1/ Plots from our Healthy High School PRIDE (Partnership in Research on Indoor Environments) project, a 4-yr USEPA funded study and intense analysis of 46 high school classrooms in Central Texas.
2/ Plot A shows air exchange rate in permanent and portable classrooms in the unoccupied setting (end of school day to start of next school day). The x is mean value and central line on bars is median. Variation shown via percentiles and min/max.
3/ The mechanical systems were off in plot A. All ventilation was via infiltration. Note much lower values and spread for permanent classrooms. Portable classrooms are connected directly to outdoors, leakier, and prone to greater ventilation by infiltration.
4/ Plot B shows air exchange rates for classrooms during the occupied school day. The red line shows approximate ventilation rate based on ASHRAE 62.1-2019 for a majority of classrooms.
5/ Note severely under-ventilated permanent classrooms (primarily for energy savings) in both seasons. Portable classrooms had a central tendency of much higher ventilation, but with significantly greater variation than permanent classrooms.
6/ Portable classrooms, highly criticized for poor environmental conditions in past research, do provide greater opportunities for natural ventilation via open windows, open doors to outside, etc., as well as filtration. Problem = greater students/ft2 (in our study).
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
1/ More results (year 1) of our Healthy High School PRIDE study. Here we show a cumulative distribution plot of average rebreathed fraction (RF) of air in classrooms during the occupied day. RF is actually converted to a percentage on the vertical axis.
2/ Note that a rebreathed fraction of 0.03 (3%), for example, means that 3% of every inhaled breath originated from the collective respiratory systems of others in the indoor space (including anyone infected with COVID-19).
3/ In my recent USEPA webinar on layered risk reduction strategies for schools I argued for a maximum RF < 0.008 (0.8%) for classrooms during this pandemic. That translates to an average CO2 concentration of less than 700 ppm.
1/ @CDCgov has bought into layered inhalation dose, and therefore risk, reduction strategies. Pleased by this recognition, but not ready to shower the agency with adulation. The agency's credibility has taken a hit. I want to see a sustained effort of focus & doing right.
2/ My life has been about looking forward. But it is difficult not to reflect on where we would have been today had recognition of inhalation of virus-laden aerosol particles in both the near and far fields been recognized by @CDC 10 months ago.
3/ Future planning for the next pandemic or continued battle with SARS-CoV-2 must rely on continued innovation, but also on a deep forensics analysis of all of the failures (on so many fronts - not just @CDC) that fueled an inferno of infection in the US & elsewhere.
1/ It is difficult, and especially if you want more than total VOCs (TVOC) using a photoionization detector with factor of three accuracy (that tells you nothing about actual chemicals). more ...
2/ In flight to Beijing for Indoor Air 2005, a large number of academics from the US brought onboard small passive ozone samplers and taped to backs of seats. These were collected and shipped back to the US for analysis. The same could be done w/ passive samplers for VOCs.
3/ What you gain from this approach is speciation of VOCs. What you lose is temporal variation, e.g., peak concentrations when high levels of hydrocarbons are emitted when an engine is first activated & during take-off.
Over 100,000 Americans currently in hospitals with COVID-19 and over 210,000 new cases today. We are converging on and will soon surpass the 9/11 death toll EVERY SINGLE DAY. And we are going to see a huge surge in the next several weeks & months.
2/ Hospital infrastructure is strained. Morgues have overflown. Front line health care workers are physically and mentally exhausted. This is a tragedy inside of a catastrophe.
3/ Despite all of this, too many people refuse to do what is needed to starve this virus of its hosts. Too many are too accepting of the death and devastation. Too many are fueling an inferno of infectiousness. It's all been said before, but ....
1/ I was asked in an interview today about the history of Indoor Air Quality. I surprised the journalist by starting about 1 million years ago with controlled fires brought into caves.
2/ There is evidence of early recognition of the importance of local exhaust, with fires placed below shafts to the outdoors. How many died from carboxyhemoglobin poisoning before recognition of the importance of ventilation?
3/ Perhaps we can ask the same question today but replace carboxyhemoglobin with COVID-19 and fire in caves with SARS-CoV-2 in (pick your favorite crowded and poorly ventilated indoor space).
Perhaps it is time we learn something from Homo erectus.
2/ The air pollution that we breathe during our lifetime, even pollution of outdoor origin, is dominated by the air we breathe INDOORS.
3/ We can dramatically reduce our exposure to air pollution by reducing emissions from indoor sources, removing pollutants of indoor origin (ventilation & good engineering controls), & designing/operating buildings to reduce outdoor pollution from penetrating indoors.