Warren Sharp Profile picture
Aug 25, 2019 12 tweets 3 min read Read on X
Insane.

Ryan Grigson killed Andrew Luck's career.

Pressured 16 times per game under Grigson's watch, MOST in NFL & hit MOST of any QB.

From 2012-2015, Grigson drafted just 3 O-Linemen before rd 7:

•Hugh Thornton (trash)
•Jack Mewhort (trash)
•Khaled Holmes (trash)

So sad.
"Injury took my joy of this game away"

About playing for Frank Reich last yr: "am I allowed to have this much fun on a football field?"

He didn't lose his joy last yr, he lost his joy due to frequent injury.

Lesson to all teams that screw around thinking O-Line isn't critical.
How did Ryan Grigson systematically curtail Andrew Luck's career?

Luck started 51 straight games, then missed 26 of his next 45.

An in-depth look at how the decisions a GM made contributed to destroying the career of one of the best young NFL QBs:

sharpfootballanalysis.com/analysis/andre…
It started with spending in free agency.

From 2013-2015, Grigson spent $329M in free agency, for an avg of $110M annually.

The #2 most in the NFL.

He primarily spent on the defensive side.

To offset his defensive spending, he had to make his offense cheaper.

And so he did.
The allocation of cap $ to the offensive side of the ball progressively decreased.

By 2014 & 2015, the Colts offense was a bottom-4 cap hit each year & #2 cheapest overall in the NFL.

Their cheapest position group in 2015?

O-line

Remember: Luck never missed a start until 2015
Who did Grigson use to protect Luck in 2015?

Joe Reitz: an undrafted NCAABB player (not football) signed to play TE, converted to O-Line

Jonotthan Harrison: another undrafted lineman

Thornton & Mewhort - Grigson draft picks. Both washed out of the NFL after their rookie deals.
Grigson also used LT Anthony Castonzo to protect Luck's blindside in 2015. Castonzo was the best player on the line, and was drafted by drafted Bill Polian the year before Grigson was hired.

(Note: Mewhort was better than he sounded. Injuries likewise shortened his career.)
Here's Luck in Grigson's term

Format: pressure % | sack/hit % (per PFF)

2012: 38.1% | 8%
2013: 37.5% | 6%
2014: 36.2% | 5%
2015: 40.2% | 14%
2016: 44.3% | 9%

Luck always played aggressively but the pressures & hits sharply increased in 2015, as O-line $ & talent decreased
Grigson was fired after 2016.

Luck missed 2017.

New GM Ballard gave him a new line in 2018.

Coupled with Reich's play calls, look at the change:

2015: 40.2% | 14%
2016: 44.3% | 9%
2017: ...
2018: 29.5% | 3%

It's not a miracle.

It's choosing not to neglect the O-Line.
Pressures, hits and sacks are not the sole responsibility of any one person.

• GM: for talent on O-Line
• O-line: for performance
• Play-caller: for plays he calls, progressions designed, audible ability entrusted to QB
• QB: for how he plays, moves & gets rid of the ball
But what is undeniable fact:

Under Grigson’s watch, over a five-year span:

• he spent less and less along the offensive line
• provided Luck with weaker and weaker talent for protection
• it resulted in Luck being the most pressured and hit quarterback in the NFL
We can't entirely blame Luck's early retirement on Grigson.

But we know it was a key contributing factor.

I hope this added context to Luck's injury history & serves as a lesson for other GMs about the importance of protecting QBs around the NFL.

More: sharpfootballanalysis.com/analysis/andre…

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Warren Sharp

Warren Sharp Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @SharpFootball

Aug 5, 2025
there is a bad narrative about Mike McDaniel out there

with his QB1, he's 25-13 (65.8%)

#7 best in the NFL

with backup QBs the record is bad

so that makes him a bad HC?

