With all due respect, but Hon'ble Judges could have used the power vested upon the HC u/a 226 and granted relief to Arnab.

The order in the case of Maharashtra chess association vs. Union of India (2019) observes as below :

The SC bench of Dr. DY Chandrachud & Indira Bannerjee:
1. Mere existence of alternate remedy does not create a bar on high courts writ jurisdiction.

2.The existence of alternate remedy whether adequate or not does not alter the fundamentally discretionary nature of the High Courts Writ Jurisdiction...
... and therefore does not create an absolute legal bar on the exercise of the Writ jurisdiction by a High Court.

3. The intention behind this self imposed rule is clear.If the HC were to exercise their writ jurisdiction so widely as to regularly override statutory appellate..
...procedures, they would themselves become inundated with a vast number of cases to the detriment of the litigants in those cases.

4.The mere of existence of alternate forum where the aggrieved party may secure relief does not create a legal bar on a HC to exercise it's writ...
... Jurisdiction. It is a factor to be taken into consideration by the High Court amongst several factors.

The above judgement can be inferred in Arnab's case, that, just because section 439 was available as alternate remedy, it hadnt barred the Hon'ble HC from giving the bail.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Adv. Chandni Shah

Adv. Chandni Shah Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @adv_chandnishah

9 Nov
In the case of Gopal Vs. State of Maharashtra, Justice S.S. Shinde (presently one of the hon'ble judge on Arnab Goswami's case) and Justice R.G.Avachat had observed that Mere mention of name in Suicide Note, does not make the named guilty of 'Abetment of Suicide.

Judgement copy:
The hon'ble high court had observed that for abetment to suicide it is necessary that the provisions given u/s 107 of the IPC are met !

#IndiaWithArnab
Allegations which are based on hearsay, should not jeopardize the fundamental and constitutional rights of the accused.

#IndiaWithArnab
Read 5 tweets
5 Nov
Read, Think, Analyse & then choose to react.

1. Anvay Naik commits suicide only because he was not paid his dues (assuming he had a perfect life other wise).

2. The suicide note has his signatures but not his Mother's.Wherein the accusation of abetment is for both suicides.
3. In the Police record it says,Anvay hanged himself & his mother was 'Found' dead.

4. In autopsy both bodies had damaged neck.Anvay's was due to hanging.His mother's death was however not concluded.
#IndiaWithArnab
5. Concorde's total debt was Rs. 19.57 cr & bank OD 10.37 cr in 2016.
The deal with Arnab had no relation with his debts & 90% of dues had already been paid.

6. Mrs.Naik asked ARG ltd to pay outstanding amt to 3rd party which was not binding the contract.

#IndiaWithArnabGoswami
Read 6 tweets
25 Sep
To all #SSRWarriors :

1. Plz dont start cursing the agencies probing the death of Sushant for the delay being caused.

2. The delay has been bcoz of the initial botch up of investigation & evidences.

3. The current investigation is being done on the FIR of abetment of suicide.
4. The drugs chat came into light & hence Narcotics had to enter in the investigation of the drugs.

5. NCB's entry does not mean the other agencies have stopped working.

6. The viscera given to AIIMS was way too less then the required quantity to carry out proper forensics.
7. There has been enough tampering of evidence and thus whatever is left with the agencies will require more time then usual.

8. Circumstantial evidences like pictures of Sushant's body, PM report inconsistency etc point at the murder angle, but the agencies do not have
Read 6 tweets
16 Sep
There is so much need to educate you @sardesairajdeep !

Read the following and may be, MAY BE, you will apologize to feed people with half baked news of your's.

1. On Dec 18, 2019, the Allahabad HC had pulled up the Uttar Pradesh Govt over a shootout at a Bijnor courtroom.
2. 3 assailants had on Dec 17,2019, opened fire in chief judicial magistrate court, Bijnor killing a murder accused. 2 policemen & a court employee injured.

3.UP Bar Council chairperson,Darvesh Yadav, shot dead by a colleague in her chamber on the civil court on June 13, 2019.
4.The Muzaffarnagar court had witnessed a similar incident in 2015 when an armed man entered the courtroom masquerading as a lawyer and shot dead Vicky Tyagi - a gangster.

5.The Allahabad High Court then directed the constitution of a special force.
Read 7 tweets
3 Sep
1. Oleanz Tablet is a prescription medicine used in the treatment of schizophrenia (a mental disorder that can result in hallucinations or delusions and also adversely affects a person's ability to think and behave) and mania.

#SushantTruthNow
#SushantDeathMystery Image
2. Qutipin Tablet is a prescription medicine which is also used in the treatment of schizophrenia & bipolar disorder. Also smtimes used off label for insomnia.

3. Serta Tablet is a type of antidepressant prescribed for depression & panic disorder, OCD, PTSD and causes insomnia. Image
Clonotril is a prescription medicine used to treat epilepsy ( seizures ), panic and anxiety disorder and causes insomnia.

#StopSSRSlander Image
Read 5 tweets
30 Aug
WHY IS BOLLYWOOD & CRICKET WORLD SILENT ON SUSHANT CASE ?

1. Let's evaluate #Cornerstone Sports & Entertainment Pvt. Ltd. It's a Celebrity Management Company.

2. Bunty Sajdeh is the CEO of Cornerstone whose sister Seema Sajdeh/Khan is married to Sohail Khan.

#SushantTruthNow
3. Cornerstone looks after the endorsements & management of the many prominent members of the Indian Cricket Team.

#SushantSinghRajput
#SushantTruthNow
Other than these players Cornerstone also looks after prominent players from the Indian Women's Cricket Team as well as other Sporting Arena in India.

#SushantTruthNow
#ArrestCulpritsOfSSR
Read 8 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!