish respond should you have substance.
2/n Below are citations from
Beyond Belief: Islamic Excursions Among the Converted Peoples

1) Islam is in its origins an Arab religion. Everyone not an Arab who is a Muslim is a convert. Islam is not simply a matter of conscience or private belief. It makes imperial demands. +
3/n + A convert’s worldview alters. His holy places are in Arab lands; his sacred language is Arabic. His idea of history alters. He rejects his own; he becomes, whether he likes it or not, a part of the Arab story. The convert has to turn away from everything that is his.++
Read 13 tweets
13 Aug
1/n #SadarPranam @NitinRaut_INC ji. Btw which saryagrah did Ambedkar participate in?

Guruji never showed even a sign to be inspired from Hitler.

In this thread I put across my argument. Challenge you to prove me wrong should you have enough substance.
2/n @NitinRaut_INC ji, Guruji served as @RSSorg chief from 1940-73, but there is not a single statement or act of him from this period which would have been shown inspiration from Hitler.

Please do bit reading.
3/n @NitinRaut_INC have you read book “We or our...” at all? What does he writes in forward & why book was refrained from circulation? Any idea if it happened before become RSS chief or after?

Let me leave it as homework for you.
Read 6 tweets
12 Aug
1/n #SadarPranam to Ishvara within you @r_bhaduri ji.

Tulasīdāsa does mention of destruction of Ram Temple. You seem to be uneducated on the subject. Here are evidences from “Doha Shatak” by Tulsidas which is also part of court document.
2/n मंत्र उपनिषद ब्राह्मनहुँ बहु पुरान इतिहास ।

जवन जराये रोष भरि करि तुलसी परिहास ॥ 85 ॥

Tulasīdāsa says that the Yavanas, filled with rage, burnt many Mantras or Saṃhitās, Upaniṣads and even Brāhamaṇas, and Purāṇa and Itihāsa scriptures, after ridiculing them.
3/n सिखा सूत्र ते हीन करि बल ते हिन्दू लोग ।
भमरि भगाये देश ते तुलसी कठिन कुजोग ॥ 86 ॥

Tulasīdāsa says that in the hard & inappropriate age, forcibly made the Hindus bereft of Śikhā & Sūtra & made them wander after which they expelled them from their country (native place).
Read 9 tweets
4 Aug
1/n #SadarPranam to Ishvara within u @Javedakhtarjadu ji.

Guruji never showed even a sign to be inspired from Hitler.

In this thread I put across my argument. Challenge you to prove me wrong should you have enough substance.
2/n @Javedakhtarjadu , Guruji served as @RSSorg chief from 1940-73, but there is not a single statement or act of him from this period which would have been shown inspiration from Hitler.

Please do bit reading.
3/n @Javedakhtarjadu have you read book “We or our...” at all? What does he writes in forward & why book was refrained from circulation? Any idea if it happened before become RSS chief or after?

Let me leave it as homework for you.
Read 6 tweets
26 Jul
1/n #SadarPranam to Ishvara within everyone at @fpjindia . I'm replying because you quoted me in this article and tried to run a fact check on my statement saying: Savarkar Wanted Muslims to stay in India".

Here in this thread I debunk your claims.
freepressjournal.in/entertainment/…
2/n I see @fpjindia , your R&D team only does one step, ie to collect data but do not run an analysis.

You rubbish my tweet by making statement that Savarkar actually did not wanted Muslims to stay in India by referring to mediocre, lowly analysed piece by @saliltripathi .
3/N Before I go on to explain that at how many places Mr @saliltripathi 's article has factual errors, let me explain you how Savarkar actually wanted Muslims to stay in India. One must understand that what Savarkar states as 2-nation is way way different than what ML said.
Read 7 tweets
17 Jul
1/n @radvaz #SadarPranam to Ishvara within u.
Came across this creation of yours where you abuse “Karwa Chauth”.