I don't understand that logic at all

and here's something that I'd LOVE to hear people explain to me....
many people think Tua is mediocre

so what does it say about a HC who takes a mediocre QB & gets that QB to be the

*ONLY QB IN THE NFL*

to rank top-5 in EPA AND success in EACH of the last 3 years?

how is the QB mediocre & HC bad but the results are elite?

make it make sense
if you don't think Tua is good, please explain how the HC mastermind of the Dolphins passing attack somehow has the Tua-led passing attack to rank:

#3 in EPA
#3 in success
#2 in YPA
#2 in comp %
#2 in explosive play rate

the last 3 years combined...

but he's a bad HC
Read 4 tweets
Jun 9, 2025
today alone I've seen people refer to Tua as:

- complete embarrassment of a QB
- borderline unserviceable
- pathetic
- garbage

I knew he was somewhat polarizing, but I didn't realize so many people were so out of touch with his actual performance

so let's talk Tua...
did you know in 2024 Tua ranked #4 in EPA & #3 in success?

did you know in 2023 Tua ranked #2 in EPA & #2 in success?

did you know in 2022 Tua ranked #2 in EPA & #5 in success?

did you know Tua is the ONLY QB IN THE NFL to rank top-5 in BOTH EPA & success rate in EACH of the last 3 yrs?
did you know from 2022-2024 combined...

...out of 64 QBs with 200+ attempts, Tua ranks:

#3 in EPA
#3 in success rate
#2 in YPA
#2 in completion rate
#2 in 15+ yard explosive play rate
Read 8 tweets
Apr 26, 2025
best value 2025 NFL draft classes

1. Falcons
2. Browns
3. Cardinals
4. Eagles
5. Giants
6. Chiefs
7. Buccaneers
8. Steelers
9. Ravens
10. Bills

see pic for 1-32 plus methodology

READ FULL ANALYSIS:



team-by-team & round-by-round analysis to follow 🧵 sharpfootballanalysis.com/analysis/nfl-d…Image
2025 NFL draft player values by round:

most underdrafted (best values)

most overdrafted (worst values aka reaches)

Rounds 1-3 by best/worst player: Image
2025 NFL draft player values by round:

most underdrafted (best values)

most overdrafted (worst values aka reaches)

Rounds 4-5 by best/worst player: Image
Read 15 tweets
May 17, 2024
the NFL controls WHEN you play, not WHO you play

I've identified the most important observations of the 2024 schedule you need to know

the schedule is less fair & equitable at a historic level in many areas

let's deep dive into the worst issues 🧵

sharpfootballanalysis.com/betting/teams-…
let's look at schedule equity using a number of variables related to rest & prep

- Net rest edge
- More or less rest than opponent
- Opponent’s days to prep for your game
- Short week road games
- Games off road SNF/MNF
- Negated bye weeks
- 3 games in 10 days (what??!!)

but first let's talk historic inequity
in 2024, there will be 101 games played where a team has more rest than their opponent

the most in history

as recently as the late 2000s, the NFL wouldn't release a schedule that featured even 30% of their games with one team having a rest advantage

we are now up to 37%
Read 32 tweets
Jan 23, 2024
The NFL pushed the panic button 🚨

They have a ref in their rotation who is a MASSIVE edge to road teams

Road teams win at the #1 highest rate with him...

He penalizes home teams in ways no other ref does... and...

He's calling the Chiefs road game

sharpfootballanalysis.com/betting/chiefs…
it was a fascinating decision to put Shawn Smith on the Chiefs game

the last 3 years:

with other refs, home teams win 55.9%

but with Smith, home win rates drop to 40.8%

with other refs, home teams cover the spread 50.1%

but with Smith, home cover rates drop to 37.0%
is this merely coincidental?

or is there a reason why home teams lose so often with him than with other refs?

so I worked with @nflrefstats1 and uncovered some wild penalty trends for Smith

these trends certainly help drive the result of home teams losing as often as they do
Read 7 tweets
May 16, 2023
it's not just WHO you play

the NFL doesn't control that

it's WHEN you play them

the NFL has 100% control of that

they set their schedule

unfortunately, I found the 2023 schedule is less fair & equitable at a historic level in many areas

a deep dive into the worst issues 🧵
let's look at schedule equity using a number of variables related to rest & prep

- Net rest edge
- More or less rest than opponent
- Opponent’s days to prep for your game
- Short week road games
- Games off road SNF/MNF
- Negated bye weeks

but first let's talk historic inequity
in 2023, there will be 95 games played where a team has more rest than their opponent

most in history

as recently as the late 2000s, the NFL wouldn't schedule 30% of there games where one team had a rest advantage

we are now up to 35%
Read 28 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(