25th Justice Sunanda Bhandare Memorial Lecture to be delivered by Dr. Upendra Baxi on

"How to Engender the Basic Structure Doctrine? The Elusive Future of Women's Rights as Human Rights"

Attorney General for India, KK Venugopal to preside. @htTweets Image
#JusticeSunandaBhandareLecture: I used to be a progressive feminist. I don't use 'ladies and gentlemen'.

I say gentle persons, says Dr. Upendra Baxi.
#JusticeSunandaBhandareLecture: Justice Sunanda Bhandare was one of the earliest feminist voices both at the Bar and the Bench, says Upendra Baxi.
#JusticeSunandaBhandareLecture: Upendra Baxi: Much before Shah Bano, Sunanda Bhandare had filed a maintenance plea in Bai Tahira's case. It came before Justice Krishna Iyer whose views were reconfirmed in Shah Bano.
#JusticeSunandaBhandareLecture: Upendra Baxi: It is an amazing achievement to have 25th memorial lecture. This lecture has saved Justice Sunanda Bhandare from unjust amnesia.
#JusticeSunandaBhandareLecture: Upendra Baxi: Doctrine of Basic Structure is long term to say, so I will abbreviate it to BS. Whether BS is in a good sense or not is for you to decide.
#JusticeSunandaBhandareLecture: Upendra Baxi: State was all male. Judiciary, Executive, Legislature was all male. Even when we speak about Constituent Assembly, we remember males and not the women in the Constituent Assembly.
#JusticeSunandaBhanadareLecture: Upendra Baxi: No institution is sovereign. Every institution in India is supreme in its own sphere and that is the message of Basic Structure.
Upendra Baxi: In the context of women's rights, the first incursion into Basic Structure came in the case of Vishaka.

Not a single time is the word Basic Structure mentioned in the judgment though.

Upendra Baxi: However, Vishaka refers to various cases on Article 21 which is based on substantive due process. Vishaka is thus the first instance of feminisation of Basic Structure.
"I dont know why judges write such long decisions," says Upendra Baxi and turns to AG KKVenugopal.

"Venu, why does Bar not protest against this", asks Baxi.
#JusticeSunandaBhandareLecture: Baxi refers to Triple Talaq judgment

"Why did court strike it down? Because of its manifest arbitrariness. And what is manifest arbitrariness - it hits Basic Structure

Thus Triple Talaq judgment is an instance of feminisation of Basic Structure
#JusticeSunandaBhandareLecture: Upendra Baxi now refers to his stance on Constitutional morality and how it conflicts with the stance of AG KK Venugopal.
Constitutional morality is a part of Basic Structure. It flows from Basic Structure. Overruling Constitutional morality is overruling Basic Structure, says Upendra Baxi.
#JusticeSunandaBhandareLecture: Upendra Baxi refers to #Sabarimala review judgment.

It is an astonishing judgment. It tries to defeminise Basic Structure by referring cases to 7-judge Bench. Never seen such a step in the history of Supreme Court.

Upendra Baxi comes down heavily on #Sabarimala review judgment. The whole exercise in Sabarimala review judgment is per incuriam, says Baxi.

The new CJI should forget about the judgment in my opinion, Baxi urges.

#Sabarimala review judgment is a violation of all the settled rules and procedure of Supreme Court

It is a betrayal of Constitutional discipline, Upendra Baxi.
#JusticeSunandaBhandareLecture: Upendra Baxi concludes his lecture.
#JusticeSunandaBhandareLecture: Attorney General KK Venugopal once again says he is not in agreement with Constitutional morality. It is an unruly horse.
#JusticeSunandaBhandareLecture: Look at PIL judgments of SC. They legislate using it. And now with Constitutional morality, court will now use it to justify anything, says Venugopal.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh

Keep Current with Murali Krishnan

Murali Krishnan Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!


Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @legaljournalist

May 17, 2021
A late night sitting by Kolkata High Court to cancel interim bail granted to two sitting State ministers, one MLA and one former Mayor.
Calcutta* High Court not Kolkata. The chartered High Court legacy.
More interesting news. This was not an appeal against the lower court order but a plea for transfer of trial under Section 407 CrPC.
Read 6 tweets
Sep 21, 2020
Sudarshan News and media regulation: Hearing commences before Supreme Court.

Centre has filed a fresh affidavit calling for regulation of digital media before the court takes up issue of regulation of TV channels.
Senior counsel Mukul Rohatgi is appearing on behalf News Broadcasters Federation which has sought impleadment in the matter.
Rohatgi says NBF is the largest body of tv channels in India with 160 members from different parts of the country.

He submits News Broadcasters Association is not representative of news channels and seeks permission to file an affidavit to put forth a self-regulatory mechanism.
Read 18 tweets
Sep 18, 2020
Hearing against Sudarshan News commences before the Supreme Court.
Sanjay Hegde enters appearance on behalf of Zakaf Foundation of India.

"I have a watching brief in this matter. We are not a party to this matter," says Hegde.
Justice DY Chandrachud tells Hegde that Sudarshan News has raised substantial issues against Zakaf Foundation.

"But we are not here to investigate into your client. But Sudarshan News has sought to justify their programme on the grounds of your source of funding"
Read 42 tweets
Sep 17, 2020
Sudarshan News and UPSC Jihad: Hearing commences before Supreme Court.
Sr. Counsel Anoop Chaudhuri appearing for petitioner says Sudarshan news has filed an affidavit with vague allegations and submits he wants to file a rejoinder.
Shyam Divan says it was difficult to file a detailed affidavit in two days. We (lawyers) are all in different locations.
We were ambushed by various applications/ interventions, he submits.
Read 4 tweets
Sep 17, 2020
Sudarshan News files affidavit before Supreme court defending its programme Bindas Bol and the use of the term "UPSC Jehad".

The affidavit largely focuses on foreign funding received by Zakat Foundation, an orgnisation which supports civil service aspirants.
Sudarshan News has claimed that some such funds received by Zakat Foundation are from terror-linked organisations.

The organisations/ individuals named in the affidavit are Madina Trust, Muslim Aid (UK), Zakat Foundation of America and Zakir Naik
The affidavit says the TV channel has no ill-will against any particular community or individual and do not oppose selection of any meritorious candidate

"There is no statement or message in the four episodes broadcast thatmembers of a particular community should not join UPSC"
Read 8 tweets
Sep 15, 2020
Supreme Court raises grave concerns about the manner in which debates are conducted by certain television channels.

Justice KM Joseph says many times panellists are not allowed to speak and anchor takes up most of the time and panellists are also half-muted.
Supreme Court berates Sudarshan news.

Here is one anchor who says one particular community is trying to gain access to UPSC. Can anything be more insidious than such claims. Such allegations affect stability of country and also casts aspersions on credibility of exam.
In the UPSC exam, all are subject to same tests, interviews and are assessed by same persons. But the insinuation is one community is trying to infiltrate the UPSC. Can such allegations without factual basis be allowed, asks Justice DY Chandrachud?
Read 15 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!

This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!


0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy


3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!