Almost any elite Indian's dream of a "developed" India will have Nordic type infrastructure and safety and low crime. But still daily domestic help that is paid in Indian wage terms, cheap autos and cabs, cheap food delivery etc.
And therein lies the disconnect between the urban elites (especially Modi lovers) and the protesting farmers. They seem almost outraged that these farmers look better off than the emaciated ones in old newsreels, but are still protesting. Bhakts consider them "uppity".
The subtext of the lofty sounding "Jai jawaan, jai kisaan" is that it is the duty of soldiers and farmers to be overworked and underpaid. And now that farmers don't look emaciated, they are suddenly thought of as fat cats. By people sitting in westernized apartment complexes.
One of the most honest things I've heard is when a friend decided to move back to India after almost a decade in the UK. She said the main reason was "I'm doing well financially but I'm unlikely to ever do well enough to hire daily drivers, maids, cooks, AND nannies in UK."
You can do the exact same white collar job in the West or in India, and your life will be identical in terms of your house, car, phone, gadgets, eating out, etc. But in India, you also get a whole army of cheap labor that relies on keeping the masses too poor to demand more.
Not a single leader, not even the most fiery communist, has communicated this fundamental disconnect between the two Indian dreams. That India's "development" will make the lives of its elites less comfortable than they currently are. Stop taking cheap labor for granted.
On my last Pune visit, a friend's mom waxed nostalgic about how in the 80s, you could afford bai, driver, aaya even on a "bank job" salary, but "nowadays some of these people earn almost as much as a bank clerk 😤". She said this sitting in a home 5x their 80s home.
"Foreign mein kya mast dignity of labour hai" in the streets.
"Yeh delivery log ka lift alag hai, watchman" in the sheets.
Relevant bizarre thing I heard on last India visit. We were talking salary caps in sports league and how rich IPL teams are known to circumvent them by giving in-demand players something extra "off the books". And a friend said "like our maid and nanny!"
I'm like, err, what?
This friend, after moving into a new rental place, hired a maid and a nanny at whatever rate they asked. And later, gave them whatever raises they asked. A couple of years later, she and her husband were told by the landlord that the residents association were upset at this.
And some upper limits for domestic help salaries were placed after heated battles on their building whatsapp group. So the maid and nanny are told to pretend that they are being paid as much as others. But she pays them more "on the side".

How to even... 🤷🏽‍♂️
Whatsapp has really weaponized the worst aspects of Resident/Tenant Associations in India, huh? The stuff I've seen and heard in recent years is just batshit.
The idea that anyone except a sports league commissioner can justifiably say "it is against the rules to pay this much of your own money to people you hire" can only make sense in indian society.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Gaurav Sabnis 🇮🇳🇺🇸

Gaurav Sabnis 🇮🇳🇺🇸 Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @gauravsabnis

13 Dec
TIL that Bhakt whatsapp, usually busy researching archaic islamic theology, has taken a break to research Canada's agriculture laws. 😂
To attack Trudeau 😂
Never mind that Trudeau didn't criticize the laws. Just the treatment of protesters.

Modi voters are so default dishonest!
Vajpayee was no saint, but he got regularly criticized and lampooned and even officially internationally sanctioned. Not once was there "HOW DARE YOU?" pushback from his people. Shekhar Suman rebooted his career by lampooning Vajpayee.

Modi is so thin-skinned and insecure!
Hearing more about it, this isn't something to "😂" at but rather "😳". This is some well thought out sophistry from the bhakt-lite camp. The logic is, Canada has laws similar to what BJP passed. So Trudeau is out of line. Again, he only talked about protests. But let's see...
Read 4 tweets
10 Dec
A very underrated and underknown figure. Centuries ahead of his time. And he got exactly the kind of pushback that Defund Police activists do today. To temper his "radical" positions towards the center. But without him, the center would have been considered radical.
This is a point I've been trying to make since the election to well meaning liberals who are going after the progressive wing and especially the squad, saying defund or GND or M4A are unrealistic pipe dreams. They might end up being. But those positions are ideological anchors.
Many like Lincoln himself (who until the war was kinda centrist if not conservative on race by today's standards) lectured Garrison, saying dude, be realistic. But he stuck to his positions and advocacy. And the center slowly moved towards him.
Read 8 tweets
9 Dec
Oh wow, this is huge! This is a bipartisan challenge to Facebook, if it involves the federal government AND 48 states. No republican democrat differentiation here. This is the United States declaring war on Facebook!
It'll take a while for everyone to realize what a huge deal this is. Like earth shattering historic huge. In these ultra polarized times when the 2 parties can't even agree on an election outcome, they are united in wanting to dismantle Facebook!

Anti-trust actions in the past against IBM, Microsoft etc haven't really gone anywhere. Mostly because by the time the lawsuits played out, the companies had stopped being monopolies, so prosecutors lost interest.

But this Facebook suit is WAY more all encompassing!
Read 7 tweets
9 Dec
मी संयुक्त बहुग्रहीक संघराज्याच्या अंतरिक्ष यान उ. स. स. एंटरप्राइझ चा कर्णधार झीन-लुच पिकॉर्ड बोलत आहे!
अरे जिम्या, मेलाय हा! @11ty1
ती लक्ष्मणरेखा इथेच ओढली पाहिजे! फक्त इथपर्यन्त! त्यपुढे एक तिसु देखील नाही! 😠😠😠😠
Read 4 tweets
9 Dec
This chapter in the Obama book kinda depressed me. Because it reminded me that on carbon emissions, US and China are in a kind of a Nash Equilibrium in not changing their respective positions. They can each justifiably blame the other to their domestic audiences. Image
When this happened, Democrats had 60 seats in the senate. But climate change has gotten so politicized in America that Obama couldn't even think of convincing 7 Republican senators to go along and ratify a binding climate treaty. That was our last dance. Under pressure.
It didn't used to be like this. Nixon set up the EPA and passed the Clear Air and Water Acts. Until then, US skies were as smoggy and heavy as Indian and Chinese cities.
Remember acid rain? Bush Sr was the one who changed policies to make it a distant memory. Republicans both.
Read 5 tweets
9 Dec
This city I tell you! 😍😍😍🗽
Also, if a humpback whale has randomly surfaced, we can assume that the USS Enterprise NCC-1701 is hidden somewhere in orbit. #StarTrekIV #VoyageHome
Which is the cutest most fun Star Trek movie of all time and why is it #StarTrekIV? Wrath of Khan is best overall obviously. But when it comes to funny, cute moments, especially with the cast so visibly old. Time travel and whales and general goofiness. Nimoy as director.
Read 11 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!