This is a thread about how utterly in love with Penelope Scott's song Rät I am. It's a breakup song to Silicon Valley and Elon Musk in particular. It is 🔥🔥🔥 on the promise, failure, and disappointment of technology. Some of my favorite lyrics:
/ God damn, I fell for you, your flamethrowers, your tunnels, and your tech
/ I studied code because I wanted to do something great like you
/ And the real tragedy is half of it was true
(This is the problem with the promise of tech, right? There IS promise. So much to fall for in that expectation for tech to be for the public good, but then... it's possible that the potential is the part that's true and the execution is the part that's not.)
/ I bit the apple 'cause I trusted you, it tastes like Thomas Malthus
/ Your proposal is immodest and insane
/ And I hope someday Selmers rides her fuckin' train
(These references are so brilliant I'll just quote the Genius annotation rather than try to unpack it myself.)
/ I loved you, I loved you, I loved you, it's true
/ I wanted to be you and do what you do
/ I lived here, I loved here, I thought it was true
/ I feel so stupid, and so used
(Raise your hand if you've worked in tech and have felt this.)
/ Well I don't want to eat the rich, I'd have to eat my heroes first
/ And my tuition's paid by blood, I might deserve your fate or worse
/ Let me level with you, man, as someone guilty of the game
/ I took the help, I took the cash, I would've taken your last name
(Or this. 🙌)
/ When I said take me to the moon, I never meant take me alone
/ I thought if mankind toured the sky, it meant that all of us could go
/ But I don't want to see the stars if they're just one more piece of land
/ For us to colonize, for us to turn to sand
(What if the promise of technology is only for the privileged? Sure, it's great... if you're rich enough to pay to go to the moon. And if you're not the one being colonized.)
Anyway thanks to TikTok to bringing this song to my attention, here's Penelope. tiktok.com/@worsethanithot
And Penelope if you want to get a PhD let me know because this song is a dissertation I wish I'd advised.
Also while we're on the topic of tech breakup songs, a decade ago Molly Lewis wrote a breakup song to Wikipedia.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Not that I was *surprised* to see this study about predicting "political orientation," but since I've been talking about the "gaydar" (sigh) algorithm from the same researcher for a while now, here's some reflection. nature.com/articles/s4159…
Given criticism of the previous paper (which if you're not familiar is here: psyarxiv.com/hv28a/ ) I was genuinely expecting to see an ethical considerations section by the end of this paper (since that criticism pretty much constructed it exactly!). There is not one.
There is a lengthy "author notes" document linked to from the article that includes FAQs (like "physiognomy????") and twice warns to not "shoot the messenger" so I guess that's the ethics statement.
Hm. I wonder what happens when a community moves off a platform because accounts are getting banned for reasons that conflict with the values of that community?
Or: I'm not saying Trump supporters have a lot in common with fanfiction writers, but remember LiveJournal? [Thread]
In 2007, LiveJournal suspended a bunch of accounts in an attempt to remove certain kinds of objectionable content, and this ended up sweeping up a lot of fanfiction and fan art accounts/communities. People were Not Happy. fanlore.org/wiki/Strikethr…
This policy change by LiveJournal was directly (if of course only partially) responsible for the conceptualization and creation of Archive of Our Own. And the rallying cry was: own the servers!!! cmci.colorado.edu/~cafi5706/CHI2…
A thread on filter bubbles, confirmation bias, design against misinformation, and social media content policy. Or: how can people really think that the U.S. election was rigged, and is it social media's fault. 🧵
If you are reading this tweet, it is possible that you literally don't know a single person who voted for Donald Trump. Meanwhile, I know a couple of people who likely literally don't know a single person who DIDN'T vote for Donald Trump, besides me.
It's not like this is new - 30 years ago the same might be true just because all your friends live in your local community - but the internet makes us FEEL like we KNOW so many more people, and that we have a broader view of the world.
In a few hours (evening for me, morning in India!) I'm giving a keynote for the COMPUTE conference on integrating ethics into computer science education. Including some links in this thread to papers and other things I will reference in that talk! Perfect for #CSEdWeek2020. :)
First: Why integrate ethics into technical CS classes? It's one way to change the culture towards recognizing that ethics is an integral part of the practice of computing, and not a specialization. howwegettonext.com/what-our-tech-…
Someone on TikTok asked if I could recommend books about tech ethics and I have never been so hyped to create a piece of content in my life. vm.tiktok.com/ZMJV3WPj8/
Obviously this list had to be visual so if there are obvious omissions it's probably because my copy of the book is trapped in my office I haven't been to since April or I've loaned it to one of my students. :)
Update on the bonkers omegaverse copyright lawsuit- a bogus DMCA claim for @thelindsayellis's video about bogus DMCA claims. AMAZING EXAMPLE of a complete misunderstanding of fair use. Let's talk about bad faith takedowns & what fair use protects! [Thread]
To briefly summarize the topic of Lindsay's original video:
Author sends DMCA takedowns for another author's books based on a claim of copyright infringement for worldbuilding concepts that originally came out of fanfiction. Gets more bonkers from there.
Following Lindsay's video, she immediately heard from Author's lawyer, with claims of copyright infringement and defamation. re: copyright infringement, the video includes about 400 words of Author's book. (Heavily bleeped since, you know... it's werewolf erotica.)