President Trump and Sen. Cruz say aloud they want a ninth justice now in order to
"settle election disputes" - in their favor, they obviously mean. But a court can only "settle" disputes if the court is accepted as legitimate. To be respected, courts must be worthy of respect.
Let's play it out. After the Bush v. Gore decision, Al Gore conceded in a very gracious statement. americanrhetoric.com/speeches/algor… The 50 Democratic senators accepted the outcome. Although many were unhappy, there were no big street protests. 1/x
Who believes that Bush-Gore will repeat if a Kavanaugh-Barrett court approves Trump voter suppression as legal? The court will settle *nothing.* Politics will move to the streets - with Trump and Barr twitching to use violence against protesters. It will be a catastrophe. 2/x
If the voting models are right, at least 145 million ballots will be cast in 2020. If the polls are right, Biden will win at least 10 million more of those votes than Trump. If the court steps in front of that locomotive, I don't think it's the locomotive that gets wrecked. END
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
The defendant's presence at his criminal trial is not an inconvenience or imposition, as Trump's partisans complain. The defendant's presence is a *right,* guaranteed by the Sixth Amendment. 1/x
The right to be present at one's trial is precious. But it is not absolute. The Supreme Court has ruled that presence at a trial can be forfeited by persistently bad behavior. 2/x
In Illinois v Allen (1970), the Supreme Court considered three options for dealing with "disruptive, contumacious, stubbornly defiant defendants": binding and gagging them, holding them in civil contempt, or temporarily removing them from the courtroom until they behave. 3/x
No big deal, just the second-largest newspaper in French Canada caricaturing Jews as vampires. lapresse.ca/actualites/car…
The Jew as vampire is one of the deepest myths of western culture. The 1922 film Nosferatu that inspired the La Presse cartoon also inspired Nazi cartoonists of the Third Reich anumuseum.org.il/blog/myth-vamp…
La Presse has removed the image, here's a screen shot. It substitutes Benjamin Netanyahu's face in an iconic still from the 1922 movie, Nosferatu. That film was riddled with antisemitic images and themes and directly inspired antisemitic cartoons in the Nazi press of the 1920s and 1930s.
Why was the Alger Hiss case such a big deal? The secrets Hiss betrayed to the Soviets were not so important. (He gave them, eg, blueprints for a new design for a Navy lifeboat.) It was Hiss's career trajectory that alarmed: the potential for a Soviet asset as secretary of state.
The Hiss case convulsed the country. But we've now had eight years of people with deep connections to the ex-KGB dictator in Moscow arriving at the very highest levels of US politics, media, and government - and that's become business as usual.
One conservative radio host used to - maybe still does - open his interviews by asking guests whether they believed Alger Hiss was guilty. Today, the answer might be, "Hiss was just a little ahead of his time."
News reports don't get more disturbing than this, from @propublica about the president of Mexico. propublica.org/article/mexico…
The @propublica story deals with Lopez Obrador's first run for president, in 2006. Lopez Obrador lost, a result he never accepted and tried to overturn. When he ran again in 2018, Lopez Obrador promised "hugs, not bullets" for the cartels.
@propublica As president, Lopez Obrador has shown favor to cartel criminals in many ways - perhaps most notably, by pressuring the Trump administration to release a former Mexican defense minister arrested in the US for drug corruption. Lopez Obrador then bestowed a medal on the ex-minister
Which is true, if by "existed" you mean "has been continuously sovereign under its present government."
It's also true that as a country founded in 1948, Israel is older than 134 of the 193 member nations of the United Nations.
The weird fact of the modern world is how *new* most countries are, even seemingly ancient ones. EG Egypt re-emerged as an independent sovereignty only in 1922 after half a millennium under Ottoman then British overlordship.
The concept of "indigenous peoples" is incoherent and generally sinister pretty much anywhere except Australasia. But it's an especial mess in the Middle East, where virtually every country is a broken-off bit of a long succession of ancient empires.