Stephen McIntyre Profile picture
Aug 29, 2018 32 tweets 11 min read Read on X
1/ in 2008, historian Mary Hershberger re-appraised John McCain's statement that "I’m an old Navy pilot. I know when a crisis calls for all hands on deck" in connection with 1967 catastrophe on USS Forrestal in which 134 dead/missing and 161+ injured.
truthdig.com/report/item/20…
2/ catastrophic fire and explosion of multiple bombs resulted from concatenation of events described in official report jag.navy.mil/library/invest…. McCain was in jet at epicenter, but luckily managed to walk away unscathed, while everyone around him perished or seriously injured.
3/ over the years, there have been rumors, that McCain, then a reckless flyboy (more recently merely reckless), precipitated incident through "wet-start" of jet engine. While his safety motto was "to hell with checklist", he was cleared of fault. But proven conduct troubling.
4/ while enlisted men were dying in the fight against fire and explosions on deck, McCain reported by Hershberger to have gone to pilot's ready room and watched fire on a television monitor.
5/ next day McCain commended heroism of enlisted men: "we're professional military men and I suppose it's our war. And yet here were enlisted men who earn $150 a month and work 18 to 20 hours a day...and certainly would have survived had they not stayed to help pilots fight fire"
6/ on day after the holocaust, only "hours after", McCain recalled their heroism to NYT reporter from comfort of villa in Saigon
graphics8.nytimes.com/packages/flash…
7/ three months later, NYT reporter RW Apple recalled McCain "sipping scotch" with friends in Saigon on day after Forrestal holocaust
graphics8.nytimes.com/packages/flash…
8/ Hershberger reported that, while fellow sailors and airmen were wounded and dying, McCain, the admiral's son, apparently without naval permission, hopped on the NYT reporter's helicopter and decamped for "some welcome R&R" in Saigon, thus missing funeral for fallen.
9/ McCain's lack of interest in the funeral of his fallen comrades might be considered as US thinks about how to commemorate his death
10/ McCain then hared off to London, where his father, the admiral, was stationed. Then, while his injured shipmates recuperated slowly, mourning the dead, McCain, still presumably on active service, went to the French Riviera where he idled nights away gambling.
11/ Hershberger, a reputable journalist, had trouble publishing her 2008 story in major outlets. John Dean, in contemporary article, supreme.findlaw.com/legal-commenta… endorsed Hershberger's credibility. In interview, many further McCain myths punctured.
12/ McCain grew up in Washington DC, where he attended elite schools. He was not an "outsider". He grew up in the swamp as child of prominent admiral.
13/ Rolling Stone published revealing profile in 2008, eviscerating McCain. rollingstone.com/politics/polit…
14/ and yet, only 10 years later, McCain is venerated by US media as some sort of modern saint - perhaps the most recent and one of the most bizarre manifestations of Trump Derangement Syndrome.
15/ an editorial today thetimes-tribune.com/opinion/mourni… praised McCain for "his old-fashioned civility in political battle". An odd statement given McCain's actual history.
16/ a good example of rollingstone.com/politics/polit… McCain's "civility" is this repugnant 1998 joke about teen-age Chelsea Clinton who, whatever one thinks of her now, didn't deserve such contumely from the odious McCain.
17/ RollingStone reported a 1992 incident in which the odious McCain screeched slurs at the wife whose fortune supported him for daring to mention that his hair was "getting a little thin on top".
18/ they recall another incident in which McCain, prone to temper tantrums since he was a child, threatened to go to blows with Sen. Grassley, who, unlike McCain, is a model of dignity, intelligence and decorum, but whose passing is unlikely to be nationally commemorated.
19/ McCain screamed at young campaign aide who failed to set up podium to conceal McCain's shortness.
20/ in 2008, even Republican senators were seriously worried about the volatile and crazed McCain
21/ McCain recklessly promoted war in Iraq, long before Bush put it on the table. He deserves extra share of blame for subsequent morass for US.
22/ in the cause of Middle Eastern destruction, McCain promoted false stories of connection between Saddam Hussein and AlQaeda and false stories of Iraqi WMD.
23/ Rolling Stone rollingstone.com/politics/polit… list more fiascos up to 2008. McCain was just getting started: Libya, Syria, Yemen were still to come.
24/ James Bond famously said "Once is an accident. Twice is a coincidence. Three times is an enemy action." Similar rules applied to accidents of navy pilots. Yet before he was shot down and prior to Forrestal incident, McCain had downed three planes and had mayhem reputation
25/ other than insider pull, there was no reason for McCain to qualify as pilot. "His record at the U.S. Naval Academy was dismal. He piled up demerits for breaking the rules, and barely passed his schoolwork, graduating 894th in a class of 899." pythiapress.com/wartales/McCai…
26/ his first crash, blamed on a stalled engine, was into Gulf of Mexico. But investigators "started the recovered engine without any problem, and their report left open the possibility of pilot error." pythiapress.com/wartales/McCai…
27/ McCain's next downed airplane resulted from him flying into power lines in Spain while hot-dogging. Even tho second incident and downing power lines and airplane damage, pampered scion of admiral's family kept privileges.
28/ third crash: McCain commandeered navy plane to navy airplane to fly from Norfolk to Philadelphia to attend the Army-Navy football game. "the plane’s engine quit, he said, so he bailed out". Another airplane destroyed with impunity for pampered McCain
29/ McCain's 4th lost plane was in Forrestal incident where he was at center of holocaust, said to start after rocket hit McCain's plane. As discussed above, McCain abandoned firefighting to watch from lounge, than abandoned ship on reporter's helicopter for R&R in Saigon
30/ McCain was shot down while bombing Hanoi (his 5th incident), but his downing was, in considerable measure, due to his failure to carry out avoidance tactics - see excerpt - that were routinely carried out by more disciplined pilots i.e. all other pilots.
31/ McCain's own account of incident reveals his failure to "follow instructions in combat". McCain flew too low and was downed by anti-aircraft fire. McCain later lied about incident in his book and political campaigns: despite records, he claimed to have been downed by SAM.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Stephen McIntyre

