Bob Profile picture
Jan 29, 2019 30 tweets 13 min read Read on X
Let’s talk about #Socialism.

This will be an open discussion about a political/economic theory.
It is NOT to support ANY candidate or platform.
It is purely for education so we’re “on the same page” with this topic.

#ResistanceEducation

👇Long thread👇
Another quick note:

If you are NOT a socialist, that’s great!
You should still read this brief overview so you can understand the current arguments of the socialist debate.

At the end I’d love to hear any questions.

Ok, let’s get started.
At its core, socialism is simply the name applied to a group of theories critical of capitalism.

As old as capitalism is (depending on definition), socialism is only a few minutes younger.
I’m not going to talk about early utopian & Christian socialist trends, aside to note that they were there.

Instead I’ll be focusing on Marx and his mature economic theories (NOT the “Communist Manifesto”, which is simply well-written propaganda).
Socialism as an economic theory starts with a simple question: what is profit?

Phrased another way: if I own a firm that produces widgets, and you sell your labor to me for $10/hr, how much money am I making from you?

This is not a trivial question.
If you make $10/hr, you have to transfer more value to me than that for me to make a profit.

If a widget sells on the market for $15, and you can make 1/hr, that means you GIVE me $5/hr more in labor than I pay you.

This is called exploitation.
The “extra” $5/hr is not just pocketed though. There are material costs for these widgets, machine costs, and maintenance costs as well.

However, these costs can never equal the $5 because then the capitalist would have no profit.
This leads us to a simple breakdown of what the market price for any commodity represents:

P = W + C + S

P: price
W: wages
C: materials/machine/etc costs
S: surplus

This is also where most people who have studied economics jump in and scream about markets.
The criticism is that supply and demand dictate price so there is no way to compose it from the “ground up” like this without acknowledging that firms place a markup on their products.

Which is exactly true.

The markup covers the “S” in the above equation.
So what is the surplus and where does it go?

Capitalists cannot simply pocket all of it, they need to pay for other social costs and for other employees (managers etc) who don’t actually produce products directly.

Only then can they pocket their profits.
So with this basic introduction to Marxian economics done, what is Marx’s suggestion?

That the person who produced that surplus should have a say in where it goes, who it pays, and how it is used.

That’s it. That’s socialism. Scary right?
Ok, maybe it’s not that simple.
History has a way of making simple things very messy.

Note that this says NOTHING about government, class struggle, social justice, or anything else that gets called socialism.

It’s simply a description of an economic system.
The role of “the state” in socialist theory is generally considered minimal, you may even hear many exclaim “Abolish the state!”.

So where did the idea of state ownership come in to modern notions of socialism?

Lenin, sort of.
One of Lenin’s main contributions to socialist theory is the notion of a “vanguard state”: a government set up to conduct and ease the transition to the “socialist mode of production”.

Later, Stalin would articulate a theory of “Socialism in One Country”.
The basic divide between these two competing ideas comes from the question of how to control the surplus: do the workers directly control it, or do all people in society via a state?

This is no less trivial than the companion debate in capitalist economies.
On the libertarian/anarchist side, the debate focuses on free association and autonomy of workers.

On the centralized side, it focuses on the rights of the society as a whole having a say in what should be done.

It’s a very important debate to have.
With that said, however, the USSR never made it to a true socialist mode of production due to the lack of worker control of the surplus.

It did succeed in state capitalism, which Wilhelm Liebknecht theorized would be the “last stage” of capitalism.
Why is state capitalism different than socialism?

Because there has been no transformation of the workplace; there is no democratic control of the surplus.

It’s that simple (remember the economic discussion above).
What role does class play in socialist theory?

The central role!

All this talk of workers and labor is really a nod to the notion of a working class.
The class that actually PRODUCES the surplus.
The “proletariat”.
Capitalists (the “bourgeoisie) are the ones who control the distribution of the surplus in capitalism.
The lords did it in feudalism; the masters in slave economies.

The other classes in Marxist theory are the subsumed class and petite bourgeoisie.
The subsumed class are the people who we would call white collar workers; they don’t produce the surplus directly, but are paid to maintain the system of exploitation.

The subsumed class is payed with a portion of the surplus not pocketed as profits.
The petite bourgeoisie is the name given to those who have the common “American Dream”: the small shop keepers, small commodities traders, etc.

They may produce surplus, or not.

Self awareness of what class you’re in is called “class consciousness”.
Where does social justice fit into Marxist theory?

It does so only tangentially: the basic premise of Marxian economics, and Marxist (note the difference!) politics is that class struggle and ending exploitation is paramount to all other issues.
If you’ve made it this far, let me first apologize for this being so long.

Second, thank you for actually reading this and (hopefully) considering it.

