A PLATINUM THREAD: When President Trump launched his Platinum Plan in Atlanta, he spent a few minutes discussing HBCUs. Watch the clip, and then read the fact check. 1/
Trump claimed Obama and Biden cut funding for HBCUs in their first year. Backstory: In 2007 the Title III F program was created by the College Cost Reduction Act signed by George W. Bush. 2/ nasfaa.org/news-item/2379…
President Obama’s first budget was for FY10, and he did not continue the program as it was completed. See line item for strengthening HBCUs mandatory. 4/
The HBCU community fought to keep the program going, & applied pressure on Obama to do so. So the stories about him cutting the funding more accurately should read he initially declined to extend a program that was ending. Congress did fund for FY10. 5/ npr.org/templates/stor…
For FY11, President Obama announced the program would be a ten year program, with $85M annually for HBCUs. Additional money would be given to other MSIs. This was the Student Aid and Fiscal Responsibility Act (SAFRA). 6/ obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/the-press-offi…
In 2019, President Trump did what Bush and Obama both did. His initial FY20 budget did not include the $85M annually for the Title III F program, called SAFRA under Obama. (Line g- the actual amount in FY19 was $79.7M) 7/
The Thurgood Marshall College Fund noted that “to cease providing any mandatory Title III funding… represents an approximately $80 million fiscal cliff for HBCUs.” 8/ tmcf.org/events-media/t…
Rep. Alma Adams wrote and shepherded the passing of the FUTURE Act, which replaced SAFRA. As Trump said in Atlanta, it is for 10 years, just like the Obama era program. 9/ uncf.org/news/a-once-in…
Next he mentions 42 heads of HBCUs meeting with him annually. There are 101 HBCUs. Maybe about 60 were at the White House in 2017. The meeting was with DeVos; with him it was a photo opp. He thought it would drive numbers; it didn’t. He fired Omarosa. 10/ washingtonpost.com/national-secur…
So I’m not sure who he is referring to coming back annually asking for funding. HBCUs are in each of his budgets as they have been in previous president’s budgets. In fact, the Title IIIB funding goes back at least to 1987. 11/ www2.ed.gov/pubs/Biennial/…
He said he worked on it, along with Senators Perdue and Loeffler. Perdue is on record as a supporter of the Senate’s version of Adams’ bill; Loeffler was busy fighting with the WNBA. 12/ 11alive.com/article/news/s…
It was odd (for the 2nd or 3rd time now) hearing Trump say he gave us more than we even asked for. The FUTURE Act is $85M a year, just as it has been since FY08. 13/ nytimes.com/2019/11/08/us/…
The Platinum plan is really a skeletal outline, but HBCUs are mentioned and it proposes to increase the Pell Grant (which is a major priority by the HBCU community). 14/ cdn.donaldjtrump.com/public-files/p…
I participated in a discussion on the Platinum Plan with @rolandsmartin on September 26th, and we discussed HBCUs in depth. 15/15
I'm sorry @PolitiFact - but your fact check regarding HBCUs is incorrect. A 🧵His campaign "promise" was half a sentence from an October 2016 speech in Charlotte: "My plan will also ensure funding for historic black colleges and universities..." 1/
But as I have shared, he proposed over $100M in cuts to HBCUs in his 4 budget proposals, including the program made permanent under the FUTURE Act. He zeroed it out in his FY20 budget, noted by the Thurgood Marshall College Fund. 2/
Too often we take things out of context. So while traveling I decided to listen to the entire 45-minute Trump even at the Detroit church. The news didn't indicate he mentioned HBCUs. But let me go through his remarks- a 🧵 1/
He said "We have record funding to historically Black colleges and universities. You all know that." But what he never says is that for his 4 budgets, he requested $107M in cuts for the 3 largest Title III programs!
Here are the DOE budget tables, FY18- FY21. Compare his request, what the House and Senate proposed, and the final appropriation. In spite of him trying to cut every year, CONGRESS increased HBCU funding by $118M during his term. Taking credit without doing the work! 3/
“Lying requires no work and has no limits. It demands no proof.... Told often and emphatically enough, lies can overwhelm the truth...” Brian Rosenberg
Quick 🧵on this evolving lie... 1/
Let's start with the "where they had none." HBCUs have had federal funding since the 1960s. You can see almost 20 years here. But note in 2008 there is a new category- mandatory funding. 2/
Under President Bush the College Cost Reduction Act was passed, which included a new, 2-year mandatory program for HBCUs. 3/
Since folks continue to speculate what's on this paper, I thought I should tell you. (Hint: nothing). A 🧵 1/
Way too many people think that Trump's HBCU executive order provided funding, provided permanent funding, or totally funded HBCUs. Point 1- there is NO MONEY allocated. In fact, you can't even find the word million or billion. 2/
There is a debate that continues about the ability of President's to appropriate funding through an EO. This is a good article explaining it.
I’ve recently realized how often people cite Dr. Lomax “thanking” President Trump as proof that he was a consequential force in HBCU funding. A 🧵 about the thanks was nowhere near a ringing endorsement. 1/
People get the quote from this article where it says “Michael Lomax, president and CEO of the United Negro College Fund, thanked Trump and the thousands of advocates who lobbied Congress to support the bill.” 2/ apnews.com/article/c4834e…
The UNCF press release provides full context. Before even mentioning Trump, Lomax clearly indicates bipartisan support PLUS pressure by HBCU alumni and advocates to get this done. If the President had placed this in his budget, this would not be needed (KEY POINT). 3/
I've had enough of people sharing this article which masquerades as journalism, and even more disappointed to see someone who should know better add to the foolishness. So here is a 🧵to make it make sense. 1/
Here is the @Newsweek article. Newsweek is wrong for posting this article on a number of fronts. First, it summarizes a few paragraphs of the original article by the Associated Press, and then pastes the rest of the @AP article. 2/ newsweek.com/hbcu-funding-f…
Here is the ORIGINAL article. Compare the framing of the story with the titles. The Newsweek article misleads folks by saying funding falls, suggesting HBCUs had $45 BILLION that Biden cut (more on what $45 billion buys in a bit). 3/ apnews.com/article/corona…