So here I'm going to start a Forecast thread

First up, the general election forecast. This is basically a blended model of my lean-Trump and lean-Biden undecided models, with weight to the lean-Biden because there's evidence to suggest the undecideds - while fewer - will break D
Notably, in this forecast, Biden relatively easily wins the major swing states.

The most contentious states are Iowa, Ohio, Texas, and Georgia with Biden narrowly winning Iowa and Georgia and narrowly losing Iowa and Texas.

Remember, these are just probabilities, not concrete
Put another way, my forecast comes out like this.

I wouldn't be shocked if Trump held Iowa and Georgia, nor if Biden took Ohio and Texas. Beyond that, a close election in NC, PA, or FL? Not really seeing it being closer than 2-3 pts as of now
1/2
My forecast differs from @FiveThirtyEight "projected vote share" by more than 1% in the following areas, my forecast listed first:

Trump MI (44.4 vs 45.5)
Biden WI (51.5 vs 52.9)
Biden OH (48.1 vs 49.6)
Biden AZ (51.9 vs 50.8)
Trump AZ (45.4 vs 47.9)
Trump FL (46.5 vs 47.7)
2/2

Trump NC (47.2 vs 48.5)
Biden NH (55.5 vs 54.3)
Trump NH (43.0 vs 44.8)
Biden ME (56.9 vs 55.4)
Trump ME (40.4 vs 43.1)
Trump GA (47.4 vs 50)
Trump TX (49.74 vs 51.1)
Biden NV (55.5 vs 52.7)
Trump NV (42.0 vs 45.8)

They're more bullish on Trump in 9 states, on Biden in 2.
Here are my updated Senate probabilities.

A few discrepancies from 538 (my % first)

AZ: 85%D vs 78%
MN: 87%D vs 93%
ME: 70%D vs 62%
GA: 39%D vs 26%
GA-S: 36%D vs 29%
AK: 34%D vs 22%
SC: 36%D vs 23%
KY: 13% D vs 4%
MT: 41%D vs 31%
I have D control Senate at ~87%, compared to 69% for @FiveThirtyEight.

Notably, they have a very wide distribution of outcomes.

I have the most common outcome as 51 or 52 Dem seats at ~20%, followed by 53 at 17% and 50 at 13%.

Their most common outcome of 51D is just 14%
Their model suggests there's a 20% chance that the Senate DOESN'T fall within R+2 to D+5

I have that as a 4% chance. That's big.

If I were a betting man, I'd take them up on their probability of 51 and 52 Dem seats (14% and 12.6%, respectively) at roughly +600 and +700 odds

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Carl Allen

Carl Allen Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @RealCarlAllen

13 Oct
1/x

Who's ready for an election thread and a (statistically literate) poll analysis & update?

There's an OBSESSION with "what the polls missed" in 2016. If you follow me, you'd know: the polls weren't wrong - people just read them wrong.
2/x

That's part of why @FiveThirtyEight's statistically invalid analysis of

"poll margin - election margin = poll error"

Is so damaging. Not only is it logically and statistically invalid, it leads them/the public to believe the POLLS were wrong when that's likely not true.
3/x

In 2016, Hillary had a decent lead, IF YOU ONLY LOOKED AT MARGIN

But you'll note - this is important -IN NO SWING STATE DID SHE POLL ABOVE 47%

Compare that to 2020

Biden is polling at ABOVE 49% in MI, PA, WI, NH, MN, ME, FL, NC, NV (and above 50% in the first 6 of those)
Read 15 tweets
12 Sep
1/x The polls weren't wrong, you just read them wrong.

The spread in a poll matters some. But a 50-47 lead (+3) is FAR MORE ROBUST than a 46-40 lead (+6)

People see a poll avg at 46-40, and when the result is 47-49, they say "pOlL wAS WrONg"

From +6 to -2?!? Off by 8!!!

Nope.
2/x

If the polls were "off" by 3 or 4 but the result of the election didn't swing because of it, no one would care, except pollsters. We wouldn't be talking about it.

Here's the most important question: what do polls measure?
3/x

This seems like a silly question, but think about it. What do polls measure?

Polls measure preference and plans.

What do polls not measure?

How/if undecided voters will vote.

It seems that people are criticizing polling for not measuring things it doesn't attempt to.
Read 37 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!