Everyone says they want ‘community’, but do they also want the endless social obligations, 3am crisis calls, constant attention to the trust between two people who aren’t you, hours spent on the phone hearing why one person is mad at another? And this is in a healthy community!
There’s also the agony of having put your faith in a group of people and watching that group crumble or the faith be unearned, the anxiety of new-group formation, the need to protect from people who will poison the well, & the self-doubt about whether you’re doing the right thing
Not saying you shouldn’t, but it feels like ‘community’ often has fantasy air-quotes around it and it’s held up as this angelic god-mother endless love space where you don’t also have actual work to do and sometimes feel threatened and alone.
It’s all part of the deal.
‘Community’ defined by lonely people has no structure, no trade-offs, no pain, and real community has all of those and is still definitely worth it but you need to understand that that’s what you’re getting in for and such tight bonds have their own cost too.
Just like you can’t expect your lover to seem the way they did in the honeymoon period, a real, functioning community has warts and feuds and vices and if you don’t think it will because your envisioned community is special I have news for you buddy
And this is great! Because once you can stop putting mythical god-mother Community on a pedestal you can actually just see her, and hang out with her, and get good at holding your own little community together.
(And maybe stop looking in the wrong places! Maybe you don’t need a new fancy plan thought up by a charismatic white man with lots of land and entirely new social norms etc etc. Maybe you just need a small group of friends who know, over time, that they can rely on each other.)
Oh yeah, and the fucking bureaucracy. Don’t get me started on the bureaucracy.
I open Twitter. And I scroll. Maybe I’m hoping there will be something I find that starts thinking itself into my head, but my head is not really thought-y and it thinks all thoughts are wrong
I watch people I know in real life and people whose voices are just made up sounds in my head whose first names I’ve never heard squawk joyously and frustratedly and parade sex and triumph and pride all over the timeline
And I feel...not that? Not that any of it is bad, but I’m not there. I’m quiet, soft, internal—even the elderly Buddhists in my meditation book club zoom seem to be speaking too loud.
I’ve run dozens of deep reading club sessions by now, and I’m kind of obsessed with the format. It’s doing something new and wonderful in a subtle way I want to try and explain.
Why deep reading clubs are fucking rad, a thread:
How a deep reading club works:
Someone chooses a book & invites a group to read it. You read together, aloud, taking the time it takes to read & absorb the text. You annotate the text together, then your annotations become the catalysts for whatever conversation comes next.
I run these using a hacky combo of Zoom and Google Docs. They are the kind of social activity that is actually a good fit for Zoom because you do naturally read a book while sitting still, so it doesn’t feel unnatural like a zoom party.
I live in a 12-person community house in SF. We bought extra food and supplies a few weeks ago, made a written quarantine plan about two weeks ago, and pulled the trigger on our first level of quarantine last week.
Most of us are lucky we can work from home; another handful work without being around other people, and one helped persuade her work (with lots of kids) to cancel events and end the semester early.
We have been going outside but not to events, restaurants or being around other people. I went grocery shopping today and used gloves. We put a hygiene station at the door where people can sanitize their hands and wipe down their phones upon entry. We bought a LOT more soap.
I'm at my parents' place, 1hr south of Sydney, Australia.
Bushfires have hit coastal communities (swollen with holiday tourists) a few hrs south of us - thousands of people trapped on beaches or on boats by fires, in areas where all the roads are now blocked off.
People have been directed to leave where possible, but there are several issues. Firstly, driving is hard:
- There is no power, limiting gas stations' ability to offer fuel
- Gas stations are running out of fuel
- Even roads that are open have terrible visibility bc smoke
Second, supplies are running low:
- Drinking water is getting contaminated with ash
- People evacuated to the beach or ocean quickly, with limited food and water supplies
- Supermarkets have no power, and can't get supplies because of blocked roads, so their inventory is limited
1. (Oh god so many likes already)
A lot of emotional processing is secretly a process of having your emotional experience witnessed by another. Witnessing is a pretty core kind of care.
2. The feeling of ‘being seen’ is so core to the feeling of being loved, that it might actually be that the majority of what it is to love someone is simply to reflect them back to themselves.