Bar and Bench Profile picture
Sep 4, 2020 65 tweets 9 min read Read on X
Delhi High Court Women's Lawyers Forum to hold a session on 'Inspiring Court Room Stories'.

Justice Jyoti Singh, Judge, Delhi HC and Kavita Jha, Partner, Vaish Associates to speak at the event.

Session to start at 5 pm today on WebEx platform.

#Webinar #CourtRoomStories Image
Session to begin shortly.

#CourtRoomStories #webinar #DelhiHC
Advocates Amita Kalkal and Aditi Gupta kick start the session.

Kalkal welcomes Justice Jyoti and Adv Kavita Jha.
As the topic suggestions, we will be focusing on the journey of our two Speakers. What according to them was the key to their success: Kalkal
Kalkal and Gupta introduce Justice Jyoti Singh and Adv Jha. Image
Justice Jyoti Singh greets the participants.
I always wanted to be a professional Bharatnatyam dancer. Law was completely default: Justice Jyoti Singh begins.
I was a botany student.. I filed up the form after my friend did it. Totally destiny I think : Justice Jyoti Singh.
When we joined the profession, there wasn't such a corporate culture. Corporate wasn't a very big option : Justice Jyoti Singh on opting to litigate.

Litigation fascinated me. For me, a lawyer meant arguing. If I had to be here, I had to be there..arguing : Justice Singh
I was a first generation lawyer. I didn't have the advantage of seeing what a high court looked like. I used to be so lost the whole day. It was my clerk and me. I would listen to the arguments and sit in the library: Justice Singh on her initial days in the profession.
I was lonely. I quit after a few days. I applied for jobs but didn't get. I get a a one day from Mr Agarwal. He said I saw you arguing one and are you ready to join.

I told him I was not meant to be in this profession. It was too boring and depressing : Justice Singh.
It was very lonely (initially). But Mr Agarwal gave me work : Justice Singh
I used to be nervous to begin with. We had some very tough judges at that time. I used to super prepared. I used to stand in front of a mirror and rehearse my arguments. First initial days, I goofed up also: Justice Singh
First four years, I went independent. I had no work, no case: Justice Singh
For three months, I had no case. I used to sit in the library till one day I got a case from someone I know: Justice Singh
I won that case and I was so excited. He gave me a dabba of halwa and said that's all I can give : Justice Singh
How did you remember handling so many cases later? You were a one woman Army. : Adv Gupta

Did I? Everyone does it. I stayed in my field ie service law. I didn't find it difficult. I had a support system. I had a junior and colleagues and friends: Justice Singh
How did life change after you were designated as a senior? : adv Gupta

I felt a lot of responsibility.. the senior gown has a weight..weight of the responsibility. The expectations are more. The Bench expects.. You have to work harder : Justice Singh
Client and briefing counsel both have expectations. They rely on you. I felt the responsibility was so much more. First day, I was nervous: Justice Singh
My first matter as a senior was terribly bad for me. My clients were in contempt. I said oh God help me. Petitioners had a battery of senior lawyers. The Judge looked at me and said "arguements heard in part. To come up next week": Justice Singh on being a Senior Adv
Mostly everyone was known to you. It was easier than I expected. Senior welcomed us: Justice Singh on becoming a Judge.
There are moments when you feel isolated. I miss the 11:30 am gate no 7 chai+coffee..I miss the Bar room. At times, there is a sense of isolation. But the transaction was good. I like to keep my courtroom light: Justice Singh Image
For me and all of you, the keyword is hardwork. There is no substitute. More than that, it's the determination in you. Each single day remind yourself that you are here to stay: Justice Singh
Always tell yourself that you are here to stay.. no matter what the situation. When you have no cases, be it things said to you inside or outside courts or be in domestic issues. Nothing is permanent: Justice Singh
Set yourself a goal in life. Set an impossible goal and work towards it.. whatever you give to the universe will come back to you. I see so many young girls.. be here: Justice Singh
It doesn't come to anyone on a platter, first generation or second generation.. to sustain, you have to do your own job: Justice Singh
Justice Singh talks about the time she had to begin working as early as 4 am and miss family activities.
We've all done this. There's nothing special with me : Justice Singh
Justice Singh concludes.

Adv Kalkal asks Adv Kavita Jha about her initial days in Delhi after coming from Kolkata.
I was in school when I thought of becoming a lawyer. I joined the 5- year law course from Calcutta University. I started practicing there: Adv Jha Image
We didn't have the corporate or internship culture then: Adv Jha
Our internship started in third year in the city civi court.. when you are watching people arguing.. it gave me an impetus. I was a lawyer by choice: Adv Jha
I aspired to be a criminal lawyer. I thought when I would graduate, there would be someone waiting with a brief for me. But life is different from theory : Adv Jha
This year I complete 20 years. My senior instilled in us commitment: Adv Jha
Calcutta is a city of joy but in Delhi, there are more opportunities and sky is the limit here: Adv Jha on coming to Delhi after getting married.