Third, I’d like to emphasize that this is just an overview of some basic aspects of Socialist theory.
Lastly, I’d like to add that I am not actually a Marxist (so you may want to read Marxists to see if you are or aren’t) and that there are many other theorists of socialism that are well worth researching.
If your more inclined to social justice, you may want to read up on some forms of “utopian socialism”.

Notable authors include Fourier, Saint-Simon, and Owens.

Engles’ “Socialism: Utopian and Scientific” is also a good read.
Suggested reading:

“Das Kapital”, “Critique of the Gotha Program”
-Marx

“Evolutionary Socialism”
-Bernstein

“Social Reform or Revolution”
-Luxemburg

“Anarcho-Syndicalism”
-Rocker

“The Poverty of Historicism”
-Popper

“The Ecology of Freedom”
-Bookchin
Resources:

marxists.org/index-mobiles.… is an extensive online library of socialis theorists.

@BlackSocialists has an excellent website with lots of great info.

@jacobinmag, @monthly_review & @SocialistViews are socialist magazines.
Ok, now it’s question time.

If you’d like to ask me a real question, or would like to debate a particular point, I’m more than willing to.

If I don’t respond, and your question isn’t just bashing socialism, please tag me.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Bob

Bob Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @BOB_1and_only

Aug 30, 2020
.@nick_brana opens the #PeoplesConvention with an overview of the argument: we need a party free from corporate interference if we want to reign in corporate greed.

Seems like a no brained to me, and many out there regardless of party affiliations.
It’s quite refreshing to see some of these film shorts portraying what the average person is really experiencing.

Not nice, clean, polished language, but the real grit and dirt of life for the majority.
@HaniehJBarnes elucidates what life is like at the other end of the US imperialist machine.

Ending endless wars is a bipartisan issue, but both parties seem to be dragging their feet. What would we expect with so much 💰 to be made? Image
Read 29 tweets
Feb 13, 2020
‼️PROGRESSIVES‼️

We must remember down-ballot candidates.

This is a list of progressive/leftist congressional candidates endorsed by at least one of these groups:

@BrandNew535
@BoldProgressive
@justicedems
@pdamerica
@RoseCaucus

#UniteLeft
#Progress2020
Please remember:

⚠️STATE CANDIDATE PRIMARIES MAY BE ON DIFFERENT DATES THAN THE PRESIDENTIAL PRIMARY⚠️

Double check your registration at least 1 MONTH 🗓 before any election you plant to vote in.

Also, endorsements are an ongoing process
Some races have 2 different candidates endorsed by different groups, so they’re both listed.

Legend:
📖➡️ platform/issues link
💵➡️ donation link

If the pinned tweet is related to their campaign, I included it.

Now, onto the (long) list.
Read 83 tweets
Apr 11, 2019
What is a “Mixed Economy”?

Most say that the US has one, and that “pure economies” don’t exist anymore, but what does that mean?

What is this thing we have which is used to justify both reform & the status quo?

#ResistanceEducation

👇LONG THREAD👇
This won’t be a discussion supporting any candidate/platform, but it will contain criticisms of theories that some support.

It will be a frank discussion about this curious concept which is so amorphous it’s used to justify opposite positions simultaneously.
One of the issues with this term is that it has 2 commonly used meanings: one purely economic, the other more politically/philosophically prescriptive.

Most of the common (mis)uses stem from conflating these two notions.
Read 26 tweets
Mar 17, 2019
Here’s this week’s rundown of what’s going on in the #FloridaLegislature.

A few bills covering campaigns & elections, and a continuation of the FL GOP’s war against poor people.

#InformFlorida
#FactsFirstFlorida
#TakeActionFL

👇THREAD👇
CS/HB 689 - allowing voting machines that produce “voter-verified ballots”
Introducers: @RepFitzenhagen (R), @Mel_Ponder (R)

CS passed Oversight 12:0, now in Public Integrity

#ElectionIntegrity
#PaperBallots
HB 615 - deletes provisions for public funding of elections

Passed Oversight 7:5, (@AnnaForFlorida, @KimDanielsFl, @RepBobbyDuBose, @GoodforFlorida, @Javierfor114 voted no)
Now in Public Integrity.

#MoneyInPolitics
#CampaignFinance

Read 14 tweets
Feb 3, 2019
As we see debates about increasing the top marginal tax rate, and even talk of a max income, I think it’s important to talk about what happened during the long reign of one of the greatest presidents of all time: FDR.

#IncomeInequality
#ResistanceEducation
FDR’s election happened during the height of the Great Depression, during which labor movements in the US were at an all time high.

This organization amongst labor, coupled with strong socialist and communist parties within the US, led to increased pressure.
This pressure was applied mainly to corporations and politicians of the time, but was also used in small struggles for better working conditions.

It was in these “trial-battles” that groups like the AFL & CIO (modern @AFLCIO) gained strength and skill.
Read 12 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(