Since I haven't read the primary source for the Rashtrakuta bit, I won't comment on it, but @kshetragnya may want to take a look at it. However, let us correct the bit about Lalitaditya. Lalitaditya swore an oath on Parihasakeshava that the king of Gauda would be safe if he+
+came to negotiations. However, he broke his word and had the king of Gauda killed. This act is, BTW, criticised by Kalhana, who is also a Kashmiri. After this, the adherents of the king of Gauda considered the murti of Parihasakeshava violated, since Lalitaditya had sworn+
+a false oath on it. So, they sought to destroy what they considered a defiled murti. However, they destroyed another murti by mistake. This is not about the deity being the favourite of Lalitaditya, but being targeted because a false oath was sworn on it. But to come to+
+to the larger issue at hand. In all the annals of Hindu history, whenever a temple/murti was destroyed either deliberately or accidentally, the king/commander doing so was condemned almost universally. The destruction of the temples of others was considered a sin and a shame+
+for the king. In the annals of Hindu history, there are about a dozen or so instances of kings destroying temples, and they are reviled for it. OTOH, Islamist kings destroying temples are a dime a dozen, and the total number of temples destroyed by Islamists run into several+
+thousands, at the very least. And while the Hindus reviled the kings who did so [at the very least, criticising the kings who did so], the chronicles of the Islamists are in raptures about the destroyed Hindu temples. In particular, I will urge people to read what Mahmud's+
+chroniclers have said about the temples of Mathura, Mohammad Ghori's chroniclers have said about the temples of Kashi, and the destruction of the temple of Somnath by various Islamist kings. The whole point is-destruction of temples was considered a sin by Hindus, while it was+
+considered a virtue by the Islamist kings and their chroniclers to destroy the temples of the kafirs. This is the vital point that those who seek to do an equal-equal between the few temples destroyed by Hindus and the thousands of temples destroyed by the Islamists ignore.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with ಷಣ್ಮುಖ சண்முக ষণ্মুখ షణ్ముఖ 𑆰𑆟𑇀𑆩𑆶𑆒 ཤནམུཁ

ಷಣ್ಮುಖ சண்முக ষণ্মুখ షణ్ముఖ 𑆰𑆟𑇀𑆩𑆶𑆒 ཤནམུཁ Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @maidros78

Feb 10
A short thread about the demographics of Haldwani-Kathgodam municipality. Let us see what has been happening to it since 1991. Since we don't have any census past 2011, we will limit our analysis to 1991-2011 census.
1) In 1991, Haldwani-Kathgodam had a total population of 1.04 lakhs. Out of this, the Hindu population was 67K and the Muslim population was 32K. There were also ~4K Sikhs. In short, the Muslim population was 31% of the city.
2) The population of the municipality exploded to 1.59 lakhs, an astonishing rise of 52% in 10 years. The demographics were now 1.07 lakh Hindus, and 45K Muslims. The Hindu population grew by 60%, while the Muslim population grew by 41%. In short, Hindu growth was greater!
Read 12 tweets
Jan 23
1) An interesting bit of news from my village in Hassan district. Apparently, last night, they had arranged for band set and procession, with the dragging of the chariot with the murti of Shree Raama in the evening [traditional for my village, BTW - all utsavas are in evenings]
2) But when they had just begun around 2000 in the evening, police turned up and told them that they had orders to prevent any utsavas and the police officer in charge pleaded that he was also a Hindu like them, but he had his orders and he had to prevent that utsava.
3) Initially, people were upset but backed down under the threat of police action. However, someone went and called HD Revanna and A Manju to come and help. Revanna intervened for the villages where utsavas had been cancelled, and forced the police to back down.
Read 5 tweets
Aug 2, 2023
1) Been seeing a few claims by apologists that the Gulf states would stop visas and/or deport Indians from the Gulf if India acted ruthlessly against the Islamist terrorists. Let us examine this claim a bit more closely, so that we can get some clarity.
2)a) The Gulf states cannot deport all Indians. Many Indians, especially those in higher levels of STEM, management, business, etc are indispensable in the short run for the economies of the Gulf states. They can be replaced, but Arabs would need to work at it for a few years.
3) b) A very large number of Indians in the Gulf are Indian Muslims. If the Gulf acted against them, the Muslims would be the hardest hit. They would return broken, and would be easy prey for the Gharwapsi activists in India, after their Islamic brethren booted them out.
Read 10 tweets
Jan 3, 2023
The reason why Congress was so much better in 1950s and 1960s was because they had a large number of idealist freedom fighters in their ranks, even if their leaders were scum. The reason why BJP-RSS is horrible is because it is full of self-seekers and mercenaries. No one cares!
Sanghis are even worse. They are so completely brainwashed by their organisation that there is no chance of turning them into Hindus. Do this experiment. Go to a shakha. Praise Golwalkar/Savarkar first. Then abuse Raama/Krishna/Hindu Gods in unprintable terms. No one will object.
For a Sanghi, RSS is his church, the leader his God. Hinduism exists only to serve Sangh. Hindus should sign over their present resources and future prosperity to Sangh, because `Sangh knows best'. Hindus may live if Sangh allows it, they must die when Sangh demands it.
Read 4 tweets
Nov 29, 2022
1) Here is a claim that Persians folded ~2.5 years after Muslim conquest of Persia. With no assertion it this is an exhaustive set of revolts against the Islamists by Zoroastrians, let us examine this claim.

By 660, the Arab conquest of Persia was over.
2) On a side note, before we actually examine Zoroastrian resistance, Muhammad saw Byzantine-Sassanid war and was greatly displeased with Sassanid victories in the initial stages, since it was infidel victory against people of the book. So, Islam was very hostile to Zoroastrians.
3) Resistance began immediately after Arab conquest. A Zoroastrian general, Hormozaan, in southern Iraq-Khuzestan revolted against Arabs in ~656 AD, fought for ~5 years, before he was captured and force-converted to Islam. His soldiers and their families were sold as slaves.
Read 22 tweets
Oct 15, 2022
To know just how fatally flawed the wooing of the Pasmanda concept is, one just needs to see how every massive atrocity on Hindus since the 20th century has been perpetrated, not by the Ashraf, but by the Pasmanda. Every single one! And BJP thinks they can be wooed away!
1) Atrocities on the Hindus of East Bengal [1905-1907]
2) South Punjab atrocities on Hindus [1915-1917]
3) Moplah atrocities [1921-23]
4) Various Bengal atrocities in 1920-1940s
5) Atrocities in Kashmir in 1930s
6) Partition atrocities

This is just an incomplete list.
The truth, despite what we are being told by BJP minions, is that it is a tiny fragment of Ashrafs that were against Jihad. Not because they disliked Jihad, but they were afraid of is consequences. And Muslim liberals were rare as Holbeins [they were there, but insignificant].
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(