@maidros78 @kaundinya_abhi @JatNationalist @sarkar_swati (1) interesting exchange. First thing that strikes is the phrase "posing as a Hindu", "=six pointed star". "posing" implies tweeple is not a "Hindu" but merely pretending to be one. A "Hindu" doesnt need to "pose" to be a Hindu. So @maidros here is being declared to be a "Jew".
@maidros78 @kaundinya_abhi @JatNationalist @sarkar_swati @MAidros (2) @kaundinya_abhi is actually pretty logical. All logic is based on axioms. His dubbing of @maidros as "posing as a Hindu", and Thaparite style narrative insertion technique of speculation "=six pointed star?" qualifies as axioms. It reduces to assumption @maidros is a "Jew".
@maidros78 @kaundinya_abhi @JatNationalist @sarkar_swati @MAidros (3) the assumption is explained by the claim that @maidros demand that Hindus don't deny Holocaust (of Jews) to retain credibility implies @maidros is not a Hindu ("posing as one"="six pointed star") but a Jew. This is problematic but understandable as to where its coming from.
@maidros78 @kaundinya_abhi @JatNationalist @sarkar_swati @MAidros I have not checked but I trust that the accuser has never denied Holocaust but is simply asking why is the accused demanding non-denial of Holocaust as must for credibility of Hindus? Its tricky, but this implies denial of Holocaust is either not discrediting for Hindus or,
@maidros78 @kaundinya_abhi @JatNationalist @sarkar_swati @MAidros that the very fact of insisting on not denying Holocaust makes the accused a non-Hindu and a "Jew". While the first one can be dismissed as politically naive, the second one is very problematic - as this logic will disqualify and misqualify a lot of "Hindus".
@maidros78 @kaundinya_abhi @JatNationalist @sarkar_swati @MAidros @kaundinya_abhi's logic as any sympathy/support for Jews makes one a Jew applied to Gandhi based on his position on Jews makes him both a Jew and a non-Jew, Nehru a Jew, Subhash Bose a Hindu, and Digvijay Singh, the ruler of pre-indep Jamnagar a Jew.
@maidros78 @kaundinya_abhi @JatNationalist @sarkar_swati @MAidros I very much like @kaundinya_abhi's pointer that Israeli textbooks dont discuss Hindu holocaust and therefore Hindus shd be neutral to Jews. We must declare Hindus shd be neutral to every nation whose textbook doesnt discuss Hindu holocaust. We have to start with India itself.
@maidros78 @kaundinya_abhi @JatNationalist @sarkar_swati @MAidros Indian school/uni texts have not yet discussed Hindu holocaust. If at all at uni humanities shenanigans its abt denial and mocking of Hindu holocaust. Even into 2nd term of BJP gov, GOI hasnt insisted on discussion of Hindu holocaust in textbooks. Hindus shd be neutral to Hindus.
@maidros78 @kaundinya_abhi @JatNationalist @sarkar_swati @MAidros By @kaundinya_abhi's logic, after India, no Islamic country including deep friends in Gulf - also dont discuss Hindu holocaust in textbks: Hindu's shd not defend/sympathize in any way, those countries either. Hindus who show such sympathies r non-Hindus. How many in gov qualify?
