Thread by @MarsilioMusing

Answering with data - see thread to follow

I'm loosely familiar with McWhirter's idea that peak of cycle is NN in Taurus & this makes sense from a Moon exaltation view, also sign of resources

But here I'm going to look at DJI data in a few different ways
1900-current, all markets & bull only
1945-current, ditto
1980-

DJI 1900-current
all markets first

Aries negative but maybe when including 2 world wars & global great depression that had something to do with it

But we cannot say Taurus standout

Taking out the nasty bits

DJI 1900-current, bull markets only

Pisces & Cancer on top

1945-current, all markets

Taurus looks better but not best by a long shot

Earth signs doing well though

1945-current, bull markets only

Cancer winning

I don't think people would have expected that but does make sense!

1980-current, all markets

Taurus on top

Problem with 41 years is less incidence

1980-current, bull only

Cancer winning again

Even though 2nd lowest in all markets

Means Cancer skittish and easily down in negative environment
In positive environment comfortable and does well

Taurus wasn't the worst and did well in some of these

But not like we can say, NN in Taurus is always the peak

Just doesn't work that way

I don't like static cycles, because the conditions are always different
Meaning every new moon / full moon...
Every NN in Taurus
Whatever!