It’s indeed amazing that you want to abuse a tradition without actually understanding the root.

Have you heard of the war with Invaders?

2/n “Karwa Chauth” is celebration of a tradition wherein wives along with children used to pray for safe return of Male who would be fighting war long away. The “Chauth” was like a landmark position of moon as even wheat showing began, hence it in pot (Karva).
3/n We celebrate many such tradition as celebration of wars we fought. @radvaz perhaps you might not be aware but people in Odisha light Diyas on banana leaf boats & make it float towards SE on Kartik Purnima. You might call it superstition but the truth is that +
Read 6 tweets
14 Jul
Life isn’t about marks but to learn from marks you got.

While I had just finished representing India in an international painting competition, I had got 38 in Maths Pre-Board class X. Everyone began to taunt my parents.

I worked hard & ended up making that 38 to 100 in Maths.
I also ensured that my parents aren’t required to pay for Tutions, considering the humble background I came from.

The 2 months of hard work for maths had now made it my fav subject.
Once a hater of maths, takes up PCM at school for +2. All goes well, but I meet an accident while cycling down to examination Center during boards of XII. Somehow I managed to write for 35 marks & just managed passing marks of 33.
Read 10 tweets
11 Jul
1/n #SadarPranam to Ishvara within you Shri @cjwerleman

I'm sorry to disappoint you Mr Tarbooj, as in this thread I'll compile Statistics about "Global Terrorism" & also rebut your fake claims later.

Do respond should you have enough substance.
2/n For the tweets that I follow, my source is statista.com

Maximum terrorist attacks happened in Afghanistan in year 2018, followed with other Islamic States.

So mathematically, 0.83 attacks happened every hour in Afghanistan. This shows the number of terrorist attacks in 2018, by count
3/n The graph shows the number of deaths due to terrorism globally between 2006-18.

32,836 people were killed by terrorists in 2018. In 2006, about 14,371 terrorist attacks were counted, while in 2018, 8,093 terrorist attacks were counted. The fear of terrorism is still instilled in many people's mi
Read 9 tweets
2 Jul
1/4 I say hail ancient India. They call me Rightist.

I say: hail ancient India because RigVeda found Earth as Sphere when Rest thought it Flat.

The same who thought World as flat came out as "Right" in France.

So is it right to call me "Right"?
2/4 I say: hail ancient India. They call me Rightist.

I say: hail ancient India because RigVeda spoke of "Democracy". The "first time Rightist" stood against Democracy.

So is it right to call me "Right"?
3/4 So am I a Leftist because I stand by "Ancient India Praise Group"?

How is it possible too when as per latest experiences "Left" stands for organisations like #Antifa that supports Anarchy and not Democracy.
Read 4 tweets
27 Jun
1/n #SadarPranam to Ishvara within you @tjoseph0010 ji.

I'm sorry to say but this dig of you at @NileshOak , in regards to time-period of Indian Civilization is highly unscientific.

Here is my rebuttal,which u may respond should u have substance,but only after tweet no is n/n.
2/n First let me give you sources from what you guys call "peer reviewed paper".
You mention that Agriculture began with the beginning of Holocene which happened 12000 years ago.

But most recent papers state that agriculture occurred 23kaBP. Read on...
3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes.

So Shri Tony Ji, archaeologically your belief is wrong about first time agriculture.

Now let us see what experts speak about Holocene.
journals.plos.org/plosone/articl…
Read 8 tweets
21 Jun
1/n #SadarPranam to Ishvara within u @Pawankhera Ji. Since u speak of Nehru Ji and 1962, I thought of sharing how @INCIndia messed Indo-Sino Border in this thread.

U may respond shud u hv enough substance. I'm citing from @CIA paper (1963). Don't respond until tweet reads n/n.
2/n 1950-51, Nehru had made it clear that it had no concern with Tibet, even though China entered Lhasa as well on Oct 26, 1951.

So, India had no objection to China inching closer.

