Steve Peers Profile picture
Professor of EU Law & Human Rights Law, @rhul_law. Latest book: EU Justice and Home Affairs Law, 5th ed (OUP), published Oct 2023. Usual disclaimers.

May 25, 2021, 28 tweets

Remember this? When I debunked a viral FB post with crazy claims about EU law?

People often asked me who was the source of this stuff. Well...

...I haven't found out the source of *those particular* crazy claims. But thanks to @EmporersNewC I have some news about some *similar* crazy claims.

Last night someone tried to prove that FB post was correct by er, just quoting it again. But then she linked to the "eutruth" website. I followed the link and...

@EmporersNewC tipped me off to find the site via the wayback machine - web.archive.org/web/2021022404…
It's a long, incoherent rant, so I'll give you the highlights. The Queen should be executed for treason. With added Germanophobia.

There's no "corpus juris" in force. The EU didn't set up admiralty courts.

But note that obsession with medical regulation. That's what the playwrights call "the gun in the first act"...

No idea if those numbers are correct, but no EU law prohibits prosecution of police officers.

The Queen won't be hanged alone - she'll be joined by civil servants, MPs and PMs...

...and maybe 1000 lawyers too.

Well, *somebody* enjoyed reading that bit

The first of many, many mentions of Hitler. But also communism. Drink!

You may recall that we have, in fact, had further elections after 2010

Immigrants! Do you have fewer than 8 children? Better get busy!

Unfortunately this segues straight into rabid Islamophobia

I bring you surprising news about the referendum. And even more surprising news about Nigel Farage and Nick Griffin.

There was convoluted CJEU case law on Sunday trading, but that's not where it ended up. But there's no EU law on sex education or "obscene homework". Perhaps more teenagers would do their homework if there were.

The death penalty for treason was "secretly" abolished. By an Act of Parliament you can find online in seconds (as he's correctly cited it, surprisingly) - legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1998/37/…

There's more along these lines, but let's move on to the author of this screed. Unlike the author of the FB post, he put his name on it: David Noakes.

Surprise! He has a conspiracy theory about (((you guys))) too. Ngl, I was hoping for ((((space lasers)))) here...cst.org.uk/news/blog/2014…

Yup, he was a candidate for the UKIP leadership. Note the glowing character reference

Let's move on to his encounters with the courts. A tribunal ruling of sex discrimination - which brings us back to his approach to medical regulation...
outsourcing-pharma.com/Article/2015/1…

Ultimately resulting in a criminal conviction and custodial sentence for selling unlicensed medicine - a supposed "cure" for cancer, HIV and autism
bbc.co.uk/news/world-eur…

And a confiscation order for £1.3 million
bbc.co.uk/news/world-eur…

He also faced trial in France, and legged it on bail from a European Arrest Warrant - but was eventually found, and the EAW was executed during the withdrawal agreement transition period
bbc.co.uk/news/world-eur…

Leading to a recent conviction, and a further custodial sentence, in France

I don't know how many people, besides my discussant last night, fell for the "eutruth" website. But I know that loads of people fell for the FB post, which is only relatively less deranged. We are where we are.

Evidence of other people failing for the "eutruth" website, via @Jim_Cornelius

And several more falling for it -

A word from Siemens about (((that))) conspiracy theory

Looks like Noakes also has a link to the "UK Column" site, which reportedly does climate change denial (and perhaps covid stuff, in light of Ivor C) too -

Share this Scrolly Tale with your friends.

A Scrolly Tale is a new way to read Twitter threads with a more visually immersive experience.
Discover more beautiful Scrolly Tales like this.

Keep scrolling