Anjanette Young. A 20 year social worker. Just back from work. Police invaded her home. Naked. Begged for clothes. Cuffed. 40 minutes of terror. Apologized & left. Then tried to cover it up. Defender: "What happened that night is the norm in Chicago." More:nbcnews.com/think/opinion/…
"Chicago police & city officials fought to suppress the truth of what happened that night. They almost succeeded. Now, Chicago Mayor Lori Lightfoot is calling for accountability. But would she have done so if her legal team or police had been successful in burying the facts?"
"We also must acknowledge how Young’s innocence & class are connected to her believability as a victim. Change one of these factors-if they had the right house, if she was not a professional, if she was using or dealing drugs-& maybe we would all be less concerned about her."
If Anjanette Young were, in fact, "guilty," or a less "sympathetic" victim of police abuse, "her experience would be consistent w/ the logic that assumes Black women should be treated w/ suspicion. And, most likely her experience would never be made known to the general public."
The normal course: "Victims & accused are dehumanized,. Many are moved through the system in complete silence. The state decides how their stories are told & what forms of accountability are just. Neither the victims nor the accused are centered in any processes of healing."
Ida B. Wells, one of Chicago's most best known and moat beloved civil rights leaders, once said, "The right way to right wrongs is to turn the light of truth upon them." But what happens when we continue to suppress truth?nypl.org/blog/2018/07/1…
"Astoundingly, this cover-up has occurred under a mayor, a County Board president and a state’s attorney who are all Black women, a fact that shows us just how systematic and prevalent these issues are."
"Not shockingly, government officials are now pointing fingers at one another. With the resignation this weekend of corporation counsel for Chicago, the search for the proverbial bad apple continues. All the while, reform efforts continue to ignore calls for systematic change."
"Among restorative justice advocates the symbolism of the mythical Sankofa bird is well known. It can’t move forward w/o being able to account for the past. As we look back in order to move forward, we must center the history of decades of police violence."berea.edu/cgwc/the-power…
"Rather than relying exclusively on the police to keep Chicago safe, we need to stop over-funding police departments at the expense of other vital functions. This also means redistributing dollars to invest in local grassroots, nonpolice orgs to respond to emergency calls."
"The outrage over Young’s home invasion & the subsequent cover-up is well placed & cant be met w/ simple reform fixes. Her story & the stories of countless others before her-both known & unknown-must point us toward a future that does more than empty promises made about “reform.”
This powerful piece was written by Emmanuel Andre. Public defender and restorative justice practitioner at Northside Transformative Law Center in Chicago.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Unexpected catharsis this weekend. Looking for at home activities for family, came across a present for my 5 year old. Origami Dinosaurs. Way too advanced for him. Too advanced for me, frankly. But found it super relaxing & as a totally non-crafty person, pretty proud of my work!
A man was on probation in Florida. On a single night, got home 26 minutes past curfew. His punishment: 201 months in prison! That's *16 years* in prison! On Dec. 2, a Florida appeals court *affirmed* this outrageous sentence. Why is this not news? Opinion: 2dca.org/content/downlo…
I learned about this case from criminal defense attorneys in Florida. @adamtebrugge & @floridalawwoman. This is not unusual. Unfortunately. Including the fact that it's so non unusual that no one even wrote about it.
Very important note: This isn't just about the cruelty of judges. This is probation officers, who decided to arrest & violate this man & push this cruelty. It's prosecutors who supported this cruelty. It's the probation system: Arbitrary, harsh, & not equipped to help only hurt.
Remember & never forget, Dermot Shea (@NYPDShea), head of NYPD, praised his force for their "restraint" in their brutal suppression of peaceful protests & slammed criticism, despite all the video, all witness statements, a Human Rights Watch investigation. nytimes.com/2020/12/18/nyr…
Colleagues-public defenders, civil rights attorney, experts of police misconduct-& I viewed hundreds of videos from early on in protests. We saw violent felonies. Civil rights violations. Patrol guide violations. We found that the NYPD is *unreformable.* nbcnews.com/think/opinion/…
NYT collected 64 videos of extreme violence committed by the NYPD in the first 2 weeks of the protests. In this same period, NYC taxpayers paid NYPD officers *$115 million* in overtime. To assault, maim, choke, beat, & terrorize protestors. We need to talk.nytimes.com/interactive/20…
REPORT: "10 states haven't included incarcerated people in any stage of their vaccine allotment plans." This is disgrace. It's also a public health failure. prisonpolicy.org/blog/2020/12/0…
The states that do not include incarcerated people in any phase of their vaccine allotment plans are: Alaska, Arkansas, Florida, *Kansas, *Michigan, *Oregon, South Carolina, South Dakota, Texas, and *Wisconsin. Four of these states (with *) are run by Democratic governors.
Report Recommendation 1: "Incarcerated people and corrections staff should be prioritized for vaccination against COVID-19. States and the Federal Bureau of Prisons should not consider vaccination of staff as sufficient to stop the spread of COVID-19 in correctional facilities."
OUTRAGEOUS: In Prince George's County, MD, judges routinely "authorize" release instead of set bail. Sounds good, right? No. It really means they pass the buck & the *jail gets to decide if/when a person is released. Result: People stay caged during COVID. taibbi.substack.com/p/what-public-…
"If the defendant is innocent but ends up unjustly jailed for a long time before trial, not the judge’s fault: they 'authorized' release. If the accused gets out & commits a serious crime, also not judge’s fault: it was Pretrial Services (the jail) that released the defendant."
"In the parody of the bail process, judges can punt crucial decisions. Although the system seems not to have been designed for this, as it currently stands, judges facing thorny decisions can buy the equivalent of a political options contract as an alternative to judgment."
A woman plows into Black Lives Matter protestors w/ her car. Gets a ticket. Charged w/ a misdemeanor. Released from precinct. If a Black teen gets caught w/ a gun after an illegal search, no use, only possession, it’s Rikers. Violent felony. Up to 15 years.nypost.com/2020/12/12/dri…
If only the people most targeted by the police for just living, walking down the street—Black & Brown communities in only certain neighborhoods—were treated with the same discretion, leniency, & care as a white woman trying to murder people speaking out against systematic racism.
NYC cops & prosecutors spent years fighting reforms requiring tickets like the one this woman received &/or freeing ppl for misdemeanors/felonies w/ no injury or no intent to cause injury. But run over BLM protestors? They’ll go out of their way to ensure your release.