I joined Vaish Associates seventeen years ago. It is the leading tax firm in India : Adv Jha
In 2007, I became an AOR.. the firm's litigation practice also grew: Adv Jha
My first appearance, my senior asked me to take an adjournment: Adv Jha
Adv Jha speaks on being appointed as Amicus Curie in a tax matter by Justice (retd) Lokur.
Adv Jha loses her internet connection.
Don't take your focus away. If you're at home, read books, journals. Utilize your time.. I also didn't have cases for months altogether: Justice Singh on her tips to lawyers.

I don't have tips on how to prepare your matters. Maybe Geeta (Luthra) will tell : Justice Singh
You have to emulate her style and hardwork. According to me, there is no answer to hardwork. I was fortunate that my father was in the profession. But I started as a civil lawyer but I had a mentor: Senior Adv Geeta Luthra
Either way (first generation or otherwise), you have to prove your mette.. youngsters now say that they want to move to another city to move out of the family aura: Luthra
My father taught me that you have to respect the Bench..the institution: Luthra
I used to go through the entire file, line to line..I didn't leave to my memory alone and made points.. my points, counter and rejoinder. I would arrange my judgements.. I spend a lot of time on preparing my file : Justice Singh
I don't think I read too much. I don't get the time now. I read The Fountainhead a couple of times. It's my Bible. I read philosophical books: Justice Singh
I do read books on how not to lose temper: Justice Singh
I don't think I faced any such challenge. I think I was blessed. 1-2 matters were taken away because I was a woman lawyer. It was neither an advantage or disadvantage: Justice Singh on being a woman in the profession.
Too soon to say.. I don't think it's going to make much of a difference. Cases are being filed. Work is increasing..VC is a great thing. It's as good as physical..things will be back to track: Justice Singh on post-COVID litigation.
Adv Jha joins back.

My initial experience was so inspiring: Adv Jha talks about CIT vs Kelvinator.
Even if you are going for a passover or adjournment, you should be prepared even if you are not the main counsel. Never go to court unprepared: Adv Jha
Adv Jha shares her experience of arguing a matter on a Saturday, which she ultimately lost.

Every experience leaves you with something to learn. Even if you lose a matter, it's fine when you get a satisfactory heating from Court : Adv Jha
Adv Jha talks about a pro bono sec 302 criminal matter that she appeared in.

It was before Justice Sanghi. He was very patient. The matter started at 11.30 and 4.30 order was pronounced and the person was acquitted: Adv Jha
I told the father of the accused that his son had been acquitted and he asked me if he got bail.
Corporate has the cream client but when you do such pro bono matters, there you get satisfaction : Adv Jha
My son's teacher asked me if I knew a matrimonial lawyer as she had to file an appeal..the matter was an ex parte divorce. Justice Hima Kohli did complete justice to the matter: Adv Jha
After this amicable settlement, I was so happy to see it happen. When you walk out of the court with complete satisfaction.. I empanelled myself with a legal services. I do two pro bono matters a month now: Adv Jha
It's very technical and be updated with judgements, circulars etc.: Adv Jha on tax litigation
The excitement of being in court..the challenge. There are no words to describe it. I have never regretted my decision of being a litigating lawyer: Adv Jha
Adv Malvika Trivedi: Can you tell us about your calmness in Court? That doesn't come from hardwork.

I don't know if I am that calm and composed... whatever was my own state of mind, when I entered court, I would become oblivious to everything: Justice Singh
At times, I do make a conscious effort to maintain my calm (as a Judge).. I have to respect the sanctity of a Judge. I have to do justice, I have to keep my calm : Justice Singh
Whether you are a judge or a counsel, you have to keep yourself clam or composed.. no matter which profession you are in: Justice Singh
Question from Adv Suruchi Suri: How do sociable lawyers take being a judge?

It's a tough question. You give up a lot. It depends a lot on your personality. : Justice Singh
Do you prefer being a lawyer or a judge? : Question.
Both are equally good. I have 29 years of being a lawyer and I enjoyed it everyday. It was always nice to be arguing. Only difference is that as a lawyer, I had to fight for somene. If someone needs justice, now I can do it with one stroke of a pen: Justice Singh
One thing that you think should change in the profession : Question

A mechanism through which the youngsters get a pedestal when they start. A lot of us got depressed.. went back home and never came back. : Justice Singh
Session comes to an end.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Bar and Bench

Bar and Bench Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @barandbench

Jul 25
Supreme Court to shortly hear the case pertaining to release of #UdaipurFiles movie

#SupremeCourt Image
The Central government on Thursday told the Supreme Court that the movie Udaipur Files is about a particular crime and not against any particular community

barandbench.com/news/udaipur-f…
Justice Kant: Have you filed any Petition in HC? How did Mr Sibal say that it was filed. First go to HC and pursue and then come here. Now other side says he is satisfied with central govt order and he does not want to pursue the case here. So you go to HC now. Why waste our time.

