#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: Day 9 hearing commences; CS Vaidyanathan resumes his arguments.

#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: CS Vaidyanathan citing precedents on adverse possession and ownership.

"There has never been any adverse possession in this case. Hindus have always expressed their desire to worship at this place", Vaidyanathan.
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: Discussion now happening on how question of adverse possession will arise only if the property is alienable.
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: The property itself being birthplace of Ram and a deity, it is res extra commercium. Thus, there is no question of anyone putting up a mosque there and claiming adverse possession, CS Vaidyanathan argues.
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: There cannot be a destruction of an idol or temple. Even if there is no temple, the place itself has sanctity which will always remain, CS Vaidyanathan.
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: The property is res extra commercium and cannot be transferred, sold, alienated or dealt with in any manner, argues Vaidyanathan.

#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: In Hindu law unlike in Mohammaden law, a person in the capacity of trustee or Shabait cannot alienate the property, submits Vaidyanathan.
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: Discussion happening now on whether property can be alienated and when the same can be done.
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: Whether a mosque is a juristic person or not?

Vaidyanathan citing 1940 judgment in Masjid Shahid Ganj case.

He says that judgment never answered that question conclusively, says Vaidyanathan.
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: This place due to the very fact that Ram was born here has divinity and needs to be treated differently, CS Vaidyanathan.
Ayodhya Hearing: Live Updates from Supreme Court [Day 9] #RamMandir #AyodhyaHearing #SupremeCourt

#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: Bench rises for lunch, hearing to resume at 2 pm.
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: Bench resumes hearing.

CJI Ranjan Gogoi asks CS Vaidyanathan to close his arguments.

#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: Their suits having been dismissed as time barred, how can they grant relief to them in my suit when most of the findings are in my favour, Vaidyanathan asks.
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: The trial was by a Full Bench of High Court.

Supreme Court should be circumspect while interfering with the findings of High Court, Vaidyanathan concludes arguments.
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: Senior Advocate PN Mishra commences arguments.
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: PN Mishra is making submissions on behalf of Ram Janmabhoomi Punaruddhar Samiti.

#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: Are you party to the suit, asks CJI Ranjan Gogoi.

"I am. I am defendant no. 20 in suit 4", replies PN Mishra.
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: I will argue that based on our doctrine, tenets and beliefs, it is a temple. I will start with Atharva Veda, submits PN Mishra.
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: It is our case that Babur never built a mosque there and Hindus have been worshipping at that place all along, submits PN Mishra.
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: PN Mishra relying on Skanda Purana, Valmiki Ramayana to argue on exact location of Ram Janmasthan.
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: Hindu texts as the basis for faith is not disputed; what we really need are objective parameters, documentary evidence for temple, Bench tells PN Mishra.
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: Bench is more interested in objective evidence than references to scriptures.
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: Justice Chandrachud asks what is the relevance of who built the mosque - be it Babur or somebody else?

Was there a mosque? Thats what is relevant, Justice Chandrachud to PN Mishra.
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: Bench says they will hear PN Mishra later.

Now SC moves on to VN Sinha who is appearing for President of Hindu Mahasabha.
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: Sinha raising the point of title claimed by Muslims.

Once territory of Awadh was annexed to British empire, all structures raised on the soil also got annexed to Britain, Sinha says.
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: Bench objects, says territory annexed means sovereignty is lost; Does not mean all structures in the territory is vested with the empire.
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: Sinha says he did not think his turn to argue would come today.

"I thought I would be asked to argue at the very end", says Sinha.

"Is anybody in suit no. 5 ready to argue", asks CJI Ranjan Gogoi.
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: Now Senior Advocate Ranjit Kumar making arguments for plaintiff Gopal Singh who died in 1986 and his son has been substituted.

He is plaintiff in suit no. 1, defendant no. 1 in suit no. 4 and defendant no. 1 in suit 5.
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: My case is that I am a worshipper, submits Ranjit Kumar.
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: Bench rises for the day.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh

Keep Current with Bar & Bench

Bar & Bench Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!


Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @barandbench

Dec 5
A PIL petitioner in #SupremeCourt:

Adv: How was my item called out and gone?

