A thread about sex, lies and paedophiles. Yesterday @PinkNews published an article on comments I made on a Facebook thread about teachers. I have to say whenever I hear Pink News is publishing something resembling a story I think of Cecilia Martinez.
2./ Remember her? In her early 80s this amateur painter decided to restore a Spanish fresco. The results were hilarious and bore as much resemblance to the original as the average Pink News story does to the actual facts. bbc.co.uk/news/world-eur…
3./ People who are gender critical like those involved in @AllianceLGB have asked innumerable times for a proper debate with Pink News on issues of substance but they never take up the offer. We'd be happy to engage in debate, for example, on how the rights of same-sex...
4./ ...attracted peeps may be undermined by the conflation of biological sex and gender. We're also keen to discuss why there's been an over 3000% rise in the number of girls being referred to GI clinics. Pink News and its allies make endless excuses why they can't debate.
5./ Instead they attack, skew, obscure, exaggerrate and obfuscate. The reason is simple: they're scared of open public debate. They and people like @DawnButlerBrent @patrickharvie and @OwenJones84 know they cannot defend their positions except by silencing critics.
6./ Only if they shout, bully, troll and malign can they retain their status as rather agitated Wizards of Woke. So do I really think gay teachers are all abusers as Pink News implied? Of course I bloody don't. Even the quotes they used ...
7./ ...disprove their own headline and their claims. I was actually discussing LGBTQ+ groups being set up in schools and the potential risks. All I pointed out (among other comments) was that we do have to be careful because a tiny minority of adults do prey on kids.
8./ I made clear the obvious fact that this tiny minority will be mainly straight because most teachers are straight. But it's silly to deny there will also be a tiny minority of gay teachers who come into contact with kids who are a risk. But no more and no less than straights.
9./ As critics have rightly pointed out any group of kids doing any activity are at risk from those adults. True enough. BUT an LGBTQ+ group unlike any other group in schools is set up specifically around sexuality. Talking about equations or parsing verbs...
10. ..isn't the same as talking about sexual attraction, and how comfortable a kid might feel in his or her body. And these groups are not set up by kids. Here's the first Stonewall guide to setting up LGBTQ+ groups in schools. stonewall.org.uk/sites/default/…
11./ It makes clear groups are set up by adult teachers FOR kids; and for kids ....of all ages. The guide includes quotes from a Year 7 student praising their group (yes an 11 year old). I'm not saying 11 year olds don't ever know if they're LGBT. Some later say they did know.
12./ Most don't and are just pondering. The age range of many of the clubs is 11-17 yrs old. Any 11 year old is also at a distinct disadvantage to 15 & 16 yr olds in the group. Whose monitoring interactions? Stonewall recommends "anything discussed in the room stays in the room".
13./ Err. Ok. All of this would just be vaguely concerning if we could be sure that Stonewall and the army of people it's trained to march through schools really cared about safeguarding. But here's Stonewall's Aimee Challoner talking about her work in schools (last para).
14./ That's the same Aimee that failed to tell the Green Party her dad was on a child rape charge for which he was eventually jailed. She was later suspended from the Lib Dems after her fiancee's child sex fantasies were exposed. thetimes.co.uk/article/lib-de…
15./ And then there's the mental confusion caused by other Stonewall so-called mentors. Believe it or not Alex Drummond the bearded lesbian goes into schools where "she" elucidates the mysteries of being "gender-queer and gender-fluid". To 11 year olds?
16./ So what's all this got to do with my comments that Pink News botched? It only shows that all LGBTQ+ school groups may not always be safe spaces. Stonewall should surely acknowledge there may be risks. Then everyone can work together to remove them.
17./ Denying there might be risks isn't just naive. It undermines LGBT education. If and when something goes wrong the whole enterprise will be tarred. Safeguarding of kids requires vigilance and shouldn't be lost in the rush of enthusiasm for so-called 'inclusive teaching'.
18./ And if that's true of safeguarding around sexuality it's just as true on gender identity. Here's Elly Barnes from Educate and Celebrate explaining how they go in and "educate" teachers in the latest minutiae of gender doctrine.
19./ And here's Relationship and Sex Education paid for and provided to schools by the BBC. At 1min 35 secs one of the teachers explains how there are over 100 genders and reveals the mysteries of "bi-gender". Yeah me neither. To 9 year olds! bbc.co.uk/teach/class-cl…
20./ Don't get me wrong. I'd have loved some more pro-gay commentary at my bigoted Ayrshire school. But Elly's breathless enthusiasm and the BBC's baffling baloney worries me. It hasn't been thought through and parental objections are being steamrollered.
21./ Also I hate to be boring but what will straight kids and their tax paying parents make of all this expensive navel-gazing and weirdness? It's easy to forget but working class kids (straight and gay) actually NEED education and skills if they're to succeed.
22/. There really is poverty and inequality in Britain and education can be a way out of it. This garbage reeks of entitled middle-class "teachers" failing in the one job they were asked to do: educate. As for Pink News it jumped on a comment of mine about a tiny minority...
23/. ..of adults. Their real intention tho is to close down a debate about the much bigger risk of gender identity propaganda in schools. But if they and their ilk can scream, rant and troll so abusively at a gay bloke that dares to question their precious belief system..
24. ..just imagine what they do to ordinary parents. If lesbians and gays who step out of line are denounced with bullying accusations of homophobia what chance have parents and teachers got who worry about this reckless experiment with the future of our nation's children?