Sr Adv Kapil Sibal: This can be transferred to the HC. I can go to the HC but matter was pending here.

Sr Adv Gaurav Bhatia: we are withdrawing it.

Sibal: that is fine ..we will challenge the Central govt order in HC
Read 12 tweets
Jul 22
A Battle for Alimony in the #SupremeCourt

Chief Justice B.R:
What is your demand (for alimony)?

Lady: Just the house in Mumbai, free of all costs. And ₹12 crore as maintenance.

CJI Gavai: But that house is in Kalpataru… one of the good builders. You’re an IT person. You’ve done your MBA. You’re in demand ..Bengaluru, Hyderabad... Why don’t you work also?”

“You had a marriage for just 18 months,” the CJI continues, “and now you also want a BMW?” 18 months marriage and you want one crore for each month!

Lady: But he is very rich. And he sought the nullity of the marriage claiming I’m schizophrenic.

Sr Adv Madhavi Divan for the Husband: She has to work also. Everything cannot be demanded like this.

Lady: Do I look Schizophrenic My Lords

CJI Gavai: File income tax returns. But understand you cannot claim the properties of his father also.

Case again at 2 pm.Image
Bench reassembled

CJI Gavai: Where are the returns?

Lady: Yes it is here

Sr Adv Divan: Please give the entire copy .. see 2015-16 there is high income because he was employed then Image
CJI: Income in 2015-16

Divan: 2 crore 50 lakhs and 1 crore bonus itself..there are also allegations of proxy businesses. Let's take that also for example.. those balance sheets also there. There is nothing to talk about.. if he can just keep the job
Read 7 tweets
Jul 17
Plea in #SupremeCourt seeks FIR against sitting Delhi HC judges

Adv: This plea seeks registration of FIR against sitting HC judges. The issue is when I am the topper of the exam, but all judges.. ideally case should be heard by court 1..

Justice Surya Kant: Are you wanting to argue or you want to do bench hunting? We understand this kind of publicity stunts. Which college you did graduate and MBA?

Adv: engineering from DU and MBA From IIM Kozhikode

Justice Kant: still you make such scandalous allegationsImage
Adv: If this can be treated it as a civil petition.. then this court can..

Justice Kant: just because there are illegal, perverse petitions being filed . You cannot ask FIRs against judges. How many cases have you done

Adv: I did law for this case only

Justice Kant: that's what I thought. Tell me under which law judges are liable to be prosecuted for giving judgments against you.
Justice Kant: What happened to your contempt plea? Why unconditional apology to the tribunal then?

Adv: the court officer told me that earlier order passed was destroyed. the case was earlier only adjourned..

Justice Kant: why unconditional apology

Adv: Justice Vipin Sanghi told me to apologise to tribunal when I moved high court
Read 7 tweets
Jul 17
"We are constantly monitored by social media" - Solicitor General Tushar Mehta is making arguments opposing X Corp's plea in Karnataka HC challenging Central govt. 'Sahyog' portal to issue content blocking orders.

Matter before Justice Nagaprasanna. Track Thread for updates Image
SG Mehta: We are constantly being monitored by social media sites, we are products for them ... There is a kind of profiling for every individual.
Judge: Whatever you desire...

SG Mehta: .. You are bombarded with it (on the phone). Even speaking is now (monitored)

Judge: Yes, whatever you are speaking to someone, you get all the related content on phone.
Read 76 tweets
Jul 16
Supreme Court to shortly hear the plea where it had granted interim bail to Ali Khan Mahmudabad, Professor of Ashoka University, in connection with his Facebook post on Operation Sindoor #SupremeCourt #OperationSindoor Image
Sr Adv Kapil Sibal: A status report has been filed. Please see what was said earlier.. that probe shall be confined to the two FIRs only.
Sr Adv Sibal: please see page 2. Para 8 of the status report. it shows data extraction report of devices and SIT examining it. Then it says investigation shall be carried out in accordance with the law. Then it says reports from FSL received..now they want to know where you travelled for the last 10 years.
Read 14 tweets
Jul 10
Supreme Court to shortly hear a batch of petitions challenging the Election Commission of India’s June 24, 2025 order for a Special Intensive Revision (SIR) in Bihar months before the state goes to assembly polls #BiharElections2025 #SupremeCourtofIndia @ECISVEEP Image
Some of the petitions are by TMC MP Mahua Moitra, former AAP co-founder Yogendra Yadav, Manoj RJD MP Manoj Jha, Association for Democratic Reforms among others @MahuaMoitra @_YogendraYadav @RJDforIndia @pbhushan1
@MahuaMoitra @_YogendraYadav @RJDforIndia @pbhushan1 A bench of Justices Sudhanshu Dhulia and Joymalya Bagchi to hear the matter today #BiharElections2025 #SupremeCourtofIndia
Read 54 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(