CJI DY Chandrachud: but the CJI has taken oath and retired. The cause of action has lapsed

Adv: the petition is not over just because CJI Gogoi retired
Adv: How will a lawyer from Pune come with three days notice. That too a 71 year old man. How will I make train reservations. Justice Madan Lokur delayed my listing by 8 months. Then CJI Bobde led bench also did not hear #SupremeCourt
CJI: forget about the past. Tell us on merits

Adv: I want Justice Gogoi to pass orders in my labour matter

CJI: there is a judicial decision. How can article 32 plea be filed ?

Adv: dismissal of my plea was by fraud
Read 8 tweets
Dec 5
Gauhati High Court asks Assam Government to ensure a Gynaecologist visits at least twice a month at all the prisons with women prisoners.

"They might feel shy to speak out about their illness. It's a very personal issue, so a Gynaecologist must visit," HC

Bench led by Chief Justice RM Chhaya expresses displeasure over the visits of doctors in prisons only once a month.

"This is like a visit of a judge, which is once a month. You need to increase these visits," CJ Chhaya

Bench is informed that in Assam's Central Prisons, over 187 under trial prisoners are ones, who have got bail but couldn't fulfill bail conditions.
Of these, 134 have been released and 53 continue to languish in jail despite bail.

Read 6 tweets
Dec 5
Delhi High Court orders LNJP Hospital to examine 33-week pregnant woman seeking abortion by 1 PM today

report by @NarsiBenwal

Update: Counsel for LNJP hospital appears before the court and informs that considering the advanced stage of pregnancy, the request for medical termination of pregnancy (MTP) has been rejected by medical board.
#DelhiHighCourt #MTP #pregnancy
Justice Prathiba M Singh is considering the one-page report presented to the court.
#DelhiHighCourt #MTP #pregnancy
Read 31 tweets
Dec 5
#SupremeCourt hears plea seeking directions to State governments for regulation of Transplantation of Human Organs and Tissues Act, 1994 and bringing uniformity in Rules regarding residency and jurisdiction of authorization committee across states with the Central rules
CJI: How can we direct states to implement uniform rules and look at domicile etc

Adv: states are misinterpreting central rules to bring their own rules

Justice PS Narasimha: Health ministry can tell us about inter state organ transplant
CJI: This plea concerns the 1994 act with the objective of regulating the removal of human organs. the transplation rules were notified in feb 1994 which was later modified by the 2014 act. grievace is patient have to submit a domicile certificate if they wish to register.
Read 4 tweets
Dec 5
[Delhi Govt vs LG matter concerning control over services]

SG Tushar Mehta: There are no facts to be controverted but I have filed an IA stating that this matter may have to be referred to be a larger bench

CJI DY Chandrachud: This can be argued when the matter is taken up
Sr Adv AM Singhvi: This IA has been filed after this court had ruled that this matter is not case for reference

CJI: Justice Krishna Murari is not well and thus a date has to be fixed

Singhvi: The IA is in the garb of a review. This cannot be allowed
CJI: What action has to be taken on IA can be decided when the constitution bench hears it. When it assembles it will see it

Singhvi: This will only create delay and such tactics cannot be allowed

CJI: even without IA it can be argued.
Read 5 tweets
Dec 5
Delhi court discharge order of #UmarKhalid and #KhalidSaifi in #Delhiriots case: As far as accused Saifi and Khalid are concerned, I find that allegations made against them relate to Umbrella Conspiracy, rather the conspiracy peculiar to incident investigated in this case.
Order: I have already discussed scope of 2 different conspiracies. Since, Umbrella Conspiracy—larger conspiracy to incite riots in Delhi—is already subject matter of consideration in FIR 59/2020 (UAPA).., these 2 accused are entitled for discharge. #UmarKhalid #KhalidSaifi
Order: There is concept of an Umbrella Conspiracy being the larger conspiracy and several smaller conspiracies hatched under the larger conspiracy. The objective of Umbrella Conspiracy may be wider than the objective of smaller conspiracy. #UmarKhalid #KhalidSaifi
Read 6 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!

This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!


0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy


3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!