Stephen McIntyre Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @ClimateAudit

May 12
in April 2022, Mark Steyn, on his GB News show
,
commented on recently released UK COVID data, claiming "the third booster shots so zealously promoted by the British state, and its groupthink media has failed, and in fact exposed you to significantly greater risk of infection, hospitalization and death."
Steyn showed images of five tables from official statistical publications to support his claims.
In April 2023, Ofcom, which, in addition to its ordinary regulatory role, had taken a special interest in vaccine advocacy, ruled that Steyn's "presentation of UK Health Security Agency data
and their use to draw conclusions materially misled the audience. In breach of Rule 2.2 of the Broadcasting Code" - a very damaging finding that Steyn has appealed.


I haven't followed this case. However, as it happens, I had taken an interest in UK COVID data about 3 months earlier, as it was one of the few jurisdictions that published case and hospitalization rates by vaccination status.


Also, to refresh readers on the contemporary context, early 2022 was the period in which COVID lockdowns and overall alarm began to decline.

At the time, I observed that the UK data showed that the case rate for triple vax was //higher// than among unvax. Three months later, Steyn (as discussed below) made a similar claim, for which he was censured.

Although the UK authorities conspicuously refrained from including this result in their summary or conclusions, they were obviously aware of the conundrum, since their publication included a curious disclaimer by UK authorities that actual case data "should not be used" to estimate vaccine effectiveness. I pointed this odd disclaimer out in this earlier thread, also noting that health authorities in Ontario and elsewhere had previously used such data to promote vaccine uptake and that the reasoning behind this disclaimer needed to be closely examined and parsed.

All of these issues turned up later in the Ofcom decision re Steyn.

Ofcom ruled that Steyn's presentation was "materially misleading" because
(1) he failed to take account of "fundamental biases" in age structure of vax and unvax groups i.e. unvax group was skewed younger, vax group skewed older; and
(2) he failed to include the disclaimer that "This raw data should not be used to estimate vaccine effectiveness as the data does not take into account inherent biases present such as differences in risk, behaviour and testing in the vaccinated and unvaccinated populations”.steynonline.com/mark-steyn-sho…
ofcom.org.uk/__data/assets/…
Image
in this thread, I'll re-examine Steyn's analysis. I've transcribed all the numbers in the tables and done further calculations to check his claims.

First, case rates. Steyn first showed an important table showing the population by 5-year age group and vax status, observing that the total population of triply vax (boosted) was approximately equal to the population of unboosted, observing that this facilitated comparison. Steyn: "Let's take a look at this, as you can see from a pool of 63 million down at the bottom there, 63 million, there are 32 million who are triple vaccinated. That leaves just under 31 million, who are either double single or unvaccinated. So we have two groups of similar size, 31, 32 million. So it's relatively easy to weigh the merits of the third shot upon Group A versus group B."

