What brought you to the hospital?
I can barely make out words of a woman in her late 70’s. She is weak. Doesn’t eat. She has a leaking feeding tube in her stomach to make up for her lack of appetite.
I hear a story of a pancreatic cyst removal. The lady asserts she’s cured /2
Judging by the fact her pancreas and spleen were taken out, she is probably in denial. Not uncommon to misunderstand medical communication. Her story makes no sense but I shut up, tell her I will review her records and come back to tell her what happened. /3
I barely scratch the surface of her medical record when I get a call from the Covid wardens that her frantic son is downstairs. His mom called and said she was dying. We are locked down but I make my way downstairs to talk to the guy. /4
The son collaborates his mom’s story. Healthy lawn mowing older Southern lady goes in for routine pancreatic cyst removal. Five total surgeries later and two organs missing she is struggling for life. /5
Son blames the surgeon. I cannot be sure. Surgeries are unpredictable.
Have you learned anything from this story? I ask of the man
I never want to go to the hospital.
We derive different meanings from the same situation. /6
I go back to talk to the patient. How was your cyst discovered? On a scan. Why were you scanned? She didn’t know.
Upon more probing I find out she came to the doctor with pain in her stomach. /7
Back to history reading I go. Chronic pancreatitis. 20 years.
Back to patient. Oh I’ve had it for years.
What’s the cause? Did anybody tell you?
Sure wasn’t my drinking!
Women of her demographic profile didn’t drink back in the day. /8
Here we are presented with several realities.
A woman and her family are convinced she was healthy as a horse, struck by random affliction, maybe mutilated by the hand of a surgeon. /9
I perceive her random affliction as likely result of eating habits that started years before she got a diagnosis of chronic pancreatitis. Likely suffering some GI symptoms she ignored until she got some pills to mask them. /10
I google for fun to see what explanations people get about chronic pancreatitis (or acute, nothing starts chronically). I find nothing inspiring or pointing in the direction “if you feel sick after eating, consider looking into what you eat”. /11
She’s so sick and her stomach drains so much, nobody knows what to do. Of course common thought was to “have more surgery”.
Of course reasonable course is to leave her be. Give her drugs to alleviate her suffering and hope she can heal within. Time and hope. /12
This archaic approach eventually worked. She got somewhat better.
Her surgeon’s promise was literally 1-3 day in and out experience that dragged into 3 months and permanent debility. /13
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
A year ago in the summer a local church held a talk by a former governor on science. I know little of churches but science holds a special place in my heart. Enough for me to venture out to this Lutheran church founded by first settlers 150 years ago. I was not disappointed. /1
Villagers (without torches and pitchforks) dutifully gathered to listen to a PowerPoint presentation of what seemed to be proof of God’s existence. /2
A former chemistry professor at one of country’s best liberal colleges was showing us pictures of dinosaurs and DNA strands for nothing screams science more than dinosaurs and a DNA strand. /3
This story shows how little doctors understand what they are doing to their loved ones and how much suffering the elderly suffer due to contradictory demands of confused relatives regardless of education. /2
It’s a story of a very old man who should have died quickly and at peace at home. Yet his fate was to be saved. Saved he was into endless suffering. /3
Dissent is never easy. Two broad possibilities in traditional cultures: voluntarily exit from a tribe (exile or becoming a hermit) or voluntary adoption/acceptance of madness/craziness. Both practices tied to Eastern religions. /2
Fools for Christ/Holy fools/Blessed fools were people who pretended to be insane to expose the sins of the world.
Hermits went into seclusion to find God.
Both practices are ascetic and derive from the conflict of what one may find true colliding with reality around. /3
Eating is passive. You don’t want to be passive. First step - figure out what food is. Once you know what food is, hopefully you will refuse to eat garbage.
In case of bread - flour, water, salt, yeast. /1
My (maternal) Grandmother ate bread with each meal, a small half piece of a slice. Upon seeing her eat bread with pasta my father would lament “Mom, you are eating bread with bread”. Grandmother remained unperturbed. /2
For Russians and Ukrainians bread is holy. You don’t throw it on the ground. Bread is the staff of life (Russian literal head of everything). /3
The discrepancy is the following. Scientists quantify the importance of things. People have the power of their authority to decide what is important. /1
Modern medicine is mitigation of side effects from disturbing biological default states. It is an uncontrolled experiment on people influenced by delusion of grandeur and control. /3