the fertility decline in modern europe began in france in ca. the 1830s and then spread to other nations *before* things like higher population density and higher urbanization existed and quite separately from the industrial revolution. nber.org/papers/w25957 h/t @Sam_Schulman!
fertility transition in france and cousin marriage in france (in the 20th century).
=P
"[Blanc] also finds that subscriptions to Diderots Encyclopédie is negatively correlated with fertility across French départements in 1831, even when controlling for industrial
output per capita, urbanization, literacy and pre-industrial development."
note that the fertility decline in france appears to predate the revolution. it was already being commented upon in 1778:
"It was difficult or downright impossible, many Chinese would argue, to remain silent during this campaign. To remain silent was to risk being attacked oneself. At best, people attacked to avoid being attacked." books.google.com/books?id=ShGfc…#StruggleSessions
"Of the true believers, many were convinced not only that struggle and violence were necessary for the achievement of revolutionary goals but also that the sacrifice of a few innocent people was the inevitable price to be paid." #StruggleSessionsbooks.google.com/books?id=ShGfc…
thread of threads/tweets of mine from 2019 i'd like to highlight. (^_^)
remember: evolution can be recent, rapid, local, and is ongoing. the forces of evolution are: mutation, selection, (gene) migration, and genetic drift. also, pop viscosity matters. 1/n
long thread on the communal field systems of medieval nw "core" europe. these pushed strongly for cooperation and conformity among comparatively unrelated, outbred nuclear families. [scroll up and down] 3/n