Not North vs South. Not Red vs Blue. It’s a 10-year trick that made neighbors fight. We’ll walk the timeline like a comic: who pushed what, how our brains got hacked, and how to beat it. Welcome to THE FAKE CIVIL WAR. Buckle up.
Right 2015–2016
Rallies felt like a concert. Big words—“FIGHT,” “ENEMY WITHIN.” That plants a thought: “People around you are dangerous.” When fear moves in, thinking moves out. That’s the first brick in a fake war.
Left 2015–2016
At the same time, the Left blasted “TRUMP = HITLER.” Scary label → easy share. Fear vs fear. When both sides only say “monster,” nobody checks facts. That’s how a meme becomes a mask you put on strangers.
Right 2017–2019
Marches with torches, “blood and soil,” edgy memes. Street shouting > real talk. Online chats started using “civil war” like it was a game level. Spoiler: level up the drama, level down the truth.
Left 2017–2019
Pink-hat seas. “RESIST!” everywhere. Loud can be good, but constant yelling makes ears stop working. If every post is an alarm, real alarms blend in with the noise. That’s how we miss the plot.
Psychology Mirror
Repeat anything long enough and it feels true. That’s the Illusory Truth Effect. “Fake news!” vs “Resist!”—same brain button, different stickers. Hear, share, repeat… and boom, it sounds like a fact.
Right 2020
Pandemic hits. Some crowds rip masks, shout “HOAX.” Anger gives quick power, but it also gives quick poison. When rage leads, math and medicine get pushed off the stage. The crowd cheers; the facts cough.
Left 2020
“Silence is violence” took off. Posting became a test: speak or be shamed. That swaps curiosity for fear. Good people froze, bad info flew. The machine doesn’t care which team shouts—only that we keep shouting.
Bandwagon Effect
When it looks like “everyone’s saying it,” your brain wants to join. That’s the Bandwagon Effect. The trick: make noise big and fast so it feels like a crowd, even when it’s a handful plus bots.
Right 2021–2023
After Jan 6, “CIVIL WAR?” talk exploded online. Costumes, flags, cosplay tough-guy vibes. Drama sells. The more we click the show, the more the show gets renewed. Ratings beat reality—again.
Left 2021–2023
Then came “DEMOCRACY IS DEAD.” Maybe you felt that in your stomach. Fear can warn us, but it can also blind us. If every day is “the last day,” we forget to do the boring stuff that actually saves democracy.
In-Group vs Out-Group
Red fist vs Blue fist. “We’re the real patriots!” “We’re the real defenders!” Same cartoon, new colors. The line between teams keeps getting taller. The higher the wall, the easier we are to herd.
Right 2024–2025 (Martyr Cycle)
When a leader gets hurt or dies, some accounts push “martyr” talk to spark more heat. Grief is real. The weaponization of grief is also real. The machine turns pain into gasoline.
Left 2024–2025 (“Last Election”)
“THIS IS THE LAST ELECTION!” posts flood feeds. Panic is a remote control for your brain. It makes you sprint past nuance and smash the share button. Addiction to urgency = obedience on autoplay.
Villains: Binder Brigade + Tech Oligarchs
It’s not your neighbors. It’s script-writers with money and megaphones. Think binders of talking points + platforms that boost outrage. They don’t pick a side; they pick engagement. Rage that pays gets raised.
The Money Machine (PACs)
PAC dollars pour in like a firehose. Money buys ads, lawyers, data, and reach. You don’t see the pipes—you just feel the splash. If a message keeps showing up everywhere, follow the funding, not the vibes.
Bot Armies (Reply Swarms)
Ever get 50 replies in 5 minutes from sketchy accounts? That’s a reply swarm. Copy-paste insults, fake “consensus,” real silence. The goal isn’t to win an argument. It’s to make you stop talking.
Fear Loops
Both sides say: “If THEY win, everything you love dies.” That’s a fear loop. It locks you in a bunker where all news sounds like sirens. Scared brains share fast, check slow. The machine loves that.
The Algorithm
Platforms boost the loudest, angriest words because anger = clicks and clicks = cash. “RAGE, TRAITOR, INVASION” pump the scoreboard. Calm facts?
Benched. You’re not the customer—you’re the product.
Real-World Impact
Online scripts become podium lines. Donations steer what gets said and who gets heard. It’s not mind control; it’s message control. When the same money writes the tune, the band plays it everywhere.
Mirror Recap
Four tricks run the show: Illusory Truth (repeat → feels true), Bandwagon (looks popular → join), In-Group (us good), Fear (them scary). Same playbook, different jerseys. Learn the moves, break the spell.
Who’s Really to Blame?
Not regular people. The fight is staged by binder-brigade operators and platform power. They drop cash and code from above while we swing below. If we keep punching each other, they keep winning.
What We Learned (Attention War)
Your attention is the trophy. The show makes Red vs Blue punch forever so the ads stay green. Crisis spikes juice the meter. Step back, breathe, ask: “Who benefits if I’m mad right now?” Hint: not you.
Final Splash
This “civil war” was scripted. We can end the scene. Shake a neighbor’s hand. Mute the rage bait. Boost receipts over rumors. Remember: it was never us vs each other. It was us vs manipulation. Thread ends. Now act.
Share this Scrolly Tale with your friends.
A Scrolly Tale is a new way to read Twitter threads with a more visually immersive experience.
Discover more beautiful Scrolly Tales like this.