Thread by @mymundanemind

For a century, 'Chesterton's Fence' has been used as a fine heuristic for rudimentary separation of Conservative thinking from Progressive thinking.

This is often told in such a way that implies the Conservative wouldn't tear down the fence. This is incorrect.
1/

This distinction lies in the reasoning. The Progressive assumes that if they cannot personally think of a reason for the fence's existence, this is good enough reason to tear it down. The reasoning here is internal, and probably arrogant.
2/

The Conservative reasons from both internal *and* external sources, in order to first determine the function of the fence, and then go about deciding if it ought to remain. This reasoning is slower, but it still takes place linearly

Less informed ➡️ more informed
3/

The point is, the Conservative might well land on the same conclusion as the Progressive (tear down the fence), he just requires a *good reason* to do so. He needs to decide that the fence has become pointless, a hindrance, or asymmetrically benefiting others at his expense.
4/

The Left calls the Right monsters. Cheaters. Fascists. Underminers of institutions. Etc.

Merrick Garland gives some teeth to a bit of this, but not much. The rest is often a bizarre form of projection. Those speciously changing the rules accuse their opponents of it instead.
5/

The Right has largely leaned into institutions functions as they ought. They've watched over the past several years as the Left perverts every lever of Government in pursuit of power. Crossfire Hurricane. Mueller Investigation. Brett Kavanaugh. Impeachment. And now this.
6/

I don't know what the Right will do if the Left gets away with stealing this election. They might just take the Senate 'W and go home, looking to 2022. Folks like @benshapiro are signaling that as their plan. Okydoke, fair enough. You do you.
7/

But there are others that will look at the fence of restraint and respect for institutions in their own yard, then look across the street and see how much power the Left gained since tearing their fence down, and really begin to consider doing the same.
8/

FWIW, I deeply dread this scenario. Two unprincipled & unscrupulous parties is a nightmare scenario I don't want to imagine. I'm only saying that at some point, the Conservatives might say "Enough is enough," and reason that the fence has to go for their own self-preservation.
9/

As they've many times done before, the Left very well could create the monster nemesis they're seeking, if the Right walks away from this election seeing how brazenly (and effortlessly!) the Left was able to undermine, perhaps even steal it, with no consequences whatsoever.
-end