1st come-1st served is the worst way to do this, especially when it involves people physically arriving and waiting, because it means the most vulnerable people, who need it the most, cannot get it. Appalling, given all the other possible approaches.
The is NO REASON to make seniors -or anyone- wait outside for long periods of time. If you MUST do it 1stC-1stS, do it with some kind of remote registration, or register & go away. They know how many doses they have, how long it takes. NO REASON for that effort & uncertainty. BUT
THERE IS NO REASON TO DO IT FIRST COME FIRST SERVED. They have records of the people living in their county and their ages, and if they don't, now is a great time to have people register so that they do. There are organizations who can access people that might not be registered,
I was shocked when I read that, after Katrina, goods like water were given out 1C1S. See the below account from Smith, James Patterson. Hurricane Katrina: The Mississippi Story. University of Mississippi Press. Jackson: 2012 (bolded are my notes from when I read it) Image
I've seen food distributions done in Darfur that were better organized than that, and it wasn't all that difficult. Unbelievable that this first come-first serve bullshit is the best people can come up with.
it's unnecessary disruption, stress, waste, and harm. & btw, @nytimes , let's not just assume "Scenes like this will surely grow more common nationwide" in the fucking sub-head. Tell people not to do it. Write a story about the better was of doing it. Don't just be sadly resigned
so angry I broke the thread #oops
Still mad. Just for example: you come up with the order first. If it's elderly, what's the age cut-off, etc. You are TRANSPARENT AF about this. Then you contact everyone. You call, email, send alerts to phones, put ads in newspaper & radio & TV, with a phone number & web site.
That's just an example! Is it more work than first come first serve? I don't know, I personally would far rather call a bunch of people than have a bunch of people waiting all night outside my fucking workplace door, and I don't even like calling people!
Alternatively, of course, you can JUST do the ads and wait for people to contact you for scheduling, but it's not as thorough, and the people who are most at risk might not be seeing a lot of ads now. Should be making it easy for them. But still better than 1stC1stS. COMEMIERDAS.
If you're going to go to the trouble of making an order for people to get it in, WHY NOT MAKE A FUCKING ORDER FOR PEOPLE TO GET IT IN?? WHAT GOOD IS YOUR FUCKING BUREAUCRACY EVEN?
I'm yanking these threads over here because I should be writing but I'M STILL ANGRY
What I'm saying is, they make a habit of this in the US, and I don't know why, but I would think some CLEAR GUIDANCE would be useful.
Oh look, a guide (from maybe my least favorite UN agency (don't ask) but anything with a section title of "Numbers, how to live with uncertainty" can't be all bad. YOU DON'T HAVE TO REINVENT THE WHEEL unhcr.org/3c4d44554.pdf
THIS IS NOT A CONCERT TOUR OR A FUCKING STAR WARS MOVIE.
The point is not to give access to those who WANT it most. The point is to give it to those who NEED it most, and give it to them with as little effort on their part as possible.
FUCK YOUR LYING FUCKING FREE MARKET COMEMIERDERÍA
Looking back at the first tweet in this thread and it sounded so measured and calm. No exclamation points even.
Now. I mentioned a few days ago that part of the reason I chose my dissertation had to do with seeing a local official in Japan, with no training, blow off minimum daily water standards. I can give FL county workers the benefit of the doubt. I think I can, anyway. I'm trying. BUT
CAN WE AT LEAST LEARN SOMETHING FROM THIS?
Distributions aren't only for vaccines. Distributions happen in all kinds of disasters. PUT TOGETHER A FUCKING HANDBOOK. OR USE SOMEONE ELSE'S! DO SOME FUCKING PREPAREDNESS WORK.
and on that hopeful note, I'm going to go write about a fantasy world for a while ✌🏼
GRRRRR (I was going to ask about this and then let it be but FUCKING COMEMIERDAS)

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with DOCTORA Malka Older

DOCTORA Malka Older Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @m_older

31 Dec
I'm reading @JincyWillett's very funny Amy Falls Down, which includes a lovely fantasy segment about someone paying for a bunch of writers to train their way across the US doing events with prosecco and some of these writers do not even have books about to come out, AND
I AM STILL MAD that we didn't get an arts stimulus package that, in addition to streaming plays and museum talks and remote concerts, would fund nightly talks and discussions by a wide range of writers and artists. I appreciate all that theaters and bookstore owners have done but
why should they (and we, because I've done lots of unpaid as well as paid events this past year) do it for free?! yes I realize that while the so-called govt is squabbling over the most basic of disaster assistance for stupid reasons we could not expect this but nonetheless we
Read 20 tweets
30 Dec
Module 2 moves on to an offshoot, or symptom, or maybe cause of quantification, as we consider the disproportionate role of economic thinking in how we consider the future, and the ways in which economics and sci-fic are similar. (Hint: lots of economics is imaginary too)
(Reminder: you can read the full syllabus here malkaolder.wordpress.com/2020/12/17/syl… I'm making minor edits as I review for the lectures, such as adjusting discussion questions)
Read 35 tweets
30 Dec
disaster response is all about logistics.
The main reason the Katrina response failed was logistics. Part of that logistics failure was driven by people not caring enough, but part of it was cost-cutting and restructuring, a lot of it related to the establishment of Dept Homeland Security.
A big part of the reason that the Japan tsunami response wasn't worse was because of the voluntary and proactive contributions of private logistics actors - local trucking associations, national shipping companies.
Read 6 tweets
23 Oct
Population is power, borders are arbitrary, and citizenship is an invented category with invented rules that can change at any time. #Infomocracy #Microdemocracy
Imagine if US followed this up, offering a path to citizenship for all Chinese citizens. Boss move in the power struggle, no? Imagine if China retaliated with the same. Then Russia offers citizenship for anyone but has to sweeten it: no taxes 1st 10years! #SpeculativeResistance
Then countries worried about falling populations like Japan decide to chip in a reimbursement for shipping costs if people come as residents on a path to citizenship. Brain drain becomes more of a concern, so countries try to cushy up their educated #SpeculativeResistance
Read 6 tweets
8 Oct
"Believes in democracy" should be the absolute minimum qualification for serving in public office in our aspiring democracy.
As I wrote for @ForeignPolicy, democracy is a principle of government that we should be able to come together around, far more powerful and near-universal than some sort of shared reality foreignpolicy.com/2020/09/25/bui…
But this comemierdería from someone who supposedly got his power from a supposed democracy is not a new argument. Opponents of democracy have long argued that you can get better outcomes if you just let someone - them - be in charge without all the fiddly voting & other people
Read 29 tweets
6 Oct
I'm building the syllabus for the new course on predictive fictions I'm teaching at @ASU_SFIS next semester and there are soooooooo many cool potential readings how am I going to winnow it???
That said, anyone with further ideas is welcome to share them! More cool stuff! More!
The course is going to be sociology + scifi. So far I've got readings on futurism, meteorology, economization (by @epopppp), college rankings, economic forecasts, cost-benefit analysis...
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!