Haven't watched the whole thing, but main problem here seems to be that both the socdems and Chomsky put loads of stock in voting or not voting as if it's of massive importance and not the least consequential activity it's possible to engage in.
If the past four years has shown anything it should be that reforming the Democratic Party is impossible. So much effort was put into it for so little result.
There's a chasm between individually holding your nose and voting in a swing state, vs doing interviews telling people it's their moral duty to either definitely do that or definitely not do that.
Very good thread on (not) voting as consumerism here, which is more a self-critique of some of the weaker anarchist arguments against voting, but epitomises the line from Briahna Joy Gray in that clip.
If you read his endorsement of Biden, he praises electoralism more generally, like the Sanders campaign. No discussion of the very successful direct action against Trump the past four years (strikes, riots, sick outs, blockades).
There's a more general problem, hinted at but not made explicit in this piece, that the framing of pro-lockdown vs denialism is handing over analysis of the pandemic to two extremely right wing narratives that don't even disagree that much.
Lockdown, as it existed from March, combined some necessary things (shutting down mass public events in poorly ventilated buildings) with completely arbitrary, authoritarian, counter productive stuff like banning people from sitting down in parks or going for long walks.
Lockdown as re-introduced yesterday with Tier 3 restrictions, bans sitting two metres away from your mate in the park, but allows you to sit 1m from a stranger inside a pub as long as you've both ordered a meal.
As usual fucking woeful that after a full week of leaks there's not even a list of the bullshit. Also, this looks like it's similar to the rules Ireland has had for months.
Ireland's rules said you can only enter a pub if you're served a 'substantial meal', defined as more than €9. Substantially food based may not include the meal requirement though who knows.
"Pubs and bars... can only remain open where they operate as if they were a restaurant - which means serving substantial meals, like a main lunchtime or evening meal. They may only serve alcohol as part of such a meal."
The big thing that Bookchin gets wrong is he did not really deal fairly with the council communists or post-war councilist Marxists like CLR James, probably due to experiencing 'Marxism' as a Stalinist. Although this also mirrors his later rejection of anarchism too.
Smith goes straight in for the 'over 100 million' victims of communism line, a favourite refrain of the far right. The problem is this number has been criticised as massively inflated even by authors featured in the book it comes from, the Black Book of Communism.
The Black Book of communism was released in 1997 on the 80th anniversary of the Russian Revolution. Twelve historians contributed, though the bulk of the writing was by Nicolas Werth on the USSR. The book was prefaced and titled by Stephanie Courtois without input from the rest.
Always fun when people take an idea put forward by multiple 19th century anarchist thinkers and Marx, the Paris Commune, the IWW, the black liberation movement, entire Mexican towns, and try to associate it with teenage stoners.
"The centralized state power, with its ubiquitous organs of standing army, police, bureaucracy, clergy, and judicature..originates from the days of absolute monarchy, serving nascent middle class society as a mighty weapon in its struggle against feudalism."
"Having once got rid of the standing army and the police – the physical force elements of the old government – the Commune was anxious to [disestablish and disendow the churches]" - Marx, Civil War in France, 1871
The UK government has 'launched' a test and trace system this week, which is being used as the justification to re-open non-essential shops and send reception, year 1 and year 6 children back to school. It's also relaxed some curfew restrictions at the same time.
Financial support to people unable to work due to lockdown has been limited to 80% payments via employers through the furlough scheme, and 80% payments to (some) self-employed people.
With test and trace, any one in contact with someone who tests positive for Covid-19 (less than 2 metres for 15 minutes or more) is expected to self-isolate for fourteen days. This means if you come off furlough, go into work in a shop, then have to self-isolate, you get nothing.