1. A very quick message before I sign off for #RoshHashanah
According to rabbinic tradition, the High Holidays are an auspicious time for introspection and repentance. One of the major themes of Rosh Hashana is the recognition of God as King and the ultimate judge.
2. I think a reason why this is emphasized at the beginning of the High Holidays is that it instills a sense of moral humility
3. If we think of ourselves as the arbiters of morality, we can justify virtually any action and frame any sin as being righteous such that we don't even feel we *need* to repent for any action.
4. Furthermore, we give ourselves the authority to judge others for their moral transgressions with whatever harshness we deem appropriate (usually while preaching tolerance and compassion when it suits us)
5. Social media is built on enraging people's moral indignations. Rosh Hashana is an opportunity to take a step back and recognize that we are not the real judges and that maybe we ought to extend to others the compassion which we would like for ourselves.
6. You'll find a range of various traditions emphasizing the process, but virtually all agree the ultimate goal of the season is a genuine commitment to do better, with this commitment demonstrated w/actions.
7. For whatever stage or situation in which you find yourself, my wish for everyone this #RoshHashanah is to try to minimize our judgmental voices in favor of emphasizing what we *can* do to be better.
2. First, here's Jason Stanley on "The End of Civic Compassion." Setting aside the laughability of the Before Time being an era of hand-holding, we've got a kicker of a paragraph in the next tweet newrepublic.com/article/181274…
3. Painting all of your political opponents as communists is fascist. Painting all your political opponents as fascists is not (and let's not even start with white-supremacy)
For those insisting on differentiating between Hamas and the Palestinian people as a whole, as recently as March 2023, 58% of those polled by the Palestinian Center for Policy and Survey Research supported armed confrontations. pcpsr.org/en/node/938
And from June 2022, "59% view armed attacks against Israelis inside Israel as serving the national interest in ending the occupation and 56% support these attacks" pcpsr.org/en/node/912
The pertinent question is not if Palestinians support the specific parties of Hamas or Fatah, but if they support murdering Jews.
1. I've made several comments about the debate over judicial reform in Israel. Due to Twitter being Twitter, criticizing one argument from one side is taken as an endorsement of the other.
For anyone who cares, here's my actual opinion 🧵
2. Checks and balances are not just a slogan, but in theory, ought to curb the potential excesses of any branch of government. The main problem is that any institution of power is susceptible to corruption.
This includes the checks and balances.
3. Rhetorical appeals to things like "will of the people", "democracy", "justice", and the like are typically empty references/appeals to vague concepts that just so coincidentally happen to correlate with one's preferences.
Today's topic: Blaming Tragedies and Suffering on Sin
2. When bad things happen in the world, e.g. natural disasters, it's not uncommon to find religious figures attributing these disasters and associated suffering to God rendering punishment for sin.
3. For one recent example, Rabbi Shmuel Eliyahu, Chief Rabbi of Tzefat Israel, compared the devastating earthquakes in Turkey to God punishing the Egyptians in the Red Sea immediately after the exodus. timesofisrael.com/top-national-r…