He then showed a table of cases by age group and vax status, pointing out that the total number of boosted cases was approximately double the number of unboosted cases: "So the triple vaccinated in March were responsible for just over a million COVID cases and everybody else 475,000 COVID cases. So the triple vaccinated are contracting COVID at approximately twice the rate of the double, single and unvaccinated. Got that? If you get the booster shot, you've got twice as high a chance of getting the COVID. In the United Kingdom, there's twice as many people with the third booster shot who got the COVID, as the people who never had the booster shot."Image
Image
Ofcom purported to rebut Steyn's analysis as shown in excerpt below. They observed that proportion of unvax in younger age groups was much higher than in older age groups and that the "simple comparison between the two groups made by Mark Steyn failed to take into account these inherent biases".

However, Ofcom failed to show that there would be a different outcome in the more complex analysis in which age groups were allowed for.

As it turns out, in regard to case rates, Steyn's conclusions, if anything, under-stated the phenomenon, as shown next.Image
Read 11 tweets
Apr 19
here is a thread from 2023 in which Eric Ciaramella's "yikes" is placed in a more detailed context.

In this thread, I suggested that the linkage was connected to Jan 21, 2016 meeting of Ukrainian prosecutors with State Dept officials, noting that Jamie Gusack (reporting to Bridget Brink) had distributing the first demand for Shokin's head (Nov 22 TPs)Image
Image
as pointed out in that thread, Gusack (State Dept) had been coordinating with Ciaramella (NSC) prior to arrival of Ukr prosecutors in Jan 2016, referring to Shokin replacement.

State Dept cited "diamond prosecutors case" as big deal. But what happened to it next? A long story. Image
Bridget Brink, Jamie Gusack's boss, reported to Victoria Nuland. Brink was appointed Ambassador to Ukraine in April 2022. Unanimous approval by Senate in early days of war at the exact time that US and UK were sabotaging the peace deal negotiated in Istanbul Image
Read 4 tweets
Mar 17
as observed yesterday, , after 2014 US coup, the tsunami of billion dollar US/IMF loans was associated with unprecedented embezzlement by Ukr oligarchs thru corrupt Ukr banking system. Rescues of failed banks (mostly unnoticed in west) were markers
in today's thread, I'll provide a short bibliography of articles (mostly Ukrainian language via google translate) on the Ukr banking corruption crisis that began and exploded after the 2014 US coup, while Biden, Blinken, Nuland et al were running Ukraine
once one searches specifically for the topic, there are interesting references, but the topic has received essentially next to zero coverage in the west. I'll take myself as an example. Despite following Ukr affairs quite closely, my prior knowledge was three vignettes.
Read 15 tweets
Mar 16
May 25, 2021: US DOJ announced indictment & arrest of Austrian banker Peter Weinzierl


Mar 13, 2024: we learn that Alexander Smirnov was an FBI informant against Weinzierl and had lured Weinzierl to UK on behalf of FBI for arrest justice.gov/usao-edny/pr/t…
archive.is/zO1rt

Image
Image
the DOJ charges against Austrian banker Weinzierl, filed during first six months of Biden admin, pertained to allegations that payments made via Meinl Bank in Austria by Brazilian construction company Odebrecht were connected to evasion of taxes in Brazil. Image
if the concern of US DOJ and FBI with administration of Brazilian tax collection seems somewhat quirky, there may be an ulterior motive: Meinl Bank had a central role in the looting of Ukrainian banks during the 2014-2016 Biden administration of Ukraine. Image
Read 11 tweets
Mar 3
Valentyn Nalyvaichenko, named by NYT as architect of 2014 post-Maidan takeover of Ukrainian intelligence by CIA, is former head of Ukrainian SBU. His comments on Biden corruption deserve attention, but have been ignored.archive.is/zXXQV
on October 10, 2019, early in the Trump impeachment saga, Nalyvaichenko published an op ed in Wall St Journal saying "alliance with US depends on answering questions about Bidens and election interference" [by Ukraine] archive.is/wsrjP
Image
in that editorial, Naluvaichenko, the former SBU hear, stated that Ukraine had responsibility to investigate allegations that Ukraine interfered in 2016 election (a separate issue from Russian interference) and whether Burisma hired Hunter Biden for "cynical purposes". Image
Read 6 tweets
Mar 1
as Svetlana @RealSLokhova explained to us, intelligence fabricators (like Halper) begin by juxtaposing two targets in the same room and using that juxtaposition for their smear.

But, Weiss' Smirnov operation did exactly the opposite. I'll explain. twitter.com/search?lang=en…
Image
Smirnov had multiple Burisma contacts in 2017-Jan 2018, that are provable by email and travel records. See diagram below.
But, according to Weiss, instead of attaching narrative to provable meetings, Smirnov attached his narrative to non-existent contacts in 2015-16 and 2019. Image
Obvious question: why would Smirnov attach his narrative to fabricated meetings/telecons, when he had multiple real meetings/telecons to which he could have attached the narrative just as easily?
Read 7 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(