THREAD: On the impossibility of an infinite cosmos. [By Al Kindi] Image
1. The first argument against the eternity of the cosmos aims at proving that body, time, and movement do not precede each other and hence, if time is finite, “the extension of the existence” of the universe is finite.
2. This argument assumes that time is not a being, but an attribute of the body. Let us say now that no body, nor anything else that has quantity and quality, can be infinite in actuality and that infinity is only in potentiality.
3. The argument then unfolds in four steps. Following a Euclidian form, it starts (a) with a series of six axioms or “first true immediately intelligible premises” , four of which will be used in subsequent argumentation.
4. (b) that no magnitude can be infinite in actuality by showing the absurdities that will loom when one tries to apply ordinary arithmetic operations to magnitudes hypothetically infinite.
5. (c) Since time is a quantity, it is impossible that there be an infinite time in actuality, since time has a finite beginning. Also, things attributed to a finite [body] are necessarily finite; therefore every attribute of a body, be it magnitude, place, movement, or time
6. (c) continued: And time is divided by motion, and the sum total of all the attributes of the body in actuality, is also finite, since body is finite; hence the body of the universe is finite, as is every one of its attributes.
7. It has been made clear that an infinite time in actuality cannot exist. Now time is the time of the body of the universe, or its extension.
8. If time is finite, the existence of the body is finite, since time is not an existent and there is no body without time, because time is an extension measured by movement. So, if there is a movement, there is time, and if there is no movement, there is no time.
9. Having shown that body, time, and motion are coextensive and finite, you still have to rule out a possibility (d): what if someone “thought that it is possible for the body of the universe to have been at rest first, having the potentiality to move, and then to have moved?”
10. Since body cannot have preceded its generation, then generation “is its essence,” and hence the being of the body is not prior to movement.
11. On the other hand if the universe was eternally at rest, motion could never arise, for motion is change and the eternal does not change, it simply is. Therefore it is self-contradictory to say that the universe is eternal and yet motion has a beginning.
12. Thus, if there is movement, there is necessarily body, and if there is body, there is necessarily movement. But we already said that time does not precede movement;
13. thus necessarily time does not precede body, since there is no time but with movement, and since there is no body but with movement and there is no movement but with a body, and no body without extension.
14. Proof by composition: This is based on the double composition of bodies, every body being composed of matter and form or sub- stance and tridimensionality. But composition is a change (affecting the state of non-composition) and thus it is a movement.
15. Without movement there is no body since body is composite. Hence body and motion do not precede each other but are coexistent.
16. Argument for the Finiteness of Past Time: The argument unfolds in two steps: (a) from the impossibility of an infinite series of past segments of time which draws (b) the impossibility of traversing a temporal infinity in order to reach a given time.
17. the present could never have been reached if infinite past time or an infinite series of past segments of time had to be traversed. But we reach a definite time; hence time does not proceed from infinity but necessarily from a limit.
18. The extension of the body is thus not infinite, and it is impossible that a body exists without extension. Therefore the existence of a body is not infinite, but the existence of a body is finite. Thus it is impossible for a body to be eternal.
19. Finally, after proving that past time can't be infinite, we have to complete the last step of this argument and prove that future time is not infinite either. No matter what definite time is added to the already accumulated finite past time, the total sum will remain finite.
20. The three arguments, intended to prove the finiteness of the world, entail de facto its creation or at least its beginning and hence the necessity of a first cause. This is linked to the thread on emergence of the body:
End of thread🙂. Likes and retweets appreciated.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Wake up

Wake up Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @enigmaoftruth1

Apr 25, 2021
THREAD: The Prophecies of Muhammad PBUH: Proofs of Prophethood. [Sh. Mohammad Elshinawy, Yaqeen]
This thread will present some of the most compelling and intriguing prophecies of Muhammad pbuh and the Quran from Sh. Elshinawy's elaborate article on the topic, which in their totality represent undoubtable miraculousness.
1. Some of the greatest and most convincing testimonies to the prophethood of Muhammad ﷺ are the multiple occasions on which he correctly predicted future events. Only one to whom God had granted access to the unseen could have, time and again, accurately foretold the future.
Read 87 tweets
Apr 6, 2021
THREAD: The various ways in which the Quran is inimitable. [Al Juwayni] Image
1. In a previous thread, we discussed the miraculous nature of the Quran. Among this miraculousness, is its inimitability. Imam Al Haramayn Al Juwayni presents the various ways in which this is the case, and its profoundness.
2. If it is said, explain to us how and in what way the Quran is inimitable, we respond: The Quran is inimitable because it combines eloquence with an elegance of form in arrangement distinct from the ordinary speech of Arabs.
Read 26 tweets
Nov 7, 2020
THREAD: Al Juwayni's proof of the will of the creator. Image
1. Once having established the temporality of the world and the commencement of its existence, it follows that the temporally produced is that whose existence and annihilation are both possible.
2. And every moment of time in which its occurrence might happen was but one of the possibilities in other moments that preceded this one.
Read 14 tweets
Aug 23, 2020
THREAD: The Miraculous Language of the Quran, Evidence of Divine Origin. [Bassam Saeh] Image
1. This thread will present some key points and proofs from Bassam Saeh's great book on this topic.
2. This thread will empirically prove that the Arabs never knew the language of the Quran before the Quran's revelation, and could never replicate it afterwards, while the language of the Prophet pbuh, despite its eloquence, was grasped and imitated, because it came from a human
Read 42 tweets
Jun 4, 2020
THREAD: Women's legal rights in Islam, compared to British modern history. ImageImage
This thread will compare some legal rights in Islam, revealed 1400 years ago in the 7th century AD, to their development in British modern history.
1. A)Property: In the UK, before the Married Women’s Property Act 1882, common law doctrine viewed husband and wife as one person; who was the husband, so a woman's pre-marital property became the husband’s and so did post-marital property and her earnings also became his.
Read 20 tweets
Mar 2, 2020
THREAD: Al Ghazali’s Kalam cosmological argument for God. Image
1. We will set out the argument in its simple form and then elaborate on the premises and conclusion.
2. The argument is: P1) The occurrence of every occurrent has a cause. P2) The world is an occurrent. C) It necessarily follows that the world has a cause.
Read 26 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(