You can also observe in this snippet, How China used to overpower Nehru's leadership.
3/n China considered the Indian Army weak.

Though the Indian army had movement in NEFA & established check-posts on the McMohan line but China didn't bother.

Peiping's asserts (People's Daily on Oct, 27, 1962 ) that this action was allowed to go unchallenged because:
Read 13 tweets
15 Jun
Rubbish!

Akbar’s General, Abdulla Khan Uzbeg enslaved 50,000 men & women.

Jahangir has sent 200,000 Indians as slave to Iran in 1619-20 alone.

Source: “Islamic Jihad: A Legacy of Forced Conversion, Imperialism, and Slavery” By M. A. Khan
@aumkotwal , the same source further quotes Manrique to explain condition under Shah Jahan. His tax collectors carried away peasants along with their children & wives to “slave fairs” to realise the tax.
@aumkotwal The Fatawa-e-Alamgiri sponsored by Aurangzeb had laws to encourage slavery.

It had provisions for:

1)the right of Muslims to purchase + own slaves
2)Muslim man's right to have sex with slave girl he owns or owned by another Muslim (with master's consent).
Read 5 tweets
1 Jun
1/5 A very brief Video thread on

"How The Arabian/ ME world had supported Hitler big time just to exterminate Jews of Palestine."

They compared Hitler to be as good as Muhammad himself.
2/5 Hitler's images were displayed in shops of Baghdad.

In October1938, Arabic versions of “Mein Kempf” were distributed in an Islamic Parliamentarian Conference at Cairo.
3/5 Young Egypt Movement (a Muslim Brotherhood campaign) adopted Fascist salutes, uniforms, torchlight processions despite being anti-west by philosophy.
Read 5 tweets
31 May
Views of Ambedkar:

1.Muslims have all evils of“Hindus”& even something more.

2.Everybody infers that Islam must be free from slavery & caste. Reg slavery nothing needs to be said. It stands abolished now by law. But while it existed,much of its support was derived from Islam..
3)“ But if slavery has gone, caste among Musalmans has remained. “

More details in snippets, where @TheInfidel23 u you can read how “Caste-based discrimination exists in the Islamic world” as per Ambedkar.

4)“Azral” are untouchables in Islam.
5.Ambedkar then talks about the system of untouchability in Muslims. After giving account of “evil Untouchability” in Panchayat system of Bengal he asserts:

6.“But the facts for Bengal are enough to show that the Mahomedans observe not only caste but also untouchability.”
Read 5 tweets
31 May
The follower of Islamic Doctrine has till now supported triple Talaq.

Show me a Hindu who tries to defend Polygamy using Hindu Scripture as justification.

Point is how would a Hindu do it, unless it is actually even mentioned in Books. All ur citations are Bunkum.
Give me the Sanskrit verse + word-word meaning to justify your claims. & to see Krishna marrying many, & to claim that Hindu Dharma supports polygamy, you need to first see him as real history. Once, you have done this, we may discuss the context too.
I believe that you have issues with "comprehension". Did I not ask you which Hindu have you seen justifying polygamy etc using Hindu SCriptures.

All of a sudden if some dolt will start shouting Hindu Scripture mean "falna-dhankana" without precedents..so?
Read 4 tweets
26 May
Listen, ma'am. Enough. I'm not sending out trolls to you. I stopped my tweets thread at 8 or 9, all with primary sources along with logics.

Can you at least acknowledge that it was all the "primary source" which I cited?

You are not one to DICTATE me, when I finish my thread.
I have many other things to do apart from twitter. Again for the time spent on twitter today it has always been wasting time on unnecessary fire spread by u. Could u not wait in all civility for me to finish the thread?

I have day-job, not unemployed.

When are you going to reply to why Shaikh asked for Akbar's permission if Ulemas had all power? And why Akbar agreed for execution giving free-hand t Ulema in the first place if he was so peeved?

Don't read but also analyze.
Read 4 tweets