This right here, is almost all of consumer psychology summarized.
This picture is a real-life proof (take it for what it's worth) of the Prospect Theory - which was presented by Dan Kahneman and Amos Traversky in a seminal paper in 1979 bit.ly/2Gsq7i2
They (actually only Kahneman) went on win the Nobel prize in 2002.
A layman summary of the theory is
Pain from loss >> Pleasure from gain
It said
People are willing to take a sure shot than gamble on getting higher gains (another form of loss aversion) - which is shown in Poll 1
(60% took the sure shot Rs. 500)
You increase the amount to 1L - this 60% will become even higher.
You increase it to 1Cr - and almost everyone will take the sure shot.
Mathematically, the expected outcome is the same
100% of sure shot amount = 50% of double the sure shot amount
But people are not rational
It also said
People are far likelier to gamble to avoid sure shot loss (another way of describing loss aversion)
Which explains poll 2 results
70% would spin the wheel rather than take the sure shot loss
You increase the sure shot loss amount and even more people will gamble.
Which in other words means,
so called Risk averse people (in Poll 1 who took the sure shot) become risk loving when it comes to avoiding loss.
This seems very intuitive and obvious, but when described with data in 1979 was path breaking.
We used to use this a lot at nearbuy
If a deal had 2 choices
Option 1: Pick from 1 starter, 1 main course and 1 dessert (equivalent to sure shot option)
Option 2: Get X% off on the entire bill (equivalent to spin the wheel)
People opted for Option 1.
Because they didn't know beforehand what they would order.
If a deal said
Get Rs. 500 off
That was better than saying Get 50% off - even if both options gave the same results
If we showed deals that had already expired in the search results, that would drive higher conversion, than if we only showed live deals.
Because people realized they lost out on something. The pain from that was greater.
The biggest impact I saw though was in running the company
If people had a fixed salary of 100 and variable expected pay of 10, their CTC was 110
If we announced the variable pay has been increased to 30, people were happy.
Their CTC was now 130
But if we didn't do well as a company and had to cut down the variable pay from 30 to 20, thus bringing the CTC to 120, people were far angrier than they were happy when it went from 100 to 130
The drop from 130 to 120 affected them more
Than the gain from 100 to 130
I can spend a lifetime on how this paper changed so much about how I saw the world, from the point I read the paper.
There is a great book
Thinking fast, Thinking Slow which is a wonderful introduction to this concept (and a lot of powerful concepts) amzn.to/34koqeH
The book that I loved more though was
The undoing project
It the story of how Kahneman and Tversky came together, how they fell apart and how their research changed the world in such meaningful ways.
(I am a sucker for stories)
I hope you pick up these 2 books, read the paper and realize this deep embedded loss aversion human mind of ours and how it is constantly at work in so many ways :)
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Instead of saying no (or worse, saying yes), ask for permission to say no. "Is it ok if I say no?"
Most people will accept your no, this way.
2/ Don't want to come across as self obsessed?
Whenever someone shares anything about their life, resist the urge to share your own experience around it, unless asked.
Avoid "me too", "I also do this", "I was thinking exactly the same".
3/ Want to deal better with failure?
Practice failing.
Everyday, pick up a task with a high chance of failure, but low cost of failing.
Ask strangers for money.
Send cold emails.
Ask someone out.
Within 30 days, you will start dealing with failure a lot better.
1995
I was 15.
Papa had just lost his job.
We were down to our last few thousands in the bank.
He went to the bank to withdraw 10K.
On his way back, someone robbed him of it.
We plunged into chaos.
Financial debt.
Personal favours.
Collectors at our doorstep.
I remember days where ma papa would skip a meal, because we didn't have money.
Ma's salary of Rs. 1000 as a primary school teacher was supporting us.
At the peak of this crisis, we received news that the government would pay compensation for Papa’s house in Kashmir, which was destroyed by now.
Accepting the compensation meant he would never, ever have the home he grew up in.
But that money would save us.
And it did.
20 years back, at the age of 24, I got my first ever job.
It paid me Rs. 14,746 per month in hand.
In 2 years, at 26, I was earning 12L per annum.
Another 3 years, it reached 33L per annum.
Here is how it happened...
In Mar '04, at the age of 24, I dropped out of my PhD program at Michigan State University and came back to India.
What made the decision easy was the 100% scholarship I was on.
There was no tangible loss of money.
Just the intangible burden of letting down everyone in my world.
With no goals, no plans and no visibility over my future, the first thing I needed was financial independence and stability.
I had to get a job.
Any job.
I tapped into my (limited) network, spoke to my friends, applied through newspaper adverts, went for walk-in interviews.