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Malcolm Clark

Malcolm Clark Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @TwisterFilm

14 Apr
1./ Jameela's puberty blocker meltdown. Today's Naomi Wolf award for BS goes to @jameelajamil for this legend where she claims blockers were given to lots of girls at her school in the 90s. It's hard to know where to begin with this level of inaccuracy. But here's a start.👇 Image
2./ The first science paper on the subject of a trial giving GnRH agonists (or puberty blockers) to adolescents was published in 1998 and was the subject of a 1996 C4 documentary. This highly experimental trial happened in Holland and NOT Jameela's school. Strangely enough.👇 Image
3./ It was only in 2011 that the leading Gender Identity Clinic in the UK began its own experimental trials. They were criticised by the usual suspects ( hello Mermaids) for being too "cautious". They wanted to find out how "reversible" were the effects. 👇tavistockandportman.nhs.uk/about-us/news/…
Read 12 tweets
12 Apr
1./ I see my my good friend Margaret Lynch is being accused of all sorts. She's even been labelled -by the usual keyboard warriors- of homophobia. Get real. Here's a little story about Ma-Grit, as I like to call her, that shows why that's so ridiculous.👇thetimes.co.uk/article/alba-c…
2./ Many moons ago I was President of the Glasgow University Gay Society (there were only 10 members so god knows why we needed a President). I was 19. To advance the cause we decided we'd hold a meeting in the University Union which was so reactionary @LiamFox was on the Board!
3./ I marched into their reception, asked to book a room, and all hell broke loose. No way would we be allowed to hold a meeting, I was told. The Board publicly issued a statement saying we'd be a moral danger to students. This was a Union that regularly showed porn films!
Read 9 tweets
11 Apr
1./ Paedophilia and the Scottish LGBTQ+ movement. Is it any surprise that Stonewall and other groups are members of ILGA an international LGBTQ+ lobby group that's alleged to be campaigning against an age of consent? Here's why it's no surprise at all. wingsoverscotland.com/the-paedophile…
2./ ILGA began in Edinburgh in 1974 when two guys brought together gay organisations from across Europe to form the International Gay Congress. One of them, Ian Dunn, was an unrepentant paedophile and founder member of PIE. Here's his obituary. 👇independent.co.uk/news/obituarie…
3./ IGC would become ILGA, the pre-eminent international gay rights organisation; despite its status as a UN NGO being interrupted in 1994 when its links to pro-paedophile organisations were revealed. ILGA says it was all a big mistake. If you say so.👇
ilga.org/ilga-ecosoc-st…
Read 16 tweets
11 Apr
1./ What has Brazil's COVID crisis got to do with the gender wars? Ever wondered how such a science-denying moron as Bolsonaro got elected? This is the story of how Queer Theory, and its nutty acolytes, helped rocket-fuel the rise of a dangerous monster.👇ft.com/content/557138…
2./ His incompetence, failure to act decisively and vaccine skepticism have resulted in a spiralling crisis with 4000+ deaths a day and a second variant spreading that combines the worst of the Manaus strain with the risks of the South African one.👇riotimesonline.com/brazil-news/mi…
3./ Bolsanaro's anti-science stance is nothing new in Brazil. There's a tradition of violent populism that equates science with "elites". When iconic medic Oswaldo Cruz promoted smallpox vaccination there were populist-agitated street riots in Rio.👇zocalopublicsquare.org/2021/02/10/190…
Read 24 tweets
4 Apr
1./ How important is Free Speech? It's an obvious question as we drift towards the signing of the new Hate Crime Bill in Scotland. In their letter today to @heraldscotland @mbmpolicy suggest if you don't think this law is dangerous you haven't been paying attention. 👇
2./ As they argue "Intention to use the legislation to inhibit debate ...is already evident." Apparently an SNP researcher in response to a reference to @ALLIANCELGB hoped the Act "will do some work to limit the activities of these hate groups". An aberration? What do you think?
3./ The last year has seen bizarre petitions, blatant lies and hysterical campaigns of slander by second rate politicians and third rate actors. These suggest the regiment of deluded gender woo hoo will jump at the chance this new law affords them. What should we do in response?
Read 9 tweets
30 Mar
1./ What's the best care for young people who think they're trans? A noisy lobby insists we must affirm their gender identity, give puberty blockers to under 16s and surgery as soon as they want it. To do otherwise is "hateful". Here's why Jolyon is wrong. vice.com/en/article/qjp…
2./ The lobby argue if these young people aren't affirmed they'll be suicidal. The evidence for this is extremely weak, unscientific and contested. It doesn't stop parents like the mom of Jazz Jennings saying she'd rather have "a living daughter than a dead son". Who wouldn't?👇
3./ But how could Jennings know her 4 year old child would grow up to feel suicidal? And where DID this mawkish suicide narrative come from? The most surprising and convincing explanation I've yet heard comes from an unlikely source: at the heart of the trans movement itself.
Read 15 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!