No doubt Harvard's @jack_turban has reason to worry about trans people. Many teens in gender clinics present with a host of problems but is there any good data on how much suicide risk is *because* of trans issues versus, say, autism, same-sex attraction or family trauma? 1/
As for this new study, Dr Turban admits it uses a "convenience sample". Suicide risk studies relied on to promote gender clinic medicine typically claim very high risk but are low-quality from a research design point of view. I base this thread on talks with experts & reading.
These trans suicide studies can't be taken to be representative of trans people generally. They recruit participants via sources such as social media & trans activist groups, where the narrative of trans suicide risk circulates and may be reinforced by each successive study.
This cycle looks risky, because social contagion appears to play some role in suicide, and so there are mental health guides telling us how *not* to talk about suicide risk. See screenshot for comments by "Lillian", a young lesbian who used to move in trans/genderqueer circles.
The trans youth suicide studies are typically online, anonymous surveys which rely on strangers being accurate. They involve no follow-up to clarify. People can confuse self-harm with an actual suicide attempt. When trained interviewers are used, you may get less alarming rates.
The quasi-official suicide risk study for trans youth in Australia is Trans Pathways. It's another online, anonymous survey with no follow-up and a convenience sample recruited, in part, via queer university departments, peer safe spaces & trans rights & LGBTQ support groups.
As for Dr Turban's new study, it's not so new. It's based on 2017 adult data, a convenience sample, and is yet another online survey by trans advocacy groups, this time the US National LGBTQ Task Force & TransLifeline.
This non-representative group was recruited from "in-person PRIDE events as well as online listservs and other social media groups". There are trans people who prefer quiet lives, are alarmed by the recent turn in radical activism, & are less likely to end up in these surveys.
And in this study, it's not just trans. People could identify however they liked & were categorised as six groups with trans just one of them. "Two-spirit" & "pan gender" became "non-binary". "Human" became "other". All then these were headlined as "trans & gender diverse": TGD.
The online question appears to be a simple box-tick "Yes/No" with no follow-up. "Do you feel close to anyone who has attempted to end their life (but did
not die at the time)?". And "Did this person consider themselves to be transgender?".
Dr Turban focuses on the more serious question: what about knowing a person who did *actually" end their life? After all, it would be surprising if exposure to such a tragedy had no effect at all on mental & emotional well-being.
Unfortunately, the survey appears to use another bald Y/N question with no follow-up or probing. And even if a given answer is accurate, the low-quality design of the survey means we have no way of knowing whether this disturbing experience is typical of trans people generally.
This screenshot gives the results. Dr Turban tweets the 26.5% figure when the close friend who died was *not* believed to be trans by the TGD person surveyed.
That's traumatic enough but an observer might think the more relevant scenario for the mental health of the TGD person is when the close friend *was* believed to be trans. This figure is 23.6%. Lower than the figure tweeted by Dr Turban, but still disturbingly high, if accurate.
But because of its weak design, this study appears to leave us none the wiser than all the previous, similar trans suicide surveys about the likely suicide risk of trans people generally, out in the real world.
And it appears there is still no good research to tell us, when a young trans person presents with an elevated suicide risk, whether that is *because* of trans/gender dysphoria issues, or other serious, non-gender issues, clinical or social or to do with family.
If the cause is not specific to trans/dysphoria, and suicide prevention is framed as a trans project, the danger is that youth with high suicide risk who *happen to be trans as well* will not get the help they need. What kind of outcome would that be for trans rights?
Imagine a study where trans people are asked to rate their emotional wellbeing *before* they were first exposed to a reporting of a trans suicide risk study. Next they would estimate how many such studies they had been exposed to since, via @Twitter & @PinkNews.
And then they would be asked to rate their present emotional wellbeing. If I were to tweet the results, I'd acknowledge it was a convenience sample. (Please let me know if there's anything incorrect in this thread).

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh

Keep Current with Bernard Lane

Bernard Lane Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!


Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @Bernard_Lane

27 May
"Australia's federal Health Minister Greg Hunt has rejected any suggestion that he & his medical college advisers have endorsed the 'affirmative' treatment model of children’s hospital gender clinics." 1/…
"He was responding to Monday’s @AustralianStory program, in which the general medicine director of Royal Children’s Hospital Melbourne, Sarah McNab, claimed a 2020 medical college report to Mr Hunt was 'incredibly validating' for the hospital’s influential gender clinic."
"Victoria’s Health Minister Martin Foley was quoted (by @ABCaustralia as saying) he had to 'give Greg Hunt and the federal government kudos' for letting the medical college @TheRACP 'determine the outcome'."
Read 8 tweets
2 Mar
.@GDSNsupport holds online support meetings for family & friends of those affected by gender dysphoria. It was founded in 2020 by a therapist & two mums of natal daughters who identify as trans. The group is looking for more therapists as demand rises. 1/ Image
In the last 2 years there's been a surge of new groups driven by concern about gender clinic medicine. They cover parents, health professionals, detransitioners, LGB people, trans care consumers & trans adults worried about the risks to minors. Here's a sample of this new push:
Society for Evidence-Based Gender Medicine @SEGMtweets
Read 26 tweets
17 Feb
"We petition the American Academy of Pediatrics to renounce its scientifically unsupported 'affirmative' policy for young people with gender dysphoria." Interesting petition given role of guidelines/policies in promoting gender hormone drugs & surgery. 1/…
Gender clinic hormonal treatments for under-18s are based on "low quality" evidence, according to reviews of the medical literature, including the first systematic review by Chew et al 2018 published in the AAP's official journal.… https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih...
In the absence of high quality evidence for gender medicine, treatment guidelines & position statements from medical associations take on more significance -- and they have their critics.
Read 11 tweets
5 Feb
"(Victoria's anti-conversion therapy bill), which could mean up to a decade in jail or fines of almost $10,000 for anyone found trying to suppress or change another person’s sexuality or gender identity, passed by 27-9 votes late on Thursday." 1/…
Not a surprise, given the numbers. More significant, I think, was hearing several Australian MPs literate in the Tavistock court ruling, risks to minors in "affirmative" gender clinics, questions of consent to gender transition, & the emergence of regretful "detransitioners".
In the debate, some MPs, notably Liberal Democrat David Limbrick, tried to tease out the logic & possible consequences of this use of coercive state power. What does it mean to "change or suppress" sexuality or gender identity? He worried aloud about real-world scenarios.
Read 21 tweets
4 Feb
"Overcoming the flesh: the transgender movement wants to legally abolish physical sex. Risks and side effects are kept silent" | Big-hit 1400-word report in Germany's influential centre-right newspaper Frankfurter Allgemeine @faznet #GenderClinics 1/…
"(The @FDP party & Greens) have presented drafts for a (gender) self-determination law that for long stretches seem as if they were written by the activists themselves. At age 14, everyone should be able to decide each year whether they are legally to be considered man or woman."
Germany is the latest country to launch a dissident LGB group in protest & alarm at what they see as the capture of establishment LGBT organisations by the radical project to topple biological sex & erect self-declared "gender identity" in its place.
Read 21 tweets
2 Feb
"Doctors and psychiatrists want the Andrews government (in the Australian state of Victoria) to make changes to its plan to ban gay conversion therapy, due to concerns it will discourage some practitioners from treating vulnerable patients."…
This is significant criticism from the main medical body @amavictoria & college of psychiatry @RANZCP, which calls out the conflation of sexual orientation & gender identity that is the hallmark of activist-driven "conversion therapy" bans globally.
This concern raised by the college's Victorian branch is also interesting because the RANZCP's own policy arguably involves a more general, Queer Theory-style conflation of sexual orientation & gender identity.…
Read 5 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!

This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!