1/ Sorry 2b late - I was out owning this opera’s villainess Ortrud by going to an evening Mass. So we’ve got LOHENGRIN: mid-career Wagner, his last opera b4 embarking in THE RING. It’s a clash of Christian and pagan forces in early 10thc Duchy of Brabant. Elsa von Brabant
2/ is accused of killing her brother, Godfrey, the rightful Duke. She asks God to send her dream-knight to defend her - and He does! What’s more, they can get married if only she’ll refrain, forever, from asking his name or origin. This is a tall order, but Elsa promises it
3/ willingly, and it’s reason has to do with the inscrutable rules of the Grail, which this knight serves: if they become known, they must return. This condition provided the perfect entry point for Ortrud to play on Elsa’s doubts. Ortrud is a proud descendant of Radbod, the
4/ pagan prince of Frisia who once ruled these parts, and she knows how to do stuff like turn Duke Godfrey into a swan - which she did, and that, not any wrongdoing by innocent Elsa, is why he disappeared! However she does not sense any incipient plot-twist in the fact that
5/ Elsa’s knight, Lohengrin, was transported to Brabant on a boat pulled by - a swan! A fourth major character is the proud and renowned knight Frederick of Telramund, who was supposed to marry Elsa, but met up with Ortrud, married her, and to his cost bought her tale about
6/ Elsa having killed Godfrey. He’s dishonored by losing the duel to Lohengrin, but later when he reproaches Ortrud, she tells him it was rigged, I’m sorry, that it was sorcery, and he shd just recommit himself to her neo-Radbodian counter-revolution.
7/ Our Lohengrin is matinée idol heldentenor Peter Hoffmann. Elsa is Eva Marton, who had sung Ortrud the previous season and is a little the worse for wear for it. Ortrud is Leonie Rysanek, veteran of many but not all Wagner soprano roles: not Brünnhilde or Isolde but definitely
8/ Sieglinde, Senta, and to a lesser extent, Elsa. Got a story. Leonie once sang Elsa with my great friend and “aunt” Nell Rankin as Ortrud. Afterwards Leonie told her, “If I sing in this opera again I want to do *your* role, and just like you, I’m going to wear a red wig!”
9/ Divas don’t get to pick their own costume accoutrements any more, but Nell was old school, and well, here’s Leonie as Ortrud, and dammit she’s got a red wig! Appropriate - the “Celtic woman” look.
10/ Ortrud is a role that we call “zwischenfach,” or, in between vocal categories. It goes high, and Wagner seems to have wanted a soprano, albeit a more “dramatic” one than the more lyrical Elsa. In time great dramatic mezzo-sopranos did it with great success: Kerstin Thorborg,
11/ Nell Rankin (aforementioned), Christa Ludwig, and Mignon Dunn, who was in this production’s debut season. It’s opinionable whether Rysanek’s Ortrud counts as a soprano in the role or as a soprano switching to mezzo roles towards the end of her career.
12/ The production is the beautifully realistic one designed by the recently-departed Ming Cho Lee - very much *early* medieval, not highly-colored late - that debuted in 1976 and replaced Wieland Wagners’s colorful but static “stained glass” vision from 1966.
13/ In 1998, Everding/Lee (this one) was replaced by one by Robert Wilson that - well, motionless? It made Wieland’s approach look like St. Audrey’s fair by comparison. It was aptly called a Kabuki production. Well, I saw it in the house (as I had the two previous prodns), and
14/ It had its moments. Well, it’s been ash-heaped, and yet another prodn is in the works. Director is chosen, but I don’t remember who or know what path he plans to take it. We’d have it now if it hadn’t been for COVID. As it is, it’s not in the planned 2021-22 season.
15/ So, maybe in fall ‘22? And maybe it won’t suck? Doubt it’ll be as good as what you see on the Met’s site tonight/tomorrow.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with David M. Wagner

David M. Wagner Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @david_m_wagner

19 Dec
1/ They say NABUCCO was Verdi's breakout work. It was certainly the work with which he elevated the baritone from lyric to dramatic and from co-star to star. Only this time we have a late-career tenor in the part, returning to his long-ago baritone Fach. ("Fach" is German for
2/ "operatic vocal category," and all the jokes have been made so don't even try.) The title character is of course Nebuchadnezzar, so to those who've just been watching A Charlie Brown Christmas: "Sort of makes you want to treat me with more respect, doesn't it!" But this is an
3/ extra-Biblical tale of how Nebbie, having conquered Jerusalem, proclaimed himself God - and got a mentally disorienting zap for it. But gradually he recovers his wits and, against the odds, defeats the machinations of his power-hungry step-daughter Abigaille, saves the lives
Read 8 tweets
19 Dec
@HumphreyBohun Tbqh I cannot easily tell - at least by the supposedly most salient differences, orchestration and harmony- which one I’m hearing. My test is a line early in the Coronation Scene fanfares: the trumpets’ line goes *down* in “original,” *up* in Rimsky. But unless I hear
@HumphreyBohun representative snippets side-by-side, taste-test style, I’m not rly sure. And I put quotes around “original” bc - has anyone *really* ever heard it? In 1974 the Met made a big covfefe out of how they were at last using Mussorgsky’s original harmonies and orchestration. But
@HumphreyBohun after Maestro Thomas Schippers’s death, his BORIS score was found, and lo, he had made numerous changes in the rehearsal process. The 2010 new production (tonight’s version) has a musicologist it relies on, as the 1955 English-language production relied on Karol Rathaus.
Read 5 tweets
18 Dec
BORIS is on my desert-island list along with FRANCESCA. National epic, imperial whodunnit, Dostoevskian psychodrama, & soul-examination of Russian ppl - traumatized when the first non-Rurikid ruler took the throne and he may, *may*, have killed a Rurikid heir to do so.
2/ Along with same composer’s KHOVANSHCHINA and Borodin’s PRINCE IGOR, this is Russia’s operatic epic. Co-starring the People alongside the title character, it starts w the People, moves to Boris, then back to the People thru a monk-chronicler who, doing what’s possible with
3/ what’s available, gives the People their national story; then in to the unscrupulous rise of the Pretender - Самосванец, self-named - then back to Boris, to whom the Pretender’s choice of an identity is a goad to conscience and madness. Then over to Poland where the Pretender
Read 7 tweets
17 Dec
1/ Just re-upped my thread from when this was last shown. Not a lot to add. When ppl ask me "What's your favorite opera," this is my answer, bc, a., ppl with so little understanding of opera-fandom deserve to be stuck with an answer they almost certainly don't recognize, but b.
2/ bc it wd certainly make my top-ten list (and that's what opera fans do: "desert island" lists). I wish I understood how FRANCESCA happened: I guess, the right conjunction of composer, librettist (D'Annunzio!), period (medieval setting, composed in florescence of late
3/ romanticism), and nation (both native and expatriate literature in Italy were experiencing troubadour-fever in 1st 2 decades of 20thc). There are other Zandonai works, and collaborations by D'Annunzio w other composers, that deserve revival; but somehow their combination
Read 8 tweets
17 Dec
1/ Berlioz determined to set Books II-IV of The Aeneid. Book II becomes Acts 1&2 (La Prise de Troie) and Bks III & IV become Acts 3-5 (Les Troyens à Carthage). Together they are LES TROYENS. The gargantuan-ness of it provokes comparison to Wagner, esp. his GÖTTERDÄMMERUNG,
2/ which we will see later this week Thus equals in mammothosity, Berlioz may compete w Wagner on getting there first and win (1858), or on music and dramaturgy, and IMO *not* win. I’ve tried w Berlioz since I first listened to his DAMNATION DE FAUST a *long* time ago
3/ and i still don’t get what’s out of the ordinary about it, and the dramatic pace in TROYENS is, IMO, glacial. Maybe epic poetry doesn’t translate well to the stage: while there have been great plays and operas based on stories within Homer, and within Dante (yo, FRANCESCA DA
Read 6 tweets
15 Dec
1/ “Epics” - in opera context this means anything with a mythical, ancient, or medieval setting. SAMSON is ancient. Saint-Saëns began it as an oratorio, which accounts for some of the odd dramaturgy in 1st half of Act 1: can the disconsolate crowd of Hebrews, barely roused
2/ by Samson’s stirring rhetoric, rly bump off Abimelech *and* ravage the Philistines’ fields in the time allotted to this in the score? With the High Priest arriving on the scene immediately? It grew more operatic as the composer went on, and it became a pinnacle of 19thc
3/ French opera. Samson’s mix if leadership and weakness, Delilah’s hate-filled but sensuous manipulation, and the cruelty and blasphemy of the High Priest of Dagon, are all made compelling in the music.
Read 10 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!