Many of you have probably seen this viral image of Kamala Harris created by Bria Goeller and Goodtrubble; there are unfortunately many misconceptions and questions surrounding the image, let me explain what I've been able to figure out after doing some digging...
But first, if you share this image, please credit Bria Goeller and Goodtrubble. They deserve the recognition and it's frustrating when artists don't get credit when their work is shared. instagram.com/briagoeller/ and instagram.com/goodtrouble/. Onto some explanations...
...The shadow of the little girl in Goeller's artwork was not a reference to artwork by contemporary artist Kara Walker, it is a reference to Norman Rockwell's 1964 painting "The Problem We All Live With." Given Walker's style, I can see how people would mistake it for Walker.
Some people are interpreting the little girl in Bria Goeller's artwork as being Kamala Harris as a child, it is in fact Ruby Bridges who was the first African American student to integrate an elementary school, who is the child depicted in Norman Rockwell's painting.
I assumed (incorrectly) that Bria Goeller's artwork was created yesterday after the announcement of the election results. Actually, Bria Goeller posted the artwork on Instagram on Oct 23. Here is Goeller's Instagram post: instagram.com/p/CGtTFawB-7b/
The image raises other questions I couldn't find answers for: who was the photographer who shot the photo of Kamala Harris? Goeller says on Instagram: "...we got the go-ahead and copyrights:..." but who did Goeller get the rights from, and for what part(s) of the image? If...
...Goeller did get the go-ahead and copyrights, why didn't she mention the photographer's name? (should she?) Rockwell is not mentioned either. Does Goeller need to mention Rockwell as a reference, or not? Should Goeller assume people know that Rockwell painting? There is...
...a lot to consider and think about here, I discuss all of this and more with Lauryn Welch, in this Art Prof stream we did this morning:
Norman Rockwell's painting "The Problem We all Live With" is an iconic painting, but in researching the viral image by Bria Goeller which refers to Rockwell's painting, I'm seeing that as famous as this painting is, many people do not know it. Here's a deeper dive:
Many people have said there's no need for Goeller to credit Rockwell when presenting her artwork, and that it's unfair because Rockwell didn't credit his references either. Rockwell didn't have to, because the references were his own. Reference photo below of the a U.S. Marshall:
Here is another reference photo, from 1963 for "The Problem We All Live With." The model is Lynda Gunn with her father standing beside her. Note the lunchbox, which isn't in the final painting. artsandculture.google.com/asset/_/AwEEt6…
For those of you who are teaching art online, I have learned a LOT since I started researching/teaching art online 6 years ago. Let me help spare you the months of grief with some best practices that will work at all levels, on any platform...
You will never achieve a perfect translation from IRL to remote teaching. That's basically saying you want to translate a Pablo Neruda poem (written in Spanish) into Japanese, and get precisely the same results and nuances. Instead of mourning what is lost in translation....
...shift your mindset and take what you can get. This might sound depressing at first, and like we are giving up. Of course we want our students to succeed & absorb 100%. But with remote teaching, the potential to lose students ENTIRELY is very high, in a way it is not IRL...
Some personal news: I'm leaving my position at RISD and moving to Utah. I always dreamed about being hired as a full-time, tenured professor but I have been watching my chances evaporate for a while. For the past 16 years, I applied every year to several positions.
On the rare occasion (twice) that I got a first interview, I never made it past the first round. After a while it became clear that my ships were sailing; the people getting the positions much younger, with less experience and an exhibition history that was 1/10 of what I had.
There are initiatives at schools for diversifying faculty, brochures that are passed around campus. I've heard all the arguments that there are simply fewer applicants who are POC, and that it's hard for people on search committees to know who is a POC based on reviewing resumes.