Sane people must learn and never forget that the stupidity of the far right is much less important than its dangerousness.

The more deluded people become, the more they will justify to promote their beliefs.
In fact, the constant stream of absurdities constantly spewed from Trump's mouth and Twitter fingers is actually what binds many of his supporters to him.
Trump doesn't personally care about religion but he knows that fundamentalists are mocked for their beliefs. All he has to do is wrap himself into the mythology and then his stupidities become their doctrine.
Thus to some extent, pointing out how wrong Trump is about things actually makes his true followers believe in him more.

His persecution is theirs. The worse he becomes, the better he becomes to them. As @roddreher noted, the mentality is almost "by his tweets we are healed."
Steve Bannon famously called Trump's approach "flooding the zone with shit." It's a media strategy that has flummoxed mainstream journalists.

There are too many lies to cover and putting fact-checkers front-and-center has strengthened Trump's persecution narrative.
This is why many MAGA fans are unreachable by factual narratives. They believe their personal and faith identities are bound up in the person of Trump.

Not only could they lose their community for "betraying" the orange god, their intellects are surrounded by a hermetic seal.
For MAGAs so entirely bought into the delusion, it's best to try to pierce the seal via conversations about non-political topics. Promote films discussing critical thinking or compassion to them rather than tell them anything about Trump. Their minds cannot handle more.
If you can get them to separate their identity from their politics, this is how change can happen. If you're going to ask a political question, ask "wouldn't you want to know if Trump is wrong?"

How they respond will help you calibrate your approach.
The mainstream press can do several things: 1) Avoid ever conflating Trump's actions with GOP voters. 2) Listen to and promote people who are post-faith or of moderate faiths. 3) Only book conservatives who are independent of Trump. 4) Avoid stating Trump's claims to refute them.
Fact checking is best done by dedicated organizations and not by general-interest media that also has to report the news. We need fact-checking desperately, but often refuting myths actually spreads them. No more live Trump press conferences.
Similarly, humor can be an effective weapon against authoritarians but it can also be used to normalize them and to instill apathy about their actions.

Far too many people focus so much on Trump's stupidity that they cannot see his malevolence.
Not to single him out in particular, but if you look at the "Daily Show" as hosted by Jon Stewart, you'll see this incorrect approach animated his entire program. His flippant mocking inured progressives and centrists to the danger that was growing among conservatives.
Trump must indeed be mocked by comedians but his insanity and insidiousness should always be kept in the forefront by his opponents /end

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Matthew Sheffield

Matthew Sheffield Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @mattsheffield

24 Dec
Trump's veto of the GOP-backed defense and COVID relief bills seems at first to be a mere temper tantrum. It is that in part, but it's primary Trump's warning shot against Republican elites to do everything he says or face complete destruction. 1/x
While GOP elites kiss up to Trump in public they actually ridicule & despise him in private. They hate Trump & want to be rid of him, but they couldn't do it for fear of alienating his voters.

Trump vetoing defense & COVID relief bills is a warning about his "Samson option."
Named after the Bible character, a Samson option refers to a country's ability to utterly destroy a hostile foreign power in the event of its own annihilation. It typically refers to Israel's long-rumored nuclear weapons and willingness to use them.
Read 14 tweets
21 Dec
As I've said before, the best way to counter large-scale far right lies is in the legal system. You can't libel people and expect no consequences. Nice to see Smartmatic getting results.

Fox News is also being forced to air retracting segments, too:

mediaite.com/tv/jeanine-pir…
This bar complaint against Sidney Powell and the other attorneys who brought a frivolous Arizona election lawsuit is also an important example of seeking accountability in the legal arena: 12news.com/article/news/p…
Powell and her allies are facing a similar bar complaint in Michigan. We need many more such sanction efforts against her and attorneys who slander in news conferences while saying different things in court. forbes.com/sites/jemimamc…
Read 4 tweets
21 Dec
Most conservative media outlets are much more biased than any source they deem to be "liberal."

So often, the articles fail to mention basic facts that might upset readers. It's partly why base conservatives get triggered by facts.

I'll update this thread periodically.
Here's Townhall talking about a desperate Trump lawsuit trying to throw out PA's Electoral College votes that have already been certified.

It leaves out the two huge losses SCOTUS has already dished out to Trump allies, one of which concerned PA: townhall.com/tipsheet/bethb…
Dishonest and incompetent articles like this that refuse to admit the truth is why Trump followers still think he has a chance.

The article also fails to mention that even if Trump miraculously won vs PA, Biden would still be president since he won so many other states.
Read 5 tweets
20 Dec
Thread: People love to rag on Nate Silver for his arrogance & they should, but he's merely an example of a larger issue that the web has made it easy to draw inferences from data without knowing the context in which it lives. 1/x
Alexander Pope's warning that "a little learning is a dangerous thing" has never been more true than an age in which we can obtain information about anything without being able to understand it.

Having data doesn't mean you can use it.
Western society has a very significant problem that expertise in one area is often conflated with expertise in others.

Men are the main culprit. We have been socialized to think we know more than we do. There are many studies showing this. Here's one: journals.physiology.org/doi/full/10.11…
Read 15 tweets
17 Dec
I don't think there is any one phrase that so adequately summarizes the global moment we're living in than this one attributed to David Hume, the Scottish philosopher who died in 1776:

"Mistakes in philosophy are merely ridiculous, those in religion are dangerous."
I haven't been able to find which work of Hume's the phrase is from so if you know of it, please chime in. But let's talk a bit about what the phrase means and why it's so important.
The word "mistake" here is not explicitly a reference to any person or group's particular dogma but rather to how society acts upon religious or moral concepts.

Humans individually and collectively are fallible so thus the biggest error is fundamentalism.
Read 23 tweets
13 Dec
The most fascinating figure from the God-Trump "Jericho March" was its emcee, Chrystal Christian radio host Eric Metaxas.

He started off hosting "Socrates in the City" pop philosophy discussions in NYC but his insatiable desire for fame took him to hosting Alex Jones. 1/x
It's a terrible story but, sadly, it's one that is extremely typical of aspiring conservative media figures.

People who try to bring nuance and to mix it up with religion skeptics always get stymied.
Because there is no center-right power in America, only far-right, this means that if you want to have a media career as a reasonable conservative, you must somehow win the NYT or WaPo lottery or labor in relative obscurity, regardless of your talent or achievements.
Read 15 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!