Chris. Father of 3 in Chicago. Couldn't even go outside bc of electronic monitoring. No walks. Errands. Not even the doctor when his son broke his arm. In August, his mom had to go to hospital so he *had* to pick up kids. Arrested. Now jailed. During COVID.themarshallproject.org/2020/11/22/whe…
During COVID, the alternative to jail for disproportionately Black & Brown communities: "Expanded use of home confinement & electronic monitoring, especially for pretrial defendants who have not been convicted & who would not be confined at all if they could afford bail."
"In Chicago, an epicenter of the rise in surveillance, the number of people on electronic monitoring jumped from 2,417 before the pandemic to 3,365 by mid-June and has remained in that range. At one point, the agency ran out of ankle bracelets."
"Because surveillance is seen as more humane than jail, judges are putting more people on it than they ever would have locked up. That trend, which has particularly affected the Black community, has been exacerbated by the pandemic & will only continue after it is over."
"Darryl, 23, said the radius he was required to stay within was just 15 feet. If he so much as took out the trash, the box that was locked onto his ankle would start ringing and flashing red—and he’d be flooded with fear, desperate not to be sent back to jail."
"Electronic monitoring makes it nearly impossible to get & hold onto a job, especially after employers receive a call from law enforcement to approve movement. It pressures people to plead even if they believe they are innocent, just to get their ankle bracelet taken off."
Public Defender Cathryn Crawford: “We had hoped that judges and electronic monitoring officers would for the first time understand how oppressive being confined in your home is—because a lot of them are now going through a version of that themselves."
"For Chris, being on house arrest during the pandemic was like “having double claustrophobia. In a way, being in jail now is a less psychologically confusing experience. “At least here,” he said, “you know that you are not free.”
Electronic monitoring, even more so during the pandemic, is oppressive, unjust, and unnecessary.
Brandon Bernard. Sentenced to death at 18 as an accomplice. Attorneys declined opening statements. Called no witnesses at penalty stage. 11 of 12 jurors were white. 5 of them now don't want death. His prosecutor has called for mercy. Bill Barr wants him executed on Dec. 10. More:
Before this year, no federal execution had taken place since 2003. In July 2020, Barr & Trump resumed federal executions. Since then, they've killed 8 people. Brandon Bernard has now received an execution date. He is currently scheduled to be killed on December 10, 2020.
Brandon was just 18 when he was convicted as an accomplice-did not pull the trigger-in a murder in Texas. Didn't realize that anyone was going to get shot. He was arrested, convicted, & sentenced to death all within 1 year. On death row since 2000. He's almost 40 now.
NYT: “Moral & public health failure.” While many jails saw population drop during first few months, the numbers of people in jails began climbed again over the summer. In 88 counties, jail populations are *higher now* than they were before the pandemic. nytimes.com/2020/11/21/opi…
“More than 196,600 coronavirus infections had been reported among state & federal prisons. More than 1,450 of those died. The case rates among inmates are more than 4x as high as those of the general public, & the death rate is more than twice as high.” Just reported cases.
“The real numbers are assumed to be higher. The virus ripples outward from these hot spots, engulfing the families and communities of inmates and workers. The coronavirus does not respect prison walls any more than it respects state or national borders. It will not be confined.”
Imagine. You’re locked in a confined space w/ dozens. 23 hrs movement restricted. No masks. Forced to share toilet. Either no soap or soap you can’t afford. Many likely have symptoms. Complain: you’re retaliated against. Medical care denied. This is US jails/prisons right now.
Our systems, system actors, prosecutors & judges, & our laws, lawmakers & leaders, across the country have largely done nothing to respond to human suffering inside jails/prisons even in a pandemic. Even in this remarkable time, it is strict adherence to the cruel status quo.
Leaders like @NYGovCuomo, @NYCMayor, & @LoriLightfoot responding w/ urgency to COVID for those outside, choose to ignore human suffering inside jails and prisons where social distancing is impossible, soap and sanitizer is denied, and medical attention is abysmal.
This is Luis Reyes. Caged on Rikers for a year for just a curfew violation. Now charged w/ stealing a package to support his substance use disorder. Suffers from mental health issues. Faces *years* in prison. Cy Vance won't offer treatment instead. More: nydailynews.com/new-york/ny-ma…
Luis Reyes has been in and out of court since he was 16. Suffering from profound mental health issues. Hopelessness. Homelessness. Substances. Horrors. He's saddled w/ a criminal record. He needs help. Not more hurt.
If Luis Reyes were arrested in Brooklyn, it would even be a question that the DA's office would offer him treatment instead of prison. Despite the crime being classified as "violent," it wasn't. Took a package from a lobby. And he already suffered in Rikers.
ATTENTION: In August, New Orleans advocates, communities, & defenders, won for justice. City council mandated public defender funding be commensurate w/ DAs. Now: The Mayor is ignoring it. Proposes no change. In fact, *PD budget is getting slashed.* More: thelensnola.org/2020/10/26/may…
As the Mayor proposed, New Orleans will spend more than $240,000,000 in 2021 to arrest, prosecute and incarcerate its citizens, and just $1,626,442 to protect innocence, fight against wrongful arrest, protect against wrongful convictions, and to hold power accountable.
Despite a massive win in August for budget parity, under the Mayor's plan, the Orleans Public Defenders appropriation went from 85% (proportion of number of people they represent) of the DA to just ONE-THIRD. This is not what ensures a fair, equitable, and just legal system.
If only our leaders listened. In April, four men caged in Miami tried to save Charles Hobbs. Guards ignored them. He died. Today, as COVID again explodes, leaders across the country still ignore those incarcerated. They spoke out then. I hope we listen now:
Follow me: The violence and indifference inside courts and jails, built to silence people, blocked by physical walls of jail/prison, and insulated by the legalese of the daily process in court, is largely invisible even though it’s no less real. Even more so during the pandemic.
Back in April and continuing to today, there was no cell phone footage inside Metro West Detention Facility in Miami where thousands are caged pre-trial. No photos. Loved ones had long been cut off from visiting and phone calls were not happening.