1/ Peloton's predicament is an opportunity to practice your unit economics skills.
"Average net monthly connected fitness churn, which Peloton uses to measure retention of connected fitness subscribers, ticked up to 0.73% from 0.52% a year earlier." cnbc.com/amp/2021/08/26…
2/ Gross Margin: 32.6%
Bill Gurley: "There is a huge difference between companies with high gross margins and those with lower gross margins. Using the DCF framework, you cannot generate much cash from a revenue stream that is saddled with large, variable costs."
3/ Assume to keep the math simple that Peloton ARPU is $39 a month. How high can customer acquisition cost (CAC) be and generate 10% ROIC? Remember, any equipment subsidy is part of CAC.
You are "solving for" CAC. Invert!
Extra credit: estimate unaddressed TAM & CAC impact.
4/ TAM is hard to determine since it requires predictions about the future.
If you encounter someone who claims you can value a stock without making predictions about the future, RUN!!!
Seth Klarman: "You must predict the future, yet the future is not reliably predictable.”
5/ Simba: "Is TAM best thought of as a probability distribution with a range of possible outcomes?
Mufasa: "Exactly. But there are clues. For example, a rising CAC is a sign you are starting to reach a TAM ceiling. Everything is connected in the Great Circle of Unit Economics."
6/ Simba: "So Peloton can be valued on a per subscriber bottoms up basis like a cable or mobile operator?"
Mufasa: "Any business can be valued that way. The sum of the value of all present and future customers is equal to the value of the business. As Rza often says: 'CREAM.'"
7/ Simba: "I've heard you say you have a feel for how unit economics factors interact."
Mufasa: "We have instrumented our processes and hired data scientists for a reason. Any CBCV variable can kill you. For example, ignoring what happens below the gross margin line is deadly."
Share this Scrolly Tale with your friends.
A Scrolly Tale is a new way to read Twitter threads with a more visually immersive experience.
Discover more beautiful Scrolly Tales like this.