What has followed journalists giving testimonials in NA is onslaught of hate & accusations of spreading ‘fake news’. It is fascinating how the eager beavers have taken up the Trump coined term and have weaponised it to suit their purpose. #AttacksWontStopUs
Fake news is a term coined by President Trump to attack &discredit media. Unfortunately, given the state of ignorance & intolerance that is rampant, the term has been weaponised to attack any news & any opinion that doesn’t align with the narrative of power. #AttacksWontStopUs
What we are seeing here is the weaponisation of the term in order to defend party narratives. So far, various items that have been tagged as fake news have not actually contained misinformation. #AttacksWontStopUs
If one aims to become a ‘fact checker’, it is important to understand what misinformation and disinformation is. Tagging every opinion, every comment as ‘fake news’ in inaccurate & simply meant to create public distrust on media. #AttacksWontStopUs
A news story isn’t a personal blog. When a reporter interviews someone, they use most of the information to understand the story & only SOME quotes can be added to the actual story. It is a global practice, doesn’t make anything 'fake’. #AttacksWontStopUs
Journalists do have the right to have opinions & on Twitter, where they are personally engaging, they do give analysis of situations. Analysis isn’t news, it is a reading of a situation that you can agree or disagree with, but it simply cannot be ‘fake’ #AttacksWontStopUs
If anyone aims to be a fact checker, specially when they are publicly discrediting journalists, it is essential that they learn to differ between facts and opinions #AttacksWontStopUs
If a politician changes his/her position on something, it is THEM who is changing their stance, it doesn’t make reports on their previous stance fake #AttacksWontStopUs
If a controversial decision is taken back on media and public pressure, that does NOT mean that reports about the original decision were fake, it simply means media did its job, and did it well #AttacksWontStopUs
In case someone actually finds misinformation in a ’news piece’ do counter, not just with a fake news tag, but with actual information and without abuse. Nobody would have a problem with that. #AttacksWontStopUsI
When the misinformation comes from the government itself, blame the government, not the media. #AttacksWontStopUs
Even when someone does find a real instance of misinformation, it doesn’t justify abuse, slurs, threats and character assassination. Learn to engage in civil discourse #AttacksWontStopUs
Important for political parties to create spaces for civil political discourse online. A code of conduct for their representatives & persistent messaging to their followers pushing for a kind Internet, with zero tolerance for abuse is essential. #AttacksWontStopUs
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
About 10 years back, I was called as a witness by the internal harassment committee in a media org. A complaint had been brought against a senior media personality, who had a pre existing reputation of behaving inappropriately towards women. #MeToo
The questions that I was asked had nothing to do with the conduct of the accused or the incident itself. ALL the questions were about the complainants' conduct & her performance at work. I was asked if I believed that the salary that she was drawing was justified. #MeToo
I was asked how I felt about the fact that I apparently made less than she did at that time. I was asked why she had more authority than other women in the newsroom. I was asked why she had not confided in me & other women about the incident the second it occurred. #MeToo
Thread.
Thank you for taking an initial step. An important concern highlighted in the statement & demonstrated through testimonials was the use of representative's accounts to tag journalists as being 'fake' or accuse them of pushing 'an agenda’. #AttacksWontSilenceUs 1/5
Discrediting of journalists is done without offering any proof & often targets opinions (which are personal & can’t be fake opinions) Branding of journalists as 'fake news peddler’ by official or representative accounts triggers abuse & violence. #AttacksWontSilenceUs
2/5
I request you to issue guidelines to i) Create a nuanced understanding of what misinformation is & b) help the officials understand & acknowledge how the term ‘fake news’ is weaponised against democratic discourse #AttacksWontSilenceUs #TogetherAgainstAbuse
3/5
اسد عمر صاحد، کچھ فیکٹس درست کر لیں۔
پہلی سٹیٹمنٹ لکھنے والوں نے کوئی غلطی کی، نا مانی۔ اس پیٹیشن کو جن صحافیوں نے لکھا اور انڈورس کیا، ان کو پاکستان تحریک انصاف کے لوگوں نے، یا پاکستان تحریک انصاف کے نام پر ٹارگٹ کیا گیا۔ اس موقف پر آج بھی سب قائم ہیں۔
حال میں جارئ ہونے والا بیان، پہلے بیان کی تردید نہیں، تائید کرتا ہے۔
ہاں، نئے بیان میں شامل ہونے والے دیگر صحافیوں نے پاکستان تحریک انصاف کے ساتھ، ساتھ دیگر سیاسی جماعتوں کے کردار کے حوالے سے بھی بات کی ہے، یہ سیاست نہیں، اس موومنٹ میں مزید لوگوں کے تجربات کو شامل کرنے کی سعی ہے
پہلے بیان، اور حالیہ بیان، کسی میں بھی تحریک انصاف کو کلین چٹ نہیں دی گئی۔ بلکہ، حالیہ بیان میں بھی، یہ ہراسگی کے کلچر کو ختم کرنے کے لئے، حکومت کو دیگر جماعتوں سے زیادہ ذمہ دار ٹہرایا گیا ہے۔ گزارش ہے کہ بیان کو غور سے پڑھیں، پھر تبصرہ کریں۔
At 17, I go to KU, fatherless & eldest among siblings, I travel in a bus for the 1st time & am touched, groped & pushed, so many times in the 15 minute journey that by the time I get to the University, I am too shaken to figure out which forms I need. #MeraJismMeriMarzi
At 18, a student at KU, I get used to being felt up. I spend the next 4 years commuting in Karachi public transport & loose count pf the number of times I am touched without consent. #MeraJismMeriMarzi
At 22, I take a rickshaw to work. 5 min in, the driver starts shouting about my duppatta. I panic. I apologise. I fumble with my duapatta. He keeps yelling. So I jump out as he starts to slow down on a red light and run with bleeding knees. I dont tell anyone. #MeraJismMeriMarzi
Citizens Protection (Against Online Harm) Rules, drafted by PTA makes one thing clear - the goal is NOT to become China, it is to become North Korea. Snippets follow.. #SeriouslyNotKidding
Social Media companies excepted to act within 24 hours (or within 6 hours in emergency) to remove or disable access to content reported by a government appointed "National Coordinator" (Btw the IT minister has 15 days to find this coordinator after the notification of rules)
Interpretation or permissibility of any online content, by PTA or National Coordinator to take precedence
over any community standards or rules or community guidelines or policies or any other
instruments devised by a Social Media Company like @Twitter & @Facebook
Shout to my team at @mmfd_Pak who helped us publish six interesting & informative publications this year - Thank you @AmelGhanii , @SalwaRana4 , @hijakamran & @_vics_ for putting in so much effort.
Follow this thread for links to these publications #TeamMMfD
This guidebook presents a brief overview of laws that regulate and criminalise expression in Pakistan. Authored by @SalwaRana4 & myself and edited by @asadbeyg , this is a must read for all Pakistani journalists.