Leaks from the peer review lottery of a very reputable conference for information system research. (Scale from 1 to 5) #openpeerreview 
Legend:
1 = "Definite reject: I would argue strongly for rejecting this submission."
5 = "Definite accept: I would argue strongly for accepting this submission."
My evaluation (3) : "Borderline: Overall I would not argue for accepting this submission."
#lasttweet
1 = "Definite reject: I would argue strongly for rejecting this submission."
5 = "Definite accept: I would argue strongly for accepting this submission."
My evaluation (3) : "Borderline: Overall I would not argue for accepting this submission."
#lasttweet
Outcome: the associate editor assigned a "2", defined as "Probably reject: I would argue for rejecting this submission."
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
