Thread by @SarahADowney

Many things described as "liberal" today mean the opposite of what was historically true and what many people expect, and this disconnect is likely contributing to some of heightened frustration we're seeing in political arguments in 2020.

1/25

Starting in roughly 2013, "liberal" veered sharply from its roots. You'll hear the word "illiberal" used to describe these contradictions, or "far/alt left," simply "not liberal", or "classic liberal" to differentiate that they're talking about basic enlightenment values.

2/25

What are classic liberal values? en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liberalis… They include civil rights, free speech, free markets, separation of church and state, capitalism, freedom of religion, limited government, and human rights. The US constitution was founded on liberal principles.

3/25

It's possible for moderates and Republicans to be more liberal than Democrats.
Today, people with different values who both identify as liberal are talking past each other. E.g., the phrase "trans women are women." Classic liberal is marked with🏛; new/radical/alt is ☭:

4/25

🏛 Classic liberal: trans women deserve equal rights, protections, and treatment; people should use trans womens' pronouns because it's humane and decent but government shouldn't compel it.

5/25

☭ Far/alt left: trans women are literally biological women and saying otherwise is violence and must be silenced; government should mandate pronoun usage; not using trans womens' pronouns is hate speech.

6/25

Here's a mega-thread of classic liberal ideas compared to radical new ones. Many of the new ones contradict what "liberal" has meant for hundreds of years. This simple comparison isn't perfect - many of these ideas are complex - but it gets to the heart of the shift quickly. 7/25

🏛 Build new things to improve
☭ Dismantle existing things to improve

🏛 No one has the right not to be offended and to always feel comfortable
☭ Everyone has the right not to be offended and to always feel comfortable

8/25

🏛 Ideas exist independently from their creators' identities, behavior, and values
☭ Ideas are inseparable from their creators' identities, behavior, and values

9/25

🏛 No one is immune from criticism
☭ More oppressed people are immune from criticism, especially coming from less oppressed people

🏛 Debate opposing ideas so the strongest ones emerge
☭ Silence opposing ideas because they can threaten people

10/25

🏛 The pinnacle of truth is a heavily-researched and well-supported scientific theory
☭ The pinnacle of truth is one's lived experience

🏛 You are what you do
☭ You are what you say you are

🏛 There is mostly growth in discomfort
☭ There is mostly loss in discomfort

11/25

🏛 Aspire to a colorblind, merit-based society where the best person for a job wins
☭ Aspire to a color-obsessed, merit-blind society where jobs are distributed equally

🏛 Figure out the individual to understand society
☭ Figure out society to understand the individual

12/25

🏛 Argument and challenge can be healthy
☭ Argument and challenge are usually toxic

🏛Focus on the individual, because they make up society
☭ Focus on the collective, because no one exists outside of their identity groups
13/25

🏛 Your positions are private; no one can compel you to share them or interpret meaning from your silence
☭ Your positions are of public concern; others need to know where you stand and your silence can be interpreted as evidence of your beliefs
14/25

🏛 Assume that most successful people worked hard for their outcomes and wealth can be deserved
☭ Assume that most successful people rose up due to privilege and almost always abuse their power

🏛 Actions and intent matter most
☭ Positioning and impact matter most

15/25

🏛 Default to trying to solve problems yourself
☭ Default to enlisting authorities or groups to solve your problems

🏛 Suffering can provide meaning and strength
☭ Suffering usually weakens and should be avoided

16/25

🏛 Prioritize equal opportunities (equality)
☭ Prioritize equal outcomes (equity)

🏛 Feelings are just one data input
☭ Feelings are the most important kind of data input

17/25

🏛 It's morally superior and more productive to focus on what you can control in your own sphere
☭ It's morally superior and more productive to focus on larger societal issues

18/25

🏛 The scientific method helps get us closer to objective truths
☭ The scientific method is just one tool and there are no objective truths

19/25

🏛 In a perfect world, race is irrelevant
☭ In a perfect world, race is center stage and we will have a "reckoning" with it

20/25

🏛 Capitalism is the best system yet discovered for creating wealth and innovation
☭ Capitalism is inherently unfair, reinforces systemic inequalities, and must be dismantled

21/25

🏛 Large groups of people saying the same thing is suspicious and possibly dangerous
☭ Large groups of people saying the same thing is good and possibly ideal

22/25

🏛 Anyone can live how they wish regardless of their background
☭ No one can shed the influence of their background in how they live

23/25

To gain clarity - and have more comprehensible political conversations - assess what someone is saying, versus how they categorize it. That itself is a liberal approach.

24/25

For easier reading, I compiled this list with a few more details in post format in "You keep using the word 'liberal:' it doesn't mean what you think it means," on @Medium ⬇️ medium.com/@sarahadowney/…

25/25