The special council meeting introducing the Reimagining Public Safety Taskforce to CPAB, SSOC and Police Commission has begun. oakland.legistar.com/MeetingDetail.…
The Special Meeting is having video glitches and failures, Kaplan and Clerk Landingham observe that this has happened before during Zoom meetings with a large number of participants [vs attendees] #oakmtg
Second call about OPD failures to enforce "basic laws" around Lake Merritt to this meeting. This caller is concerned about Reimagining will lead to "more problems", and wants to "building up new capabilities", suggesting police need to back those as well #oakmtg
Asata Olugbala says the main problem that the City keeps saying "violence prevention is working", but its not. She wants the city to be more sober in assessing Measure Z, Ceasefire, etc. #oakmtg
Kaplan introduces a policy suggestion for OPD to make “guns the top law enforcement priority,” and "requesting follow up information on gun tracing, and timely deployment to notifications of shootings and armed robberies", links that to de-prioritizing policing protests #oakmtg
Kaplan's report suggests that OPD has had a diminishing success in tracing guns since 2017, almost half as many handguns traced in 2019 vs 2017, 2019 decrease over 2018 #oakmtg
Gallo says that the difference between a politician and a drug dealer is that the drug dealer gives you something. Recounts eyewitnessing a gun robbery, recently, suggests gun crimes are happening due to social failures #oakmtg
Reid says that the highest number of homicides is in D7, and the second highest is in D5. Wants a strategy on "reducing level of insanity", like Gallo, he's describing social issues, repair as core issues, needs. #oakmtg
Reid says that D7 is returning to its nickname "killing fields of Oakland". He describes, Guatemalan gangs and African American gangs taking each other's lives, but he begins to get back into law and order territory by saying he doesn't even know if there is a solution #oakmtg
Reid pulls out his oft-used claim that he walks his dogs in San Leandro, says that if shooters shot straighter, there'd be a higher murder number. He is now saying that young Latino and AA don't believe in Covid proscriptions, drinking 40oz, buying drugs, selling drugs #oakmtg
Reid spoke for nearly ten minutes, incredible that no one cut him off, given the number of speakers and organizations present today. #oakmtg
Harris says she doesn't support defunding police, but rather making it more efficient. She largely agrees with Reid's assessment of the issues in D7, and says that East Oakland has become a dumping ground for everything that Oakland doesn't want. #oakmtg
Harris complains about a lack of transparency and accountability within Ceasefire #oakmtg
Bas says that Covid has exacerbated social inequities, lack of jobs and lack of constructive things to do. She says the Reimagining Taskforce has potential to "break the cycle" of doing the same things, investing in alternatives to policing #oakmtg
Thao says that she agrees with Gallo about going after root causes, after school and library programs, internships. Community policing, and having community leadership. She says that Ceasefire needs to do a better job of being visible in community #oakmtg
Remarkably, the Ceasefire evaluation included in today's agenda packet was co-authored by one of the original designers of the Ceasefire model, Anthony Braga. Its weird that the OPD commissioned a study from someone one assumes is invested in having the program appear to work.
Cespedes is giving a background on Department of Violence Prevention. He's been the Chief of the program--so named to appear to be an analogue to the Police Chief. DVP appears to have a handful of staff members, and wields its programs thru 21 third party orgs #oakmtg
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Carson arguing for his part, that the schedule is soon for his successor on the BOS to be a functional part of the process. "implore people to deeply consider that"
Carson said that the timing on moving on both recalls was "premature...I'm not too sure that after one year in office, an active campaign to remove people gave people the opportunity to focus on the job they were elected to do..."
Vote Update: Latter tranches of votes come in lower for Mayoral recall, but likely won't be enough. Latest batch itself 43% vs 57%. Total gap still large: on Friday was 63.8% vs 36.15%, now 61.59 vs 38.41. With 99K counted, this could be around half the votes with 70-80% turnout
Relative newcomer Rowena Brown pulled ahead of Leronne Armstrong in straight votes, way ahead in RCV. The trend of Brown getting a huge number of Wang's votes, despite Empower Oakland recommending an LA/Wang slate continues: she gets half Wang's votes, double Armstrong's share
Things are worse for Dreyfuss' bag man for the recall, Len Raphael, losing votes with each update. He was at 15.19% Friday in straight votes, now 14.92%. He actually benefits in RCV from getting a few hundred of Frank's votes, boosting his share to 16.78% Unger 83.2%
Sitting in on today's case conference where Chanin and Burris' report back to NSA will be heard. Chanin & Burris say current scandal, where Armstrong's IAD failed to hold a police officer who paid witnesses and perjured, shows the OPD should be put under more rigorous oversight.
*accountable...at today's meeting, Chanin, Burris and also the Oakland Police Commission Chair, Marsha Peterson. It will be interesting to see where she and OPC land on this, as she and others have seemed resistant to holding Armstrong accountable
I also see Mac Muir, CPRA Director. CPRA's independent investigation of IAD's faulty investigation is what led to all this...but its unclear that investigation is even available to plaintiff attorneys, Burris and Chanin, as they referred to DBG & Ali Winston's reporting instead.
At Life Enrichment, a crowd came out to show support for Carroll Fife who has been under attack by right wing groups aligned with recalls, led by Dominique Walker, "thank you for all that you do for us", listed Fife's accomplishments and help for community with homeless families.
Shereena Thomas recounting how Fife helped her through health problems and disability. "I don't know any other person who has been in the trenches...I don't know of any other Cm who has done for community as she has. The record speaks for itself and I have receipts"
"I grew up on 57th in Oakland, I've been homeless 5 times in my life...I was sleeping in my car [when covid came], I was working a temp job & I couldn't work remotely..." Fife helped pay for hotel, buy a car, & work w/Moms 4 Housing. Victim of PTSD, single mom whose son passed
🚨As I seem to be the only reporter interested in, and covering, the closure of this year's budget gap now that its confirmed the Coli sale won't cover FY 23-24s deficit, here's what the City Admin now suggests for closure, along with substantive changes from previous plan🧵
The CAO previously proposed 30 MM in cancelled carry forwards, transfers to other funds & etc to close about 20 MM of gap. That would have been 30 MM, but CAO left a 10 MM buffer contingency just in case. That left about 42 MM, which was meant to be covered by portion of Coli $$.
Now the City is absorbing back the contingency, making it an even 30 MM again. That leaves 30 MM to close; 19.3 MM of that will be resolved thru the following actions, including cancelling a new $9 MM OPD/OFD fleet, & 6MM use of library bond measure on library exp
I'll revise this: in their ignorance of the politics, OPC got Chief Mitchell and a staffer to acknowledge what Council never will:
Mitchell: "the police dept is slowly shrinking..."
OPD budget staffer: "cola increases in staffing, that makes up the difference [in increase]"
Mitchell returned to the subject and made it completely clear: "the cola increases built into the OPOA contract" increase the costs of the police, while the OPD is shrinking.
What OPC won't be able to cohere on here, Oakland's policing is currently untenable in its current conception. Every year budget is increasing due to guaranteed 3.5% cola increases the Council was badgered into passing by Schaaf and Armstrong. Meanwhile